2013 -- S 0533 | |
======= | |
LC01905 | |
======= | |
STATE OF RHODE ISLAND | |
| |
IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY | |
| |
JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2013 | |
| |
____________ | |
| |
A N A C T | |
RELATING TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY - THE LEGISLATIVE AUDIT BUREAU | |
|
      |
|
      |
     Introduced By: Senators Ciccone, Cote, McCaffrey, Raptakis, and Picard | |
     Date Introduced: February 28, 2013 | |
     Referred To: Senate Finance | |
It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows: | |
1-1 |
     SECTION 1. Chapter 22-13 of the General Laws entitled "Auditor General" is hereby |
1-2 |
amended by adding thereto the following section: |
1-3 |
     22-13-11. Audit provided for by finance committee of the house of representatives. – |
1-4 |
It shall be the duty of the finance committee of the house of representatives to provide annually |
1-5 |
for a complete post audit of the financial transactions and accounts of the state. The finance |
1-6 |
committee of the house of representatives shall be required to utilize the services of the auditor |
1-7 |
general to perform the post audit. The post audit shall commence as soon as possible after the |
1-8 |
close of each fiscal year and shall include the examination of all accounts from the date of the last |
1-9 |
post audit. |
1-10 |
     22-13-12. Specifications of audit - copies of report. – The director of administration |
1-11 |
and the general treasurer shall assist the finance committee of the house of representatives in |
1-12 |
determining the post audit specifications prior to the employment of the certified public |
1-13 |
accountant or accountants. Upon completion of the post audit the certified public accountant or |
1-14 |
accountants shall submit copies of the report to the members of the finance committee of the |
1-15 |
house of representatives, the governor, the director of administration, the general treasurer, and |
1-16 |
the legislative council. The report shall also be made available for public inspection. |
1-17 |
     22-13-13. Audit of quasi-public agencies. – All quasi-public agencies including |
1-18 |
corporations, authorities, commissions, and boards created by the authority of the general |
1-19 |
assembly, executive order, or state law, excluding cities and their subdivisions, towns and their |
1-20 |
subdivisions, regional school districts and school committees, water districts, fire districts, and |
2-1 |
any other municipal corporations and their agencies, subject to post audit, are hereby required to |
2-2 |
obtain the approval of the director of administration and the auditor general prior to the |
2-3 |
employment of private auditors. Audit workpapers of the private auditors shall be made available |
2-4 |
upon request, at the completion of the audit, to the auditor general and/or the director of |
2-5 |
administration for their review. The audit report shall be furnished to the auditor general and the |
2-6 |
director of administration. |
2-7 |
     22-13-14. Travel and entertainment expenses of quasi-public agencies. – Quasi-public |
2-8 |
agencies, as set forth in section 35-7-13, shall prepare and maintain documentation for all travel |
2-9 |
and entertainment expenses in sufficient detail to allow for post audit. |
2-10 |
     SECTION 2. Title 22 of the General Laws entitled "GENERAL ASSEMBLY" is hereby |
2-11 |
amended by adding thereto the following chapter: |
2-12 |
     CHAPTER 20 |
2-13 |
THE BUREAU OF AUDITS COMMITTEE |
2-14 |
     22-20-1. Title. – This chapter shall be known as “The Bureau of Audits Committee.” |
2-15 |
     22-20-2. Bureau of audits committee created – Appointment of members - Officers. |
2-16 |
– (a) There is hereby created the bureau of audits committee that shall consist of five (5) members |
2-17 |
as follows: two (2) shall be appointed by the speaker of the house; two (2) shall be appointed by |
2-18 |
the senate president; one shall be appointed alternately by the senate president and the speaker of |
2-19 |
the house with the senate president making the first appointment. |
2-20 |
     (b) Appointments to the committee shall be made to provide demonstrated and |
2-21 |
acknowledged expertise in a diverse range of financial and auditing areas, including: |
2-22 |
     (1) Financial expert; |
2-23 |
     (2) Active certified public accountant; |
2-24 |
     (3) Certified internal auditor; |
2-25 |
     (4) Governmental financial accounting expert; and |
2-26 |
     (5) Information technology systems and services expert. |
2-27 |
     (c) Appointments to the committee shall consider the expertise of the other members so |
2-28 |
that the committee’s composition reflects a range and diversity of skills. |
2-29 |
     (d) No member of the committee shall be a current or former state legislator, or be |
2-30 |
employed by, a consultant to, or affiliated with the Rhode Island house of representatives or the |
2-31 |
Rhode Island senate. |
2-32 |
     (e) A committee member shall not receive compensation for his or her service on the |
2-33 |
committee, but may receive a per diem and reimbursement for travel and other necessary |
2-34 |
expenses while engaged in the performance of official duties of the committee. |
3-1 |
