2012 -- H 8006

=======

LC02226

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2012

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO TOWNS AND CITIES -- DISTRESSED COMMUNITIES

     Introduced By: Representatives Brien, and Newberry

     Date Introduced: March 28, 2012

     Referred To: House Finance

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Title 45 of the General Laws entitled "TOWNS AND CITIES" is hereby

1-2

amended by adding thereto the following chapter:

1-3

     CHAPTER 13.2

1-4

HIGHLY DISTRESSED COMMUNITY INTERVENTION ACT

1-5

     45-13.2-1. Short title. – This chapter shall be known and may be cited as the “Highly

1-6

Distressed Community Intervention Act.”

1-7

     45-13.2-2. Purpose. – It shall be the policy of the state to provide ongoing resources and

1-8

tools for, and to intervene on behalf of, cities and towns undergoing extraordinary financial

1-9

distress. The problems that municipalities with financial challenges experience threaten the fiscal

1-10

well-being, public safety and welfare of such cities and towns as well as the state as a whole. The

1-11

state has a right to involve itself in the fiscal affairs of any community that presents multiple

1-12

symptoms of economic stress. The powers delegated by the general assembly in this chapter shall

1-13

be carried out by municipalities in such a manner as will best preserve the safety and welfare of

1-14

citizens of the state and their property and the access of the state and its municipalities to capital

1-15

markets, all to the public benefit and good.

1-16

     45-13.2-3. Legislative findings. – (a) The general assembly finds and declares that:

1-17

     (1) Due to several factors, including, but not limited to, the extreme economic and

1-18

financial pressures experienced on the state and local levels, reductions in the state’s ability to

1-19

appropriate funds for municipal governments, certain structural changes to the manner in which

1-20

the state supports municipal governments, and large unfunded liabilities attributable to retirement

2-1

benefits and other post-employment benefits, the state’s cities and towns face unprecedented

2-2

financial challenges.

2-3

     (2) As of February 2012, several municipalities have perilously and disproportionately

2-4

high property tax burdens relative to the wealth of their taxpayers. Without state intervention,

2-5

financial instability will continue to pose grave problems for the citizens of those communities

2-6

and could introduce additional fiscal problems for other communities as well as the state.

2-7

     (3) It is in the best interests of municipalities, taxpayers, and the state itself to maintain

2-8

the fiscal well-being, public safety, welfare and sovereignty of the municipalities. These

2-9

compelling state interests include:

2-10

     (i) Preserving, to the fullest extent practicable, the principle of home rule as it is

2-11

enshrined in Article XIII of the Rhode Island Constitution, without jeopardizing the economic

2-12

stability of the various municipalities and the state;

2-13

     (ii) Empowering municipalities to utilize financial resources and tools that are reasonably

2-14

necessary to allow them to achieve self-sufficiency within the shortest possible timeframe; and

2-15

     (iii) Preventing the financial downgrade of municipalities by rating agencies, which

2-16

would make it more difficult to access the capital markets and increase the costs of borrowing.

2-17

     (b) For the foregoing reasons, the general assembly expressly finds and declares that the

2-18

situation confronting several municipalities has reached a stage of emergency requiring state

2-19

intervention and relief, and must be addressed without delay and the enactment of this chapter is

2-20

reasonable and necessary to achieve and protect the compelling public interests listed herein.

2-21

     45-13.2-4. Eligibility. – In order for a highly distressed community to be eligible for

2-22

relief under this chapter, its municipal council shall have adopted an ordinance or charter

2-23

amendment assuming any one, or more than one, of the relief provisions set forth in section 45-

2-24

13.2-6, which ordinance or charter amendment shall be supported by:

2-25

     (1) A finding that the ordinance or charter amendment is reasonable and necessary to

2-26

ameliorate the municipality’s property tax burden relative to its citizens’ wealth, thereby

2-27

supporting such municipality’s fiscal stability and protecting its property, and the health, welfare

2-28

and property of its citizens; and

2-29

     (2) Findings demonstrating that alternatives to enacting the particular policies set forth in

2-30

section 45-13.2-6 have been and/or are being implemented. For purposes of this chapter, “highly

2-31

distressed community” means a municipality that falls into the lowest twenty percent (20%) of all

2-32

four (4) indices established by section 45-13-12, as determined by the director of revenue on an

2-33

annual basis pursuant to section 45-13-12.

