2012 -- S 2389 SUBSTITUTE A AS AMENDED

=======

LC01456/SUB A

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2012

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO INSURANCE - PRODUCER LICENSING ACT

     Introduced By: Senator Roger Picard

     Date Introduced: February 15, 2012

     Referred To: Senate Corporations

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Section 27-2.4-20 of the General Laws in Chapter 27-2.4 entitled "Producer

1-2

Licensing Act" is hereby amended to read as follows:

1-3

     27-2.4-20. Revocation or modification of insurance producer's contract --

1-4

Procedures. -- (a) No company shall cancel the authority of an insurance producer, if the

1-5

insurance producer is not an employee of the company, and no company shall modify a contract

1-6

with that insurance producer unless the company gives written notice of its intent to cancel that

1-7

insurance producer or its intent to modify the contract at least one hundred eighty (180) days

1-8

before the proposed effective date of any cancellation or at least one hundred eighty (180) days

1-9

before the proposed effective date of any modification. No company shall allow the license of

1-10

that insurance producer to expire unless the company gives written notice of its intent to do so at

1-11

least one hundred eighty (180) days before the proposed effective date of expiration because of

1-12

cancellation. Except as otherwise provided in this section, any insurance producer receiving

1-13

notice of cancellation, modification, or expiration may, within sixty (60) days after receipt of the

1-14

notice, make a written demand for reference to three (3) referees of the question as to whether or

1-15

not the cancellation, modification, or expiration will affect the renewal, continuation, or

1-16

replacement of any policies placed with the company through the efforts of the insurance

1-17

producer, or the services needed by any policyholder doing business with the company as a result

1-18

of the efforts of the insurance producer, as to justify renewal or continuation of any policies then

1-19

in effect having been placed with the company by that insurance producer. In the event the

1-20

referees find that the cancellation, modification, or expiration will affect the renewal,

2-1

continuation, or replacement of any policies placed with the company through the efforts of the

2-2

insurance producer, or the services needed by any policyholders doing business with the company

2-3

as a result of the efforts of the insurance producer, then the referees shall order continuance or

2-4

renewal of any policies expiring within a period of twelve (12) months of the issuance of the

2-5

notice, at a rate of compensation to the insurance producer equal to that as provided in the

2-6

agreement expiring or being cancelled or modified, for one additional policy period equal in

2-7

length to the most recent policy period of the expiring policy, but in no event for more than one

2-8

year. The referees shall not order continuance or renewal of any policies if they find that the

2-9

reason for the cancellation or expiration of the agreement by the company was legitimately based

2-10

upon one of the following grounds:

2-11

      (1) The insurance producer was convicted of a dishonest act related to his or her

2-12

occupation as an insurance agent;

2-13

      (2) The insurance producer's license to engage as an insurance producer was revoked; or

2-14

      (3) The company surrendered its license to do business in the state.

2-15

      (b) An insurance producer making a written demand for a reference shall accompany the

2-16

written demand with the names and addresses of three (3) persons, where the company shall,

2-17

within fifteen (15) days, notify the insurance producer of its choice of one of the persons to act as

2-18

one of the referees and at the same time submit the names and addresses of three (3) persons to

2-19

the insurance producer, who shall, within fifteen (15) days after receiving these names, notify the

2-20

company in writing of his her choice of one of the persons to act as a second referee. At the same

2-21

time the insurance producer shall notify the commissioner, the notice to be on a form prescribed

2-22

by the commissioner, that both the company and insurance producer have chosen referees. Within

2-23

ten (10) days of the receipt of this notice the commissioner shall appoint a person to serve as third

2-24

referee, and shall notify that person, the insurance producer, and the company in writing of this

2-25

appointment. Each person nominated or appointed as a referee shall be a disinterested person,

2-26

shall be a resident of the state, and shall be willing to act as a referee. Within ten (10) working

2-27

days of the appointment of the third referee, who shall serve as chairperson, the three (3) referees

2-28

shall meet, hear evidence, and reduce their decisions to writing and sign it, and shall deliver a

2-29

copy of the decision to the insurance producer, to the company, and to the commissioner. In the

2-30

event any company receiving a written demand for a reference fails to comply with the provisions

2-31

of this subsection, then the insurance producer shall have the authority to renew or continue any

2-32

policies placed with that company through the efforts of the insurance producer expiring within a

2-33

period of thirteen (13) months from the date of the notice of cancellation, modification, or

2-34

expiration of the agreement, at a rate of compensation to the insurance producer equal to that as

3-1

provided in the agreement expiring or being cancelled or modified, for one additional policy

3-2

period equal in length to the most recent policy period of the expiring policy, but in no event for

3-3

more than one year.

3-4

      (c) Any insurance company and any insurance producer may by written contract agree to

3-5

modify the provisions of subsections (a) and (b) of this section other than the requirement of a

3-6

one hundred eighty (180) day notice in the event of cancellation or a one hundred eighty (180)

3-7

day notice in the event of modification of a contract or of intent to allow the expiration of a

3-8

license, by provisions presented to and approved by the commissioner which he or she finds after

3-9

due hearing and investigation will adequately protect both the right of the policyholder to a

3-10

continuance of insurance and the services of any insurance producer of his or her own choosing

3-11

and the right of the insurance producer to fair compensation for the insurance placed with a

3-12

company as a result of the insurance producer's efforts. The commissioner may make reasonable

3-13

rules of general application regarding these modified provisions.