     (f) Each committee member shall, before entering upon his or her duties, take an oath to |
3-2 |
administer the duties of his or her office faithfully and impartially, and the oath shall be filed in |
3-3 |
the office of the secretary of state. |
3-4 |
     (g) A quorum shall consist of three (3) members of the committee. A majority vote of |
3-5 |
those present shall be required for action. |
3-6 |
     (h) There shall not be any liability in a private capacity on the part of the committee or |
3-7 |
any member of the committee, or any officer or employee of the committee or on account of any |
3-8 |
act performed or obligation entered into in an official capacity, when done in good faith, without |
3-9 |
intent to defraud, and in connection with the administration, management, or conduct of this |
3-10 |
chapter or affairs related to this chapter. |
3-11 |
     (i) The committee shall adopt a code of ethics applicable to each committee member, |
3-12 |
officer and employee that, at a minimum, includes standards established in chapter 36-14 (“code |
3-13 |
of ethics”). |
3-14 |
     22-20-3. Term of office – Officers - Vacancies. – (a) One of those members first |
3-15 |
appointed by the speaker of the house shall serve an initial term of two (2) years; one of those |
3-16 |
members first appointed by the senate president shall serve an initial term of two (2) years. |
3-17 |
Thereafter, all appointed members of the committee shall be appointed to serve for terms of three |
3-18 |
(3) years, except for the member alternately appointed who shall serve a term of four (4) years. |
3-19 |
     (b) The member alternately appointed shall serve as chairperson. The committee shall |
3-20 |
select a vice chairperson and secretary from among its membership. |
3-21 |
     (c) The committee members are eligible to succeed themselves. All appointed committee |
3-22 |
members shall be appointed to serve for not more than two (2) terms. A vacancy other than by |
3-23 |
expiration shall be filled in the manner of the original appointment but only for the unexpired |
3-24 |
portion of the term. |
3-25 |
     (d) A member of the committee appointed by the speaker of the house shall be removable |
3-26 |
by the speaker of the house with the consent of a majority of the senate. A member of the |
3-27 |
committee appointed by the senate president shall be removable by the senate president with the |
3-28 |
consent of a majority of the house. Removal in accordance with this subsection shall be for cause |
3-29 |
only and removal solely for partisan or personal reasons unrelated to capacity or fitness for the |
3-30 |
office shall be unlawful. |
3-31 |
     (e) Any committee member who fails to attend more than fifty percent (50%) of all |
3-32 |
meetings held during any calendar year shall be deemed to have resigned, unless the committee |
3-33 |
member requests in writing to the chairperson to serve the remaining term of his or her |
3-34 |
appointment, setting forth the reason or reasons for the absences, and the majority of the |
4-1 |
committee members approve the request. |
4-2 |
     22-20-4. Chief of the bureau of audits. – (a) The committee shall engage a chief of the |
4-3 |
bureau of audits who shall be an employee of the committee and who shall not be a member of |
4-4 |
the committee. At the time of appointment, the chief of the bureau of audits shall have had active |
4-5 |
experience in general accounting principles and practices in this state for a total period of at least |
4-6 |
five (5) years. The chief of the bureau of audits shall be in the unclassified service. The duties and |
4-7 |
powers of the chief of the bureau of audits shall be determined by the committee and the chief |
4-8 |
shall be subject to the direction and control of the committee. The committee shall not engage a |
4-9 |
chief for more than five (5) years; provided, however, that the committee may renew its contract |
4-10 |
with the chief of the bureau of audits. |
4-11 |
     (b) The committee shall employ qualified persons necessary for the efficient operation of |
4-12 |
the bureau of audits, shall determine their duties and compensation, shall be subject to the |
4-13 |
direction and control of the committee, and those persons shall be in the unclassified service. |
4-14 |
     (1) No person shall be employed as an auditor who does not have adequate technical |
4-15 |
training and proficiency, and a baccalaureate degree from a college or university, and no person |
4-16 |
shall be employed or retained as legal advisor on either a full-time or a part-time basis who is not |
4-17 |
a member of the Rhode Island bar. |
4-18 |
     (c) The chief, before entering upon the duties of his or her office, shall take and subscribe |
4-19 |
to the oath of office required of state officers by the state constitution. |
4-20 |
     (d) The chief shall be provided with suitable quarters, but to facilitate auditing and to |
4-21 |
eliminate unnecessary traveling, the committee may establish divisions and assign auditors to |
4-22 |
each division and determine their duties and the areas of the state to be served by the respective |
4-23 |
divisions. The chief shall be provided and furnished with any space that may be necessary to |
4-24 |
carry out his or her functions in other areas of the state. |
4-25 |
     (e) Subject to the direction of the committee, the chief may make and enforce reasonable |