3-34

     45-13.2-5. Collective bargaining contracts. – During any fiscal year in which a

3-35

municipality has been designated as a highly distressed community and until it is no longer taking

3-36

advantage of the relief provisions enumerated under section 45-13.2-6, its municipal council shall

3-37

be required to:

3-38

     (1) Estimate the financial impact of any collective bargaining contract proposal on the

3-39

taxpayers of that community;

3-40

     (2) Balance such financial impact against the community’s ability to pay; and

3-41

     (3) Take such balance into account before deciding to approve or disapprove the

3-42

collective bargaining contract.

3-43

     45-13.2-6. Relief provisions. – During any fiscal year in which a municipality is

3-44

designated as a highly distressed community pursuant to section 45-13.2-4 and for two (2) years

3-45

after it is no longer so designated, its municipal council shall be authorized and empowered to

3-46

adopt an ordinance or charter amendment specifying any of the following relief provisions (which

3-47

relief provisions shall be automatically repealed, and shall have no legal force or effect, as of two

3-48

(2) years after the date that the municipality is no longer designated as a highly distressed

3-49

community):

3-50

     (1) Purchasing. During any fiscal year that a municipality has been designated as a highly

3-51

distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance or charter amendment that

3-52

requires municipal purchasing to be conducted in accordance with sections 37-2-56 and/or 16-60-

3-53

7.3.

3-54

     (2) Continuance of contractual provisions. During any fiscal year that a municipality has

3-55

been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance

3-56

or charter amendment that suspends sections 28-9.1-17 and/or 28-9.2-17.

3-57

     (3) Retirement of sick or injured police officers and fire fighters. During any fiscal year

3-58

that a municipality has been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council

3-59

may adopt an ordinance or charter amendment that revises the disability retirement allowance

3-60

provided under section 45-19-19 to between fifty percent (50%) and sixty-six and two-thirds

3-61

percent (66 2/3%) of a retiree's annual salary at the time of retirement, subject to the provisions of

3-62

section 45-21-31.

3-63

     (4) Educational incentive pay. During any fiscal year that a municipality has been

3-64

designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance or

3-65

charter amendment that suspends chapter 28.1 of title 42.

3-66

     (5) Consolidation of administrative functions. During any fiscal year that a municipality

3-67

has been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an

3-68

ordinance or charter amendment that authorizes and empowers its chief executive officer or the

4-1

town manager or town administrator to consolidate some or all responsibilities with respect to the

4-2

following under a single person or a unified position, as may be most appropriate: municipal

4-3

administrative functions and non-educational functions that are or may be included under chapter

4-4

2 of title 16, including, but not limited to, human resources, information technology, budgetary

4-5

and financial management, procurement, disbursement, and/or facilities management.

4-6

     (6) Municipal budget and contract approvals. During any fiscal year that a municipality

4-7

has been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an

4-8

ordinance or charter amendment that, notwithstanding the provisions of section 16-2-9, requires

4-9

the approval of the municipality’s chief executive officer or the town manager or town

4-10

administrator with respect to: (i) Any school budget, with line item veto power in respect thereto;

4-11

(ii) Any changes to the school budget during the course of the school year; and/or (iii) Any and

4-12

all contractual arrangements entered into by the school committee.

4-13

     (7) Teacher step increases. During any fiscal year that a municipality has been designated

4-14

as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance or charter

4-15

amendment that suspends section 16-7-29.

4-16

     (8) Certified nurses. During any fiscal year that a municipality has been designated as a

4-17

highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance or charter

4-18

amendment that suspends section 16-21-8 and requires that the functions performed by such

4-19

nurse-teachers be performed by certified nurses, consistent with policies, procedures and

4-20

regulations promulgated by the board of regents for elementary and secondary education.

4-21

     (9) School bus monitors. During any fiscal year that a municipality has been designated

4-22

as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance or charter

4-23

amendment that suspends section 16-21-1. Any such ordinance or charter amendment may

4-24

require the functions performed by school bus monitors be fulfilled on a volunteer basis.

