2012 -- S 2053

=======

LC00041

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2012

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO MOTOR AN OTHER VEHICLES - MOTOR VEHICLE OFFENSES

     Introduced By: Senators Tassoni, Lynch, Jabour, and Doyle

     Date Introduced: January 11, 2012

     Referred To: Senate Judiciary

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Section 31-27-2 of the General Laws in Chapter 31-27 entitled "Motor

1-2

Vehicle Offenses" is hereby amended to read as follows:

1-3

     31-27-2. Driving under influence of liquor or drugs. -- (a) Whoever drives or

1-4

otherwise operates any vehicle in the state while under the influence of any intoxicating liquor,

1-5

drugs, toluene, or any controlled substance as defined in chapter 28 of title 21, or any

1-6

combination of these, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor except as provided in subdivision (d)(3)

1-7

and shall be punished as provided in subsection (d) of this section.

1-8

      (b) (1) Any person charged under subsection (a) of this section whose blood alcohol

1-9

concentration is eight one-hundredths of one percent (.08%) or more by weight as shown by a

1-10

chemical analysis of a blood, breath, or urine sample shall be guilty of violating subsection (a) of

1-11

this section. This provision shall not preclude a conviction based on other admissible evidence.

1-12

Proof of guilt under this section may also be based on evidence that the person charged was under

1-13

the influence of intoxicating liquor, drugs, toluene, or any controlled substance defined in chapter

1-14

28 of title 21, or any combination of these, to a degree which rendered the person incapable of

1-15

safely operating a vehicle. The fact that any person charged with violating this section is or has

1-16

been legally entitled to use alcohol or a drug shall not constitute a defense against any charge of

1-17

violating this section.

1-18

      (2) Whoever drives or otherwise operates any vehicle in the state with a blood presence

1-19

of any scheduled controlled substance as defined within chapter 28 of title 21, as shown by

1-20

analysis of a blood or urine sample, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and shall be punished as

2-1

provided in subsection (d) of this section.

2-2

      (c) In any criminal prosecution for a violation of subsection (a) of this section, evidence

2-3

as to the amount of intoxicating liquor, toluene, or any controlled substance as defined in chapter

2-4

28 of title 21, or any combination of these, in the defendant's blood at the time alleged as shown

2-5

by a chemical analysis of the defendant's breath, blood, or urine or other bodily substance shall be

2-6

admissible and competent, provided that evidence is presented that the following conditions have

2-7

been complied with:

2-8

      (1) The defendant has consented to the taking of the test upon which the analysis is

2-9

made. Evidence that the defendant had refused to submit to the test shall not be admissible unless

2-10

the defendant elects to testify.

2-11

      (2) A true copy of the report of the test result was mailed within seventy-two (72) hours

2-12

of the taking of the test to the person submitting to a breath test.

2-13

      (3) Any person submitting to a chemical test of blood, urine, or other body fluids shall

2-14

have a true copy of the report of the test result mailed to him or her within thirty (30) days

2-15

following the taking of the test.

2-16

      (4) The test was performed according to methods and with equipment approved by the

2-17

director of the department of health of the state of Rhode Island and by an authorized individual.

2-18

      (5) Equipment used for the conduct of the tests by means of breath analysis had been

2-19

tested for accuracy within thirty (30) days preceding the test by personnel qualified as

2-20

hereinbefore provided, and breathalyzer operators shall be qualified and certified by the

2-21

department of health within three hundred sixty-five (365) days of the test.

2-22

      (6) The person arrested and charged with operating a motor vehicle while under the

2-23

influence of intoxicating liquor, toluene, or any controlled substance as defined in chapter 28 of

2-24

title 21, or, any combination of these in violation of subsection (a) of this section was afforded the

2-25

opportunity to have an additional chemical test. The officer arresting or so charging the person

2-26

shall have informed the person of this right and afforded him or her a reasonable opportunity to

2-27

exercise this right, and a notation to this effect is made in the official records of the case in the

2-28

police department. Refusal to permit an additional chemical test shall render incompetent and

2-29

inadmissible in evidence the original report.