4-26 |
rules and regulations necessary to facilitate audits which the committee authorizes the chief to |
4-27 |
perform. |
4-28 |
     (f) No employee of the bureau of audits shall serve as an executive, officer, or employee |
4-29 |
of any political party committee, organization, or association or be employed by, a consultant to, |
4-30 |
or affiliated with the house or senate. Neither the chief nor any employee of the bureau of audits |
4-31 |
shall become a candidate for election to public office unless he or she shall first resign from his or |
4-32 |
her office or employment. |
4-33 |
     22-20-5. Salaries and expenses. – (a) The expenses of the members of the committee |
4-34 |
shall be approved by the chairperson of the committee, and paid from the appropriation for |
5-1 |
legislative expense. |
5-2 |
     (b) The chief shall prepare and annually submit to the committee a proposed budget for |
5-3 |
the ensuing fiscal year. The committee shall review the budget request and may amend or change |
5-4 |
the budget request as it deems necessary. The budget request, as amended or changed by the |
5-5 |
committee, shall become the operating budget of the bureau of audits for the ensuing fiscal year; |
5-6 |
provided, that the budget so adopted may subsequently be amended under the same procedure. |
5-7 |
     (c) Within the limitations of the approved operating budget, the salaries and expenses of |
5-8 |
the chief and his or her staff shall be paid from the appropriation for legislative expense or any |
5-9 |
other moneys appropriated by the legislature for that purpose. The committee shall approve all |
5-10 |
bills for salaries and expenses. |
5-11 |
     (d) Commencing January 1, 2014, and every year thereafter, each quasi-public |
5-12 |
corporation shall be assessed an amount not to exceed one-sixteenth (1/16) of one percent (1%) of |
5-13 |
its total annual revenue for the previous fiscal year. The assessments shall be placed in a |
5-14 |
restricted receipt account of the joint committee on legislative services for the sole purpose of |
5-15 |
covering the operating costs of the bureau of audits. For purposes of this chapter, a quasi-public |
5-16 |
corporation means any body corporate and politic created or to be created pursuant to the general |
5-17 |
laws. |
5-18 |
     22-20-6. Access of chief to state property – Assistance to other departments. – For |
5-19 |
the purpose of making any investigation authorized by this chapter, the chief of the bureau of |
5-20 |
audits or his or her duly authorized agent may enter upon any state property at any reasonable |
5-21 |
time. |
5-22 |
     22-20-7. Audits performed by the bureau of audits. – (a) The bureau of audits is |
5-23 |
authorized to conduct audits of any state department, state agency, quasi-public corporation, or |
5-24 |
private entity that is a recipient of state funding or state grants. As deemed necessary or expedient |
5-25 |
by the bureau of audits, audits may be made relative to the financial affairs or the economy and |
5-26 |
efficiency of management of each department, agency and quasi-public corporations. The chief, |
5-27 |
at the direction of the committee, shall determine which such audits shall be performed in |
5-28 |
accordance with a risk-based evaluation. Unless there is an issue of misappropriation, the |
5-29 |
provisions of this section shall not apply to non-profit organizations. |
5-30 |
     (b) Within twenty (20) days following the date of the issuance of the final audit report, |
5-31 |
the head of the department, agency, quasi-public corporation, or private entity audited shall |
5-32 |
respond in writing to each recommendation made in the final audit report. This response shall |
5-33 |
address the department’s, agency’s, quasi-public corporation’s, or private entity’s plan of |
5-34 |
implementation for each specific audit recommendation and, if applicable, the reasons for |
6-1 |
disagreement with any recommendation proposed in the audit report. Within one year following |
6-2 |
the date on which the audit report was issued, the bureau of audits may perform a follow-up audit |
6-3 |
for the purpose of determining whether the department, agency, or quasi-public corporation, or |
6-4 |
private entity has implemented, in an efficient and effective manner, its plan of action for the |
6-5 |
recommendations proposed in the audit report. |
6-6 |
     (c) The bureau of audits shall maintain a full record of each audit. In the event that |
6-7 |
information gathered as a result of an audit indicates that criminal activity may have occurred, the |
6-8 |
chief of the bureau of audits may provide such information to a state or federal law enforcement |
6-9 |
agency. For any such information that is otherwise exempt from public disclosure under the |
6-10 |
provisions of chapter 38-2-1, the provision of such information to a law enforcement agency shall |
6-11 |
not therefore require that this information be further disclosed. |
6-12 |
     (d) Copies of each audit report, the written response to the audit report, and the results of |
6-13 |
each follow-up audit as described in subsection (b) above shall be submitted to the governor and |
6-14 |
the chairpersons of the house finance committee and the senate finance committee. |
6-15 |