4-25

     (10) Transportation to nonpublic schools. During any fiscal year that a municipality has

4-26

been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance

4-27

or charter amendment that suspends any mandate pursuant to chapter 21.1 of title 16 to provide

4-28

bus transportation to pupils who attend nonpublic nonprofit schools that are consolidated,

4-29

regionalized, or otherwise established to serve residents of a specific area within the state.

4-30

     (11) Health insurance cost sharing and plan design. During any fiscal year that a

4-31

municipality has been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may

4-32

adopt an ordinance or charter amendment that requires future negotiated changes for active

4-33

employees under chapters 9.1, 9.2, 9.3 and/or 9.4 of title 28, relating to cost sharing and plan

4-34

design of health insurance, be applicable to new and existing retirements under the same chapters.

5-1

     (12) Public safety collective bargaining. During any fiscal year that a municipality has

5-2

been designated as a highly distressed community, its municipal council may adopt an ordinance

5-3

or charter amendment that amends sections of the general laws of Rhode Island as set forth in

5-4

subdivisions (1) and/or (2) of this section related to fire fighters’ or police officers’ collective

5-5

bargaining rights, respectively.

5-6

     45-13.2-7. Mandatory reinvestment; Annual certifications. – (a) At least fifty percent

5-7

(50%) of funds resulting from enacting an ordinance or charter amendment pursuant to this

5-8

chapter shall be reinvested exclusively to reduce a highly distressed community’s property tax

5-9

burden or to limit growth of a highly distressed community’s property tax burden, at least until

5-10

such municipality is no longer designated as a highly distressed community and is no longer

5-11

taking advantage of the relief provisions enumerated under section 45-13.2-6.

5-12

     (b) Every highly distressed community shall submit a certification to the auditor general

5-13

and the director of revenue no later than one year after the date of passage of the ordinance or

5-14

charter amendment declaring that the municipality has assumed such designation, which

5-15

certification shall contain budgetary and numerical data sufficient to substantiate the satisfaction

5-16

of subsection (a) of this section. This certification requirement shall continue, on an annual basis

5-17

as measured from the date of passage of the ordinance or charter amendment, until a municipality

5-18

is no longer designated as a highly distressed community and is no longer taking advantage of the

5-19

relief provisions enumerated under section 45-13.2-6.

5-20

     45-13.2-8. Failure to comply. – With respect to any municipality that fails to comply

5-21

with section 45-13.2-4 or 45-13.2-7:

5-22

     (1) The general treasurer is authorized to withhold moneys due from the state for any

5-23

purpose other than education, including, but not limited to, municipal aid and other aid provided

5-24

under sections 45-13-5.1, 45-13-12, 44-34.1-2, 44-13-13, 44-18-18.1, 44-18-36.1(b) and 42-63.1-

5-25

3; and

5-26

     (2) The auditor general shall have the power to compel a performance audit in connection

5-27

with such municipality, as provided under section 22-13-4.

5-28

     45-13.2-9. Supersession; Exclusivity. – Notwithstanding any general or special law to

5-29

the contrary, unless otherwise specified, the provisions of this chapter shall supersede any

5-30

conflicting provisions of a local ordinance, collective bargaining agreement, interest arbitration

5-31

award, or municipal charter; further, the inclusion of any particular provision in this chapter shall

5-32

not be construed in a manner indicating that a municipality has no right to take action with

5-33

respect to the substance of such provision but for this chapter.

6-34

     SECTION 2. Sections 28-9.1-3, 28-9.1-9, 28-9.1-10 and 28-9.1-16 of the General Laws

6-35

in Chapter 28-9.1 entitled "Firefighters' Arbitration" are hereby amended to read as follows:

6-36

     28-9.1-3. Definitions. -- As used in this chapter the following terms, unless the context

6-37

requires a different interpretation, shall have the following meanings:

6-38

      (1) "Base salaries" means the annual salary pursuant to the salary schedule or salary

6-39

chart contained in the collective bargaining agreement between the corporate authorities and the

6-40

bargaining unit exclusive of any monies provided for length of service or longevity, overtime

6-41

payments, incentive pay payments, special duty payments, detail payments and any non-salary

6-42

economic issues such as pensions, health and medical insurance costs.

