2012 -- H 7559 SUBSTITUTE A AS AMENDED

=======

LC01337/SUB A

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2012

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO COURTS AND CIVIL PROCEDURE--PROCEDURE GENERALLY --

EVIDENCE

     Introduced By: Representatives Tarro, Serpa, and Dickinson

     Date Introduced: February 15, 2012

     Referred To: House Judiciary

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Section 9-19-27 of the General Laws in Chapter 9-19 entitled "Evidence" is

1-2

hereby amended to read as follows:

1-3

     9-19-27. Evidence of charges for medical and hospital services and for prescriptions

1-4

and orthopedic appliances -- Evidence required from hospital medical records. – (a) This

1-5

section is enacted primarily to relieve physicians and the other medical professionals defined

1-6

herein who are associated with hospitals and other health care facilities from the hardship and

1-7

inconvenience of attending court as witnesses, therefore in interpreting this section and the

1-8

medical records exception to the hearsay rules of evidence in court or other related proceedings,

1-9

the trial courts of this state shall liberally construe this section to admit what is presumptively

1-10

reliable medical evidence presented by way of this statutory process without the necessity of

1-11

calling numerous medical personnel as witnesses.

1-12

     (b) In any proceeding commenced in any court, commission, or agency, an itemized bill

1-13

and reports, whether originating within this state or any other state, including hospital or health

1-14

care facility, medical records, relating to medical, dental, hospital services, prescriptions, or

1-15

orthopedic appliances rendered to or prescribed for a person injured, and/or any report of any

1-16

examination of the injured person, including, but not limited to, hospital medical records and

1-17

written statements made by the physician or dentist whether contemporaneous with the treatment

1-18

or not, subscribed and sworn to under the penalties of perjury by the physician, dentist, or

1-19

authorized agent of the hospital or health care facility rendering the services or by the pharmacist

2-1

or retailer of orthopedic appliances, shall be admissible as evidence of the fair and reasonable

2-2

charge for the services and/or the necessity of the services or treatment, the diagnosis of the

2-3

physician or dentist, the prognosis of the physician or dentist; the opinion of the physician or

2-4

dentist as to proximate cause of the condition so diagnosed, and the opinion of the physician or

2-5

dentist as to disability, or incapacity or permanency, if any, proximately resulting from the

2-6

condition so diagnosed; and, provided. Such affidavit may incorporate by reference such other

2-7

records or written statements as are relied upon by the affiant in reaching the opinions set forth in

2-8

the affidavit, if of a type reasonably and customarily relied upon by such providers, and which

2-9

shall thereby provide the necessary foundation for the record relied upon to be independently

2-10

introduced as an exhibit in accordance with the terms herein.

2-11

     The authorized agent of the hospital or health care facility shall be deemed the proper

2-12

agent to subscribe and swear to said written statements contained in its medical records as the

2-13

authorized agent for physicians employed by said hospital or clinic, and rendering treatment to

2-14

the patient during the course of his or her employment. Said records shall not be deemed

2-15

inadmissible because the physician so employed by the hospital or health care facility has not

2-16

subscribed to the affidavit.

2-17

     Provided, further, that written notice of the intention to offer the bill or report as such

2-18

evidence, together with a copy thereof, has been given to the opposing party or parties, or to his

2-19

or her or their attorneys, by mailing the notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, not less

2-20

than ten (10) days before the introduction of the bill or report into evidence, and that an affidavit

2-21

of the notice and the return receipt is filed with the clerk of the court forthwith after the receipt

2-22

has been returned. Nothing contained in this section shall be construed to limit the right of any

2-23

party to the action to summon or depose, at his or her own expense, the physician, dentist,

2-24

pharmacist, retailer of orthopedic appliances, or agent of the hospital for the purpose of cross

2-25

examination with respect to the bill, record, and report or to rebut the contents thereof, or for any

2-26

other purpose, nor to limit the right of any party to the action to summon or depose any other

2-27

person to testify in respect to the bill, record, and/or report or for any other purpose.

2-28

     The adverse party shall be entitled at the expense of the proponent of the affidavit to a

2-29

reasonable opportunity for cross-examination, not to exceed one hour at the office of the

2-30

physician or other expert witness. Additional time for cross-examination shall be at the adverse

2-31

party’s expense. The expert witness fee provided by the proponent of the expert and the

2-32

additional fee, if required on the part of the adverse party, may be included in the costs of the case

2-33

payable to the prevailing party. The time and method of the payment or taxing of such costs shall

2-34

be subject to the order of the trial court.

3-1

      (c)(b) The words "physician", and "dentist" shall not include any person who is not

3-2

licensed to practice as such under the laws of the jurisdiction within which the services were

3-3

rendered, but shall include chiropodists, chiropractors, optometrists, osteopaths, physical

3-4

therapists, psychologists, and other medical paramedics or rescue or emergency medical service

3-5

personnel or ambulating services and other medical, mental health care or social work personnel

3-6

licensed to practice under title 5 or under the laws of the jurisdiction within which the services

3-7

were rendered; provided, that said chiropodists, chiropractors, optometrists, osteopaths, physical

3-8

therapists, psychologists, and other medical, mental health care, or social work personnel

3-9

subscribes to said statements designating his or her licensure, and specifying his or her authority

3-10

to subscribe in said capacity.