3-14

      (d) The decision of the referees may provide for the renewal or continuance of any or all

3-15

policies expiring within a period of twelve (12) months of the issuance of any notice, at a rate of

3-16

compensation to the insurance producer equal to that as provided in the agreement expiring or

3-17

being cancelled or modified, for one additional policy period equal in length to the most recent

3-18

policy period of the expiring policy, but in no event for more than one year. The decision of the

3-19

referees may also provide for the continuance of previous contractual provisions, if the referees,

3-20

or a majority of them, find that the decision will best protect the right of a policyholder to a

3-21

continuance of insurance and the services of an insurance producer of his or her own choosing

3-22

and the right of any insurance producer to compensation for the insurance placed with a company

3-23

as a result of his or her efforts, giving due consideration to the possibility the affected insurance

3-24

producer has of obtaining similar coverage for policyholders affected from other companies at

3-25

reasonable compensation. The decisions rendered in accordance with the provisions of this

3-26

section providing for reference shall be binding on all companies and insurance producer affected

3-27

by those decisions. If a decision orders the renewal or continuance of any policies, policyholders

3-28

and the affected insurance producer shall be entitled in all respects to the same services and

3-29

practices as were in effect prior to reference insofar as amounts and types of coverage, credit

3-30

terms, commissions paid to the insurance producer, and insurance producer services are also

3-31

continued.

3-32

      (e) All policies expiring within twelve (12) months of the notice may be renewed for the

3-33

policy periods as provided in subsection (d) of this section, but no insurance producer or company

3-34

relying on this section shall again refer the same issue to referees. Where other provisions of the

4-1

general laws require notice to policyholders before non-renewal of any coverage, the company

4-2

shall, at the request of the insurance producer who is unable to replace any policy which has been

4-3

renewed for one or more policy periods in accordance with this section, comply with those

4-4

provisions of law.

4-5

      (f) An insurance producer initiating reference under this section and the company

4-6

receiving written demand shall each be liable for the payment of the reasonable charges and

4-7

expenses of his or her nominee for referee and one-half ( 1/2) of the compensation for the

4-8

reasonable charges and expenses of the third referee. The third referee shall upon the execution of

4-9

the decision furnish the insurance producer and the company with a written statement specifying

4-10

in detail his or her charges for compensation and expenses. The insurance producer or the

4-11

company, if aggrieved by these charges, may petition the commissioner for review. The petition

4-12

shall set forth with particularity the specific item or charges in dispute. The commissioner shall,

4-13

within ten (10) days of receipt of the petition, notify the interested parties of the date established

4-14

for a hearing on the petition and, after the hearing, the commissioner shall approve or disapprove

4-15

the charges in whole or in part, his or her findings and decisions shall be final and conclusive.

4-16

     (g) In the event a property and casualty insurance producer has a contract with and places

4-17

such insurance with more than one property and casualty company, then said insurance producer

4-18

and the company that contracts to provide such insurance to the insurance producer shall not be

4-19

subject to this section but shall be subject to the provisions of section 27-2.4-20.1.

4-20

     However, any insurance producer who by contractual agreement either represents only

4-21

one company or group of affiliated insurance companies or is required by contract to submit risks

4-22

to a specified company or group of affiliated insurance companies prior to submitting them to

4-23

other insurance companies, then those contracts shall remain subject only to section 27-2.4-20.

4-24

     (h) This section shall not apply to agents of title insurers as defined in chapter 27-2.6, or

4-25

to insurance producers who are employees of the insurance company.

4-26

     SECTION 2. Chapter 27-2.4 of the General Laws entitled "Producer Licensing Act" is

4-27

hereby amended by adding thereto the following section:

4-28

     27-2.4-20.1. Revocation or modification of property and casualty insurance

4-29

producer's contract - Procedures. – (a) No property and casualty insurance company shall

4-30

cancel the authority of an insurance producer, having a contract with and placing such insurance

4-31

with more than one property and casualty insurance company, unless the company gives written

4-32

notice of its intent to cancel that insurance producer at least fourteen (14) months before the

4-33

proposed effective date of any cancellation. In such case, no company shall allow the license of

4-34

that insurance producer to expire unless the company gives written notice of its intent to do so at

5-1

least fourteen (14) months before the proposed effective date of expiration because of

5-2

cancellation. In addition, no company shall modify a contract with an insurance producer, unless

5-3

the company gives written notice of its intent to modify the contract of that insurance producer at

5-4

least one hundred eighty (180) days before the proposed effective date of the modification.

5-5

     (b) When a property and casualty insurance company cancels the authority of an

5-6

insurance producer having a contract with and places such insurance with more than one property

5-7

and casualty insurance company under the provisions of this section, the company shall continue

5-8

to renew the expiring policies of the insurance producer who has received notification of

5-9

cancellation that meets it’s underwriting guidelines for a period of fourteen (14) months of the

5-10

issuance of the notice at a rate of compensation to that insurance producer equal to that provided

5-11

in the expiring contract.

5-12

     (c) The provisions of subsections (a) and (b) do not apply to a property and casualty

5-13

insurance producer:

5-14

     (1) Convicted of a dishonest act related to his or her occupation as an insurance agent; or

5-15

     (2) Whose license to engage as an insurance producer was revoked; or

5-16

     (3) Whose company surrendered its license to do business in the state; or

5-17

     (4) Who is an employee of the insurance company.

5-18

     SECTION 3. This act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01456/SUB A

========

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO INSURANCE - PRODUCER LICENSING ACT

***

6-1

     This act would amend the notification procedures for modifying or revoking a property

6-2

and casualty insurance producer’s contract.

6-3

     This act would take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01456/SUB A

=======