6-43

     (1)(2)"Corporate authorities" means the proper officials within any city or town whose

6-44

duty or duties it is to establish the wages, salaries, rates of pay, hours, working conditions, and

6-45

other terms and conditions of employment of fire fighters, whether they are the mayor, city

6-46

manager, town manager, town administrator, city council, town council, director of personnel,

6-47

personnel board or commission, or by whatever other name or combination of names they may be

6-48

designated.

6-49

     (2)(3) "Fire fighter" means the permanent uniformed members, rescue service personnel

6-50

of any city or town, emergency medical services personnel of any city or town, any fire

6-51

dispatchers of any city or town, and all employees with the exception of fire chiefs of any paid

6-52

fire department in any city or town within the state. No assistant chief, deputy chief, battalion

6-53

chief, captain or lieutenant shall be excluded from the collective bargaining solely by virtue of his

6-54

or her title or position.

6-55

     (3)(4) "Unresolved issues" means any and all contractual provisions specifically

6-56

addressing base salaries which have not been agreed upon by the bargaining agent and the

6-57

corporate authorities within the thirty (30) day period referred to in section 28-9.1-7. Any

6-58

contractual provision not presented by either the bargaining agent or the corporate authority

6-59

within the thirty (30) day period shall not be submitted to arbitration as an unresolved issue;

6-60

provided, that if either party or both parties are unable to present their respective proposals to the

6-61

other party during the thirty (30) day period, they shall have the opportunity to submit their

6-62

proposals by registered mail by midnight of the 30th day from and including the date of their first

6-63

meeting.

6-64

     28-9.1-9. Hearings. -- (a) The arbitration board shall, acting through its chairperson, call

6-65

a hearing to be held within ten (10) days after the date of the appointment of the chairperson, and

6-66

shall, acting through its chairperson, give at least seven (7) days notice in writing to each of the

6-67

other two (2) arbitrators, the bargaining agent, and the corporate authorities of the time and place

6-68

of the hearing. The hearing shall be informal, and the rules of evidence prevailing in judicial

7-1

proceedings shall not be binding. Any documentary evidence and other data deemed relevant by

7-2

the arbitrators may be received in evidence.

7-3

      (b) The arbitrators shall have the power to administer oaths and to require by subpoena

7-4

the attendance and testimony of witnesses, and the production of books, records, and other

7-5

evidence relative or pertinent to the issues presented to them for determination.

7-6

     (c) All parties to arbitration shall present, at the formal hearings before the issuance of the

7-7

award, written estimates to the arbitration panel of the financial impact of their contract proposal

7-8

on the taxpayers of the city or town that employs the members of the bargaining unit.

7-9

     (d) Each arbitration decision shall be accompanied by a written report explaining how

7-10

each of the statutory factors contained in section 28-9.1-10 played into the arbitrators’

7-11

determination of the final award. The report shall certify that the arbitration board gave primary

7-12

weight to the community’s ability to pay and a comparison of the wages and other benefits of

7-13

employment of employees with the economic conditions of residents of the community, and that

7-14

it took into account the statutory limitations imposed on the local levy cap in making the award.

7-15

     (c)(e) The hearing conducted by the arbitrators shall be concluded within twenty (20)

7-16

days of the time of commencement, and within ten (10) days after the conclusion of the hearings,

7-17

the arbitrators shall make written findings and a written opinion upon the issues presented, a copy

7-18

of which shall be mailed or otherwise delivered to the bargaining agent or its attorney or

7-19

otherwise designated representative and the corporate authorities. The chairperson may require

7-20

briefs of the parties, in which case the time for issuance of the award shall be extended by no

7-21

more than ten (10) days.

7-22

      (f) The chairperson of the arbitration board shall be required to render an arbitration

7-23

award within the aforementioned timeframes and under no circumstances shall the timeframes

7-24

provided for in this section be exceeded. Any chairperson who fails to render an award within the

7-25

time requirements set forth in this section shall be fined one thousand dollars ($1,000) by the

7-26

courts for each day that the award is late.