2-30

      (d) (1) (i) Every person found to have violated subdivision (b)(1) of this section shall be

2-31

sentenced as follows: for a first violation whose blood alcohol concentration is eight one-

2-32

hundredths of one percent (.08%) but less than one-tenth of one percent (.1%) by weight or who

2-33

has a blood presence of any scheduled controlled substance as defined in subdivision (b)(2) shall

2-34

be subject to a fine of not less than one hundred dollars ($100) nor more than three hundred

3-1

dollars ($300), shall be required to perform ten (10) to sixty (60) hours of public community

3-2

restitution, and/or shall be imprisoned for up to one year. The sentence may be served in any unit

3-3

of the adult correctional institutions in the discretion of the sentencing judge and/or shall be

3-4

required to attend a special course on driving while intoxicated or under the influence of a

3-5

controlled substance; provided, however, that the court may permit a servicemember or veteran to

3-6

complete any court-approved counseling program administered or approved by the Veterans'

3-7

Administration, and his or her driver's license shall be suspended for thirty (30) days up to one

3-8

hundred eighty (180) days.

3-9

      (ii) Every person convicted of a first violation whose blood alcohol concentration is one-

3-10

tenth of one percent (.1%) by weight or above but less than fifteen hundredths of one percent

3-11

(.15%) or whose blood alcohol concentration is unknown shall be subject to a fine of not less than

3-12

one hundred ($100) dollars nor more than four hundred dollars ($400) and shall be required to

3-13

perform ten (10) to sixty (60) hours of public community restitution and/or shall be imprisoned

3-14

for up to one year. The sentence may be served in any unit of the adult correctional institutions in

3-15

the discretion of the sentencing judge. The person's driving license shall be suspended for a

3-16

period of three (3) months to twelve (12) months. The sentencing judge shall require attendance

3-17

at a special course on driving while intoxicated or under the influence of a controlled substance

3-18

and/or alcoholic or drug treatment for the individual; provided, however, that the court may

3-19

permit a servicemember or veteran to complete any court-approved counseling program

3-20

administered or approved by the Veterans' Administration.

3-21

      (iii) Every person convicted of a first offense whose blood alcohol concentration is

3-22

fifteen hundredths of one percent (.15%) or above, or who is under the influence of a drug,

3-23

toluene, or any controlled substance as defined in subdivision (b)(1) shall be subject to a fine of

3-24

five hundred dollars ($500) and shall be required to perform twenty (20) to sixty (60) hours of

3-25

public community restitution and/or shall be imprisoned for up to one year. The sentence may be

3-26

served in any unit of the adult correctional institutions in the discretion of the sentencing judge.

3-27

The person's driving license shall be suspended for a period of three (3) months to eighteen (18)

3-28

months. The sentencing judge shall require attendance at a special course on driving while

3-29

intoxicated or under the influence of a controlled substance and/or alcohol or drug treatment for

3-30

the individual; provided, however, that the court may permit a servicemember or veteran to

3-31

complete any court-approved counseling program administered or approved by the Veterans'

3-32

Administration.

3-33

      (2) (i) Every person convicted of a second violation within a five (5) year period with a

3-34

blood alcohol concentration of eight one-hundredths of one percent (.08%) or above but less than

4-1

fifteen hundredths of one percent (.15%) or whose blood alcohol concentration is unknown or

4-2

who has a blood presence of any controlled substance as defined in subdivision (b)(2), and every

4-3

person convicted of a second violation within a five (5) year period regardless of whether the

4-4

prior violation and subsequent conviction was a violation and subsequent conviction under this

4-5

statute or under the driving under the influence of liquor or drugs statute of any other state, shall

4-6

be subject to a mandatory fine of four hundred dollars ($400). The person's driving license shall

4-7

be suspended for a period of one year to two (2) years, and the individual shall be sentenced to

4-8

not less than ten (10) days nor more than one year in jail. The sentence may be served in any unit

4-9

of the adult correctional institutions in the discretion of the sentencing judge; however, not less

4-10

than forty-eight (48) hours of imprisonment shall be served consecutively. The sentencing judge

4-11

shall require alcohol or drug treatment for the individual; provided, however, that the court may

4-12

permit a servicemember or veteran to complete any court-approved counseling program

4-13

administered or approved by the Veterans' Administration and may prohibit that person from

4-14

operating a motor vehicle that is not equipped with an ignition interlock system for a period of

4-15

one year to two (2) years following the completion of the sentence as provided in section 31-27-

4-16

2.8.