3-11

      (d)(c) The word "hospital" shall mean any hospital required to incorporate under title 7,

3-12

or which is in any way licensed or regulated by the laws of any other state, or by the laws and

3-13

regulations of the United States, including hospitals of the veterans’ administration or similar type

3-14

institutions, whether incorporated or not.

3-15

     (e) The words “health care facility” includes those entities referred to in subdivision 23-

3-16

17-2(6) except to the extent that paramedic or rescue or emergency medical service personnel or

3-17

ambulatory service are excluded.

3-18

      (f)(d) Any party objecting to the admitting into evidence of the affidavit shall file an

3-19

objection specifying the grounds thereof within ten (10) days of receipt of the affidavit, or said

3-20

objections are waived.

3-21

     (g) Consistent with federal and state constitutional and statutory guarantees nothing in

3-22

this section shall be construed so as to limit the right of a defendant in a criminal case to confront

3-23

and cross examine witnesses.

3-24

     (h) These provisions shall not apply to claims for personal injury or wrongful death filed

3-25

against a licensed physician, hospital, clinic, health maintenance organization, professional

3-26

service corporation providing health care services, dentist, or dental hygienist based on

3-27

professional negligence.

3-28

     SECTION 2. Chapter 9-19 of the General Laws entitled "Evidence" is hereby amended

3-29

by adding thereto the following section:

3-30

     9-19-27.2. Evidence of charges required from hospitals for medical records, hospital

3-31

services and for prescriptions and orthopedic appliances - Applicable to claims against

3-32

medical providers. – (a) In any proceeding commenced in any court, commission, or agency, an

3-33

itemized bill and reports, whether originating within this state or any other state, including

3-34

hospital medical records, relating to medical, dental, hospital services, prescriptions, or

4-1

orthopedic appliances rendered to or prescribed for a person injured, and/or any report of any

4-2

examination of the injured person, including, but not limited to, hospital medical records

4-3

subscribed and sworn to under the penalties of perjury by the physician, dentist, or authorized

4-4

agent of the hospital rendering the services or by the pharmacist or retailer of orthopedic

4-5

appliances, shall be admissible as evidence of the fair and reasonable charge for the services

4-6

and/or the necessity of the services or treatment, the diagnosis of the physician or dentist, the

4-7

prognosis of the physician or dentist; the opinion of the physician or dentist as to proximate cause

4-8

of the condition so diagnosed, and the opinion of the physician or dentist as to disability or

4-9

incapacity, if any, proximately resulting from the condition so diagnosed; and, provided, further,

4-10

that written notice of the intention to offer the bill or report as such evidence, together with a

4-11

copy thereof, has been given to the opposing party or parties, or to his or her or their attorneys, by

4-12

mailing the notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, not less than ten (10) days before the

4-13

introduction of the bill or report into evidence, and that an affidavit of the notice and the return

4-14

receipt is filed with the clerk of the court forthwith after the receipt has been returned. Nothing

4-15

contained in this section shall be construed to limit the right of any party to the action to summon

4-16

or depose, at his or her own expense, the physician, dentist, pharmacist, retailer of orthopedic

4-17

appliances, or agent of the hospital for the purpose of cross examination with respect to the bill,

4-18

record, and report or to rebut the contents thereof, or for any other purpose, nor to limit the right

4-19

of any party to the action to summon or depose any other person to testify in respect to the bill,

4-20

record, and/or report or for any other purpose.

4-21

      (b) The words "physician", and "dentist" shall not include any person who is not licensed

4-22

to practice as such under the laws of the jurisdiction within which the services were rendered, but

4-23

shall include chiropodists, chiropractors, optometrists, osteopaths, physical therapists,

4-24

psychologists, and other medical personnel licensed to practice under title 5 or under the laws of

4-25

the jurisdiction within which the services were rendered.

4-26

      (c) The word "hospital" shall mean any hospital required to incorporate under title 7, or

4-27

which is in any way licensed or regulated by the laws of any other state, or by the laws and

4-28

regulations of the United States, including hospitals of the veterans administration or similar type

4-29

institutions, whether incorporated or not.

4-30

      (d) Any party objecting to the admitting into evidence of the affidavit shall file an

4-31

objection specifying the grounds thereof within ten (10) days of receipt of the affidavit, or said

4-32

objections are waived.

4-33

     (e) These provisions shall only apply to claims for personal injury or wrongful death filed

4-34

against a licensed physician, hospital, clinic, health maintenance organization, professional

5-1

service corporation providing health care services, dentist, or dental hygienist based on

5-2

professional negligence.

5-3

     SECTION 3. This act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01337/SUB A

========

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO COURTS AND CIVIL PROCEDURE--PROCEDURE GENERALLY --

EVIDENCE

***

6-1

     This act would set forth separate provisions for the admission of medical affidavits into

6-2

evidence without the provider being required to testify in court, based on claims of professional

6-3

negligence against medical providers.

6-4

     This act would take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01337/SUB A

=======

S. 2012 -- H 7559

SUBSTITUTE A

A N A C T

RELATING TO COURTS AND CIVIL PROCEDURE--PROCEDURE GENERALLY -- EVIDENCE

=======

LC01337/SUB A

=======

======================================================================

Presented by