7-27

      (d)(g) A majority decision of the arbitrators shall be binding upon both the bargaining

7-28

agent and the corporate authorities.

7-29

     (h) Any arbitration board created pursuant to this chapter shall not issue a decision which

7-30

increases the aggregate base salaries of the employees in the bargaining unit in an amount greater

7-31

than two percent (2%).

7-32

     28-9.1-10. Factors to be considered by arbitration board. – The arbitrators shall

7-33

conduct the hearings and render their decision upon the basis of a prompt, peaceful, and just

7-34

settlement of wage or hour disputes between the fire fighters and the city or town by which they

8-1

are employed. The factors, among others, to be given weight by the arbitrators in arriving at a

8-2

decision shall include:

8-3

     (1) The overall compensation presently received by the employees, inclusive of direct

8-4

wages, salary, vacations, holidays, excused leaves, insurance and pensions, medical and

8-5

hospitalization benefits, and all other economic benefits received while in the employ of the city

8-6

or town or from the city or town upon the retirement of any member of the bargaining unit as

8-7

compared with the economic conditions of residents of the community.

8-8

      (1)(2) Comparison of wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of the fire

8-9

department in question with prevailing wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of skilled

8-10

employees of the building trades and industry in the local operating area involved.

8-11

      (2)(3) Comparison of wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of the fire

8-12

department in question with wage rates or hourly conditions of employment maintained for the

8-13

same or similar work of employees exhibiting like or similar skills under the same or similar

8-14

working conditions in the local operating area involved.

8-15

      (3)(4) Comparison of wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of the fire

8-16

department in question with wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of fire departments in

8-17

cities or towns of comparable size.

8-18

      (4)(5) Interest and welfare of the public. Among the items the panel of arbitrators shall

8-19

assess when considering this factor is the limitation imposed upon the employers by section 44-5-

8-20

2.

8-21

      (5)(6) Comparison of peculiarities of employment in regard to other trades or

8-22

professions, specifically:

8-23

      (i) Hazards of employment.

8-24

      (ii) Physical qualifications.

8-25

      (iii) Educational qualifications.

8-26

      (iv) Mental qualifications.

8-27

      (v) Job training and skills.

8-28

      (6)(7) Comparison of community's ability to pay.

8-29

     28-9.1-16. Attorneys' fees -- Costs -- Interest. – (a) In the event either the bargaining

8-30

agent or the corporate authorities files a petition for writ of certiorari to the supreme court of the

8-31

state of Rhode Island for a review or modification of a majority decision of the arbitrators, which

8-32

by the provisions of section 28-9.1-9 is binding upon both the bargaining agent and the corporate

8-33

authorities, the party against whom the decision of the supreme court is adverse, if the supreme

8-34

court finds the appeal or petition to be frivolous, shall pay reasonable attorneys' fees and costs to

9-1

the successful party as determined by the supreme court, and the supreme court shall in its final

9-2

decision or judgment award costs and reasonable attorneys' fees. If the final decision affirms the

9-3

award of money, the award, if retroactive, shall bear interest at the rate of eight percentum

9-4

percent (8%) per annum from the effective retroactive date.

9-5

     (b) In the event either the bargaining agent or the corporate authorities files a petition for

9-6

writ of certiorari to the supreme court, said petition shall be filed within sixty (60) days from the

9-7

date the parties were in receipt of the written decision of the arbitration board.

9-8

     SECTION 3. Sections 28-9.2-3, 28-9.2-9, 28-9.2-10 and 28-9.2-16 of the General Laws

9-9

in Chapter 28-9.2 entitled "Municipal Police Arbitration" are hereby amended to read as follows:

9-10

     28-9.2-3. Definitions. -- As used in this chapter the following terms, unless the context

9-11

requires a different interpretation, have the following meanings:

9-12

     (1) "Base salaries" means the annual salary pursuant to the salary schedule or salary chart

9-13

contained in the collective bargaining agreement between the corporate authorities and the

9-14

bargaining unit exclusive of any monies provided for length of service or longevity, overtime

9-15

payments, incentive pay payments, special duty payments, detail payments and any non-salary

9-16

economic issues such as pensions, health and medical insurance costs.