4-17

      (ii) Every person convicted of a second violation within a five (5) year period whose

4-18

blood alcohol concentration is fifteen hundredths of one percent (.15%) or above by weight as

4-19

shown by a chemical analysis of a blood, breath, or urine sample or who is under the influence of

4-20

a drug, toluene, or any controlled substance as defined in subdivision (b)(1) shall be subject to

4-21

mandatory imprisonment of not less than six (6) months nor more than one year, a mandatory fine

4-22

of not less than one thousand dollars ($1,000) and a mandatory license suspension for a period of

4-23

two (2) years from the date of completion of the sentence imposed under this subsection. The

4-24

sentencing judge shall require alcohol or drug treatment for the individual; provided, however,

4-25

that the court may permit a servicemember or veteran to complete any court approved counseling

4-26

program administered or approved by the Veterans' Administration.

4-27

      (3) (i) Every person convicted of a third or subsequent violation within a five (5) year

4-28

period with a blood alcohol concentration of eight one-hundredths of one percent (.08%) or above

4-29

but less than fifteen hundredths of one percent (.15%) or whose blood alcohol concentration is

4-30

unknown or who has a blood presence of any scheduled controlled substance as defined in

4-31

subdivision (b)(2) regardless of whether any prior violation and subsequent conviction was a

4-32

violation and subsequent conviction under this statute or under the driving under the influence of

4-33

liquor or drugs statute of any other state, shall be guilty of a felony and be subject to a mandatory

4-34

fine of four hundred ($400) dollars. The person's driving license shall be suspended for a period

5-1

of two (2) years to three (3) years, and the individual shall be sentenced to not less than one year

5-2

and not more than three (3) years in jail. The sentence may be served in any unit of the adult

5-3

correctional institutions in the discretion of the sentencing judge; however, not less than forty-

5-4

eight (48) hours of imprisonment shall be served consecutively. The sentencing judge shall

5-5

require alcohol or drug treatment for the individual; provided, however, that the court may permit

5-6

a servicemember or veteran to complete any court-approved counseling program administered or

5-7

approved by the Veterans' Administration, and may prohibit that person from operating a motor

5-8

vehicle that is not equipped with an ignition interlock system for a period of two (2) years

5-9

following the completion of the sentence as provided in section 31-27-2.8.

5-10

      (ii) Every person convicted of a third or subsequent violation within a five (5) year

5-11

period whose blood alcohol concentration is fifteen hundredths of one percent (.15%) above by

5-12

weight as shown by a chemical analysis of a blood, breath, or urine sample or who is under the

5-13

influence of a drug, toluene or any controlled substance as defined in subdivision (b)(1) shall be

5-14

subject to mandatory imprisonment of not less than three (3) years nor more than five (5) years, a

5-15

mandatory fine of not less than one thousand dollars ($1,000) nor more than five thousand dollars

5-16

($5,000) and a mandatory license suspension for a period of three (3) years from the date of

5-17

completion of the sentence imposed under this subsection.

5-18

      (iii) In addition to the foregoing penalties, every person convicted of a third or

5-19

subsequent violation within a five (5) year period regardless of whether any prior violation and

5-20

subsequent conviction was a violation and subsequent conviction under this statute or under the

5-21

driving under the influence of liquor or drugs statute of any other state shall be subject, in the

5-22

discretion of the sentencing judge, to having the vehicle owned and operated by the violator

5-23

seized and sold by the state of Rhode Island, with all funds obtained by the sale to be transferred

5-24

to the general fund.

5-25

     (iv) In any case where a person is convicted of a first offense under the provisions of

5-26

paragraph 31-27-2 (d)(i)-(iii) the sentencing judge may grant the person a conditional work

5-27

license during the period of the license suspension. Said conditional work license or privilege

5-28

shall be valid only for use by the holder thereof, traveling to and from the holder’s place of

5-29

employment or, if the holder’s employment requires the operation of a motor vehicle then during

5-30

the hours of employment as well. The sentencing judge shall have the discretion to set whatever

5-31

other conditions deemed appropriate under the circumstances.