9-17

     (1)(2) "Corporate authorities" means the proper officials within any city or town whose

9-18

duty or duties it is to establish the wages, salaries, rates of pay, hours, working conditions, and

9-19

other terms and conditions of employment of police officers, whether they are the mayor, city

9-20

manager, town manager, town administrator, city council, town council, director of personnel,

9-21

personnel board or commission, or by whatever other name they may be designated, or any

9-22

combination thereof.

9-23

      (2)(3) "Police officer" means a full-time police officer from the rank of patrolman up to

9-24

and including the rank of chief, including policewomen, of any particular police department in

9-25

any city or town within the state.

9-26

     (4) "Unresolved issues" means any and all contractual provisions specifically addressing

9-27

base salaries which have not been agreed upon by the bargaining agent and the corporate

9-28

authorities within the thirty (30) day period referred to in section 28-9.2-7. Any contractual

9-29

provision not presented by either the bargaining agent or the corporate authority within the thirty

9-30

(30) day period shall not be submitted to arbitration as an unresolved issue; provided, that if

9-31

either party or both parties are unable to present their respective proposals to the other party

9-32

during the thirty (30) day period, they shall have the opportunity to submit their proposals by

9-33

registered mail by midnight of the thirtieth (30th) day from and including the date of their first

9-34

meeting.

10-1

     28-9.2-9. Hearings. -- (a) The arbitration board shall, acting through its chairperson, call

10-2

a hearing to be held within ten (10) days after the date of the appointment of the chairperson, and

10-3

shall, acting through its chairperson, give at least seven (7) days notice in writing to each of the

10-4

other two (2) arbitrators, the bargaining agent, and the corporate authorities of the time and place

10-5

of the hearing. The hearing shall be informal, and the rules of evidence prevailing in judicial

10-6

proceedings shall not be binding. Any documentary evidence and other data deemed relevant by

10-7

the arbitrators may be received in evidence.

10-8

      (b) The arbitrators shall have the power to administer oaths and to require by subpoena

10-9

the attendance and testimony of witnesses, and the production of books, records, and other

10-10

evidence relative or pertinent to the issues presented to them for determination.

10-11

     (c) All parties to arbitration shall present, at the formal hearings before the issuance of the

10-12

award, written estimates to the arbitration panel of the financial impact of their contract proposal

10-13

on the taxpayers of the city or town that employs the members of the bargaining unit.

10-14

     (d) Each arbitration decision shall be accompanied by a written report explaining how

10-15

each of the statutory factors contained in section 28-9.2-10 played into the arbitrators’

10-16

determination of the final award. The report shall certify that the arbitration board gave primary

10-17

weight to the community’s ability to pay and a comparison of the wages and other benefits of

10-18

employment of employees with the economic conditions of residents of the community, and that

10-19

it took into account the statutory limitations imposed on the local levy cap in making the award.

10-20

     (c)(e) The hearing conducted by the arbitrators shall be concluded within twenty (20)

10-21

days of the time of commencement, and within ten (10) days after the conclusion of the hearings,

10-22

the arbitrators shall make written findings and a written opinion upon the issues presented, a copy

10-23

of which shall be mailed or otherwise delivered to the bargaining agent or its attorney or

10-24

otherwise delegated representative and to the corporate authorities. The chairperson may require

10-25

briefs of the parties, in which case the time for issuance of the award shall be extended by no

10-26

more than ten (10) days.

10-27

      (f) The chairperson of the arbitration board shall be required to render an arbitration

10-28

award within the aforementioned timeframes and under no circumstances shall the timeframes

10-29

provided for in this section be exceeded. Any chairperson who fails to render an award within the

10-30

time requirements set forth in this section shall be fined one thousand dollars ($1,000) by the

10-31

courts for each day that the award is late.

10-32

      (d)(g) A majority decision of the arbitrators is binding on both the bargaining agent and

10-33

the corporate authorities.

11-34

     (h) Any arbitration board created pursuant to this chapter shall not issue a decision which

11-35

increases the aggregate base salaries of the employees in the bargaining unit in an amount greater

11-36

than two percent (2%).