5-32

      (4) Whoever drives or otherwise operates any vehicle in the state while under the

5-33

influence of any intoxicating liquor, drugs, toluene, or any controlled substance as defined in

5-34

chapter 28 of title 21, or any combination of these, when his or her license to operate is

6-1

suspended, revoked or cancelled for operating under the influence of a narcotic drug or

6-2

intoxicating liquor shall be guilty of a felony punishable by imprisonment for not more than three

6-3

(3) years and by a fine or not more than three thousand dollars ($3,000). The court shall require

6-4

alcohol and/or drug treatment for the individual; provided, the penalties provided for in

6-5

subdivision 31-27-2(d)(4) shall not apply to an individual who has surrendered his or her license,

6-6

and served the court ordered period of suspension, but who, for any reason, has not had their

6-7

license reinstated after the period of suspension, revocation, or suspension has expired; provided,

6-8

further the individual shall be subject to the provisions of paragraphs 31-27-2(d)(2)(i) or (ii) or

6-9

31-27-22(d)(3)(i), (ii), or (iii) regarding subsequent offenses, and any other applicable provision

6-10

of section 31-27-2.

6-11

      (5) (i) For purposes of determining the period of license suspension, a prior violation

6-12

shall constitute any charge brought and sustained under the provisions of this section or section

6-13

31-27-2.1.

6-14

      (ii) Any person over the age of eighteen (18) who is convicted under this section for

6-15

operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, other drugs, or a combination of

6-16

these, while a child under the age of thirteen (13) years was present as a passenger in the motor

6-17

vehicle when the offense was committed may be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of not more

6-18

than one year and further shall not be entitled to the benefit of suspension or deferment of this

6-19

sentence. The sentence imposed under this section may be served in any unit of the adult

6-20

correctional institutions in the discretion of the sentencing judge.

6-21

      (6) (i) Any person convicted of a violation under this section shall pay a highway

6-22

assessment fine of five hundred dollars ($500) which shall be deposited into the general fund. The

6-23

assessment provided for by this subsection shall be collected from a violator before any other

6-24

fines authorized by this section.

6-25

      (ii) Any person convicted of a violation under this section shall be assessed a fee of

6-26

eighty-six dollars ($86).

6-27

      (7) (i) If the person convicted of violating this section is under the age of eighteen (18)

6-28

years, for the first violation he or she shall be required to perform ten (10) to sixty (60) hours of

6-29

public community restitution, and the juvenile's driving license shall be suspended for a period of

6-30

six (6) months, and may be suspended for a period up to eighteen (18) months. The sentencing

6-31

judge shall also require attendance at a special course on driving while intoxicated or under the

6-32

influence of a controlled substance and alcohol or drug education and/or treatment for the

6-33

juvenile. The juvenile may also be required to pay a highway assessment fine of no more than

6-34

five hundred dollars ($500), and the assessment imposed shall be deposited into the general fund.

7-1

      (ii) If the person convicted of violating this section is under the age of eighteen (18)

7-2

years, for a second or subsequent violation regardless of whether any prior violation and

7-3

subsequent conviction was a violation and subsequent under this statute or under the driving

7-4

under the influence of liquor or drugs statute of any other state, he or she shall be subject to a

7-5

mandatory suspension of his or her driving license until such time as he or she is twenty-one (21)

7-6

years of age and may, in the discretion of the sentencing judge, also be sentenced to the Rhode

7-7

Island training school for a period of not more than one year and/or a fine of not more than five

7-8

hundred dollars ($500).

7-9

      (8) Any person convicted of a violation under this section may undergo a clinical

7-10

assessment at the community college of Rhode Island 's center for workforce and community

7-11

education. Should this clinical assessment determine problems of alcohol, drug abuse, or

7-12

psychological problems associated with alcoholic or drug abuse, this person shall be referred to

7-13

an appropriate facility, licensed or approved by the department of mental health, retardation and

7-14

hospitals for treatment placement, case management, and monitoring. In the case of a

7-15

servicemember or veteran, the court may order that the person be evaluated through the Veterans'

7-16

Administration. Should the clinical assessment determine problems of alcohol, drug abuse, or

7-17

psychological problems associated with alcohol or drug abuse, the person may have their

7-18

treatment, case management and monitoring administered or approved by the Veterans'

7-19

Administration.

7-20

      (e) Percent by weight of alcohol in the blood shall be based upon milligrams of alcohol

7-21

per one hundred (100) cubic centimeters of blood.