11-37

     28-9.2-10. Factors to be considered by arbitration board. -- The arbitrators shall

11-38

conduct the hearings and render their decision on the basis of a prompt, peaceful, and just

11-39

settlement of wage or hour disputes between the police officers and the city or town by which

11-40

they are employed. The factors, among others, to be given weight by the arbitrators in arriving at

11-41

a decision shall include:

11-42

     (1) The overall compensation presently received by the employees, inclusive of direct

11-43

wages, salary, vacations, holidays, excused leaves, insurance and pensions, medical and

11-44

hospitalization benefits, and all other economic benefits received while in the employ of the city

11-45

or town or from the city or town upon the retirement of any member of the bargaining unit as

11-46

compared with the economic conditions of residents of the community.

11-47

      (1)(2) Comparison of wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of the police

11-48

department in question with prevailing wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of skilled

11-49

employees of the building trades and industry in the local operating area involved.

11-50

      (2)(3) Comparison of wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of the police

11-51

department in question with wage rates or hourly conditions of employment of police

11-52

departments in cities or towns of comparable size.

11-53

      (3)(4) Interest and welfare of the public. Among items the panel of arbitrators shall

11-54

assess when considering this factor is the limitation imposed upon the employer by section 44-5-

11-55

2.

11-56

      (4)(5) Comparison of peculiarities of employment in regard to other trades or

11-57

professions, specifically:

11-58

      (i) Hazards of employment.

11-59

      (ii) Physical qualifications.

11-60

      (iii) Educational qualifications.

11-61

      (iv) Mental qualifications.

11-62

      (v) Job training and skills.

11-63

      (5)(6) Comparison of community's ability to pay.

11-64

     28-9.2-16. Attorney's fees -- Costs -- Interest. – (a) If either the bargaining agent or the

11-65

corporate authorities files a petition for writ of certiorari to the supreme court of the state of

11-66

Rhode Island for a review or modification of a majority decision of the arbitrators, which by the

11-67

provisions of section 28-9.2-9 is binding upon both the bargaining agent and the corporate

11-68

authorities, the party against whom the decision of the supreme court is adverse, if the supreme

12-1

court finds the appeal or petition to be frivolous, shall pay reasonable attorney's fees and costs to

12-2

the successful party as determined by the supreme court, and the supreme court shall in its final

12-3

decision or judgment award costs and reasonable attorney's fees. If the final decision affirms the

12-4

award of money, the award, if retroactive, shall bear interest at the rate of eight percent (8%) per

12-5

annum from the effective retroactive date.

12-6

     (b) In the event either the bargaining agent or the corporate authorities files a petition for

12-7

writ of certiorari to the supreme court, said petition shall be filed within sixty (60) days from the

12-8

date the parties were in receipt of the written decision of the arbitration board.

12-9

     SECTION 4. Severability. If any provision of this act or the application thereof to any

12-10

person or circumstances is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect other provisions or

12-11

applications of the act, which can be given effect without the invalid provision or applications,

12-12

and to this end the provisions of this act are declared to be severable.

12-13

     SECTION 5. This act shall take effect upon passage; provided, however, that the

12-14

provisions and amendments to the general laws contained in Sections 2 and 3 of this act shall

12-15

only apply to municipalities that are highly distressed, as defined under sections 45-13-12 and 45-

12-16

13.2-4 of the general laws and that have invoked the provisions of chapter 45-13.2 of the general

12-17

laws by the adoption of an ordinance or charter amendment.

=======

LC02226

=======

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO TOWNS AND CITIES -- DISTRESSED COMMUNITIES

***

13-1

     This act would extend to communities which have been determined to be “highly

13-2

distressed communities” by reference to section 45-13-12 of the general laws additional

13-3

authorization to act in modification of police and fire labor contracts.

13-4

     This act would take effect upon passage, provided; however, that the provisions and

13-5

amendments to the general laws contained in Sections 2 and 3 of this act would only apply to

13-6

municipalities that are highly distressed, as defined under sections 45-13-12 and 45-13.2-4 of the

13-7

general laws and that have invoked the provisions of chapter 45-13.2 of the general laws by the

13-8

adoption of an ordinance or charter amendment.

=======

LC02226

=======