7-22

      (f) (1) There is established an alcohol and drug safety unit within the division of motor

7-23

vehicles to administer an alcohol safety action program. The program shall provide for placement

7-24

and follow-up for persons who are required to pay the highway safety assessment. The alcohol

7-25

and drug safety action program will be administered in conjunction with alcohol and drug

7-26

programs licensed by the department of mental health retardation and hospitals.

7-27

      (2) Persons convicted under the provisions of this chapter shall be required to attend a

7-28

special course on driving while intoxicated or under the influence of a controlled substance,

7-29

and/or participate in an alcohol or drug treatment program; provided, however, that the court may

7-30

permit a servicemember or veteran to complete any court-approved counseling program

7-31

administered or approved by the Veterans' Administration. The course shall take into

7-32

consideration any language barrier which may exist as to any person ordered to attend, and shall

7-33

provide for instruction reasonably calculated to communicate the purposes of the course in

7-34

accordance with the requirements of the subsection. Any costs reasonably incurred in connection

8-1

with the provision of this accommodation shall be borne by the person being retrained. A copy of

8-2

any violation under this section shall be forwarded by the court to the alcohol and drug safety

8-3

unit. In the event that persons convicted under the provisions of this chapter fail to attend and

8-4

complete the above course or treatment program, as ordered by the judge, then the person may be

8-5

brought before the court, and after a hearing as to why the order of the court was not followed,

8-6

may be sentenced to jail for a period not exceeding one year.

8-7

      (3) The alcohol and drug safety action program within the division of motor vehicles

8-8

shall be funded by general revenue appropriations.

8-9

      (g) The director of the health department of the state of Rhode Island is empowered to

8-10

make and file with the secretary of state regulations which prescribe the techniques and methods

8-11

of chemical analysis of the person's body fluids or breath, and the qualifications and certification

8-12

of individuals authorized to administer this testing and analysis.

8-13

      (h) Jurisdiction for misdemeanor violations of this section shall be with the district court

8-14

for persons eighteen (18) years of age or older and to the family court for persons under the age

8-15

of eighteen (18) years. The courts shall have full authority to impose any sentence authorized and

8-16

to order the suspension of any license for violations of this section. All trials in the district court

8-17

and family court of violations of the section shall be scheduled within thirty (30) days of the

8-18

arraignment date. No continuance or postponement shall be granted except for good cause shown.

8-19

Any continuances that are necessary shall be granted for the shortest practicable time. Trials in

8-20

superior court are not required to be scheduled within thirty (30) days of the arraignment date.

8-21

      (i) No fines, suspensions, assessments, alcohol or drug treatment programs, course on

8-22

driving while intoxicated or under the influence of a controlled substance, public community

8-23

restitution, or jail provided for under this section can be suspended.

8-24

      (j) An order to attend a special course on driving while intoxicated that shall be

8-25

administered in cooperation with a college or university accredited by the state, shall include a

8-26

provision to pay a reasonable tuition for the course in an amount not less than twenty-five dollars

8-27

($25.00), and a fee of one hundred seventy-five dollars ($175), which fee shall be deposited into

8-28

the general fund.

8-29

      (k) For the purposes of this section, any test of a sample of blood, breath, or urine for the

8-30

presence of alcohol, which relies in whole or in part upon the principle of infrared light

8-31

absorption is considered a chemical test.

8-32

      (l) If any provision of this section or the application of any provision shall for any reason

8-33

be judged invalid, such a judgment shall not affect, impair, or invalidate the remainder of the

8-34

section, but shall be confined in this effect to the provision or application directly involved in the

9-1

controversy giving rise to the judgment.

9-2

      (m) For the purposes of this section, "servicemember" means a person who is presently

9-3

serving in the armed forces of the United States including the Coast Guard, a reserve component

9-4

thereof, or the National Guard. "Veteran" means a person who has served in the armed forces,

9-5

including the Coast Guard of the United States, a reserve component thereof, or the National

9-6

Guard, and has been discharged under other than dishonorable conditions.

9-7

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC00041

=======

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO MOTOR AN OTHER VEHICLES - MOTOR VEHICLE OFFENSES

***

10-1

     This act would give the sentencing judge discretion to grant a conditional work license to

10-2

first offenders in driving under the influence cases.

10-3

     This at would take effect upon passage.

=======

LC00041

=======