     22-20-8. Cost of forensic examinations. – When it is determined by the chief at the |
6-16 |
direction of the committee that an audit is necessary because there is sufficient evidence to |
6-17 |
believe that there may have been fiscal impropriety, wrongdoing or fiscal mismanagement by any |
6-18 |
employee, board member, or commissioner of any state agency or authority as defined in section |
6-19 |
42-35-1, the bureau of audits may conduct a forensic examination of such entity. All costs |
6-20 |
associated with the forensic examination shall be paid, as deemed appropriate by the committee, |
6-21 |
either by the examined entity or by an appropriation proposed by the governor and enacted by the |
6-22 |
general assembly. Such costs shall include, but not be limited to, the following expenses: |
6-23 |
     (1) One hundred percent (100%) of the total salaries and benefits paid to the examining |
6-24 |
personnel of the bureau of audits engaged in those examinations; |
6-25 |
     (2) All costs associated with the procurement of a forensic consultant; |
6-26 |
     (3) All costs associated with a consultant that provides expertise pertinent to the |
6-27 |
examinee’s operations; and |
6-28 |
     (4) All reasonable technology costs related to the forensic examination process. |
6-29 |
Technology costs shall include the actual cost of software and hardware utilized in the |
6-30 |
examination process and the cost of training examination personnel in the proper use of the |
6-31 |
software/hardware. |
6-32 |
     22-20-9. Investigations or management advisory and consulting services upon |
6-33 |
request of governor or general assembly. – The bureau of audits shall, upon the written request |
6-34 |
of the governor, the director of the department of administration, or of either branch of the |
7-1 |
general assembly, conduct audits, provide management advisory and consulting services, or |
7-2 |
conduct investigations relative to the financial affairs or the economy and efficiency of |
7-3 |
management, or both, of any state department or agency. The chief, at the direction of the |
7-4 |
committee, may from time to time, make such investigations and additional reports to the |
7-5 |
governor, the director of the department of administration, and the general assembly as the chief, |
7-6 |
at the direction of the committee shall deem necessary or advisable. |
7-7 |
     22-20-10. Management advisory and consulting services provided to state agencies |
7-8 |
and departments. – When requested in writing by the head of a state department, agency or |
7-9 |
quasi-public corporation the chief, at the direction of the committee, may provide management |
7-10 |
advisory or consulting services to the department or agency. Any such request must include the |
7-11 |
scope of services requested and a schedule for the work to be performed. |
7-12 |
     22-20-11. Persons authorized to conduct audits – Reports of irregularities. – Any |
7-13 |
qualified person duly authorized by the committee to act as auditor may examine the books, |
7-14 |
papers, and documents of any department, or of the clerk of any court or office of the state having |
7-15 |
control of funds, and if the audit discloses any irregularities or improper handling of records or |
7-16 |
funds, the auditor shall report the same to the committee, the governor, the speaker of the house |
7-17 |
and the senate president. |
7-18 |
     22-20-12. Disclosure of confidential health care information. – A patient’s |
7-19 |
confidential health care information shall be released or transferred without the written consent of |
7-20 |
the patient or the patient’s authorized representative to the chief or his or her designated |
7-21 |
representative for the purpose of conducting financial audits, management audits, program |
7-22 |
evaluations, and research, provided the personnel shall not identify, directly or indirectly, any |
7-23 |
individual patient in any report of the audit, evaluation, or research, or otherwise disclose patient |
7-24 |
identities in any manner. |
7-25 |
     22-20-13. Access to executive sessions of a public agency – Access to records – |
7-26 |
Disclosure by the chief. – (a) Whenever a public agency goes into executive session, the chief or |
7-27 |
his or her designated representative shall be permitted to attend the executive session or if the |
7-28 |
chief or his or her designee is not in attendance at the executive session, the chief or his or her |
7-29 |
designee, upon written request, shall be furnished with copies of all data or materials furnished to |
7-30 |
the members of the public agency at the executive session. If the chief or his or her designee |
7-31 |
attends the executive session, the chief shall be furnished the same data in the same form and at |
7-32 |
the same time as members of the public agency. |
7-33 |
     (b) Within three (3) working days of a written request by the chief, the public agency |
7-34 |
shall furnish a copy, whether approved by the agency or not, of the minutes of any meeting, |
8-1 |
including any executive session of the public agency. |
8-2 |
     (c) The chief shall have full and unlimited access to any and all records of any public |
8-3 |
agency, in whatever form or mode the records may be, unless the chief’s access to the records is |
8-4 |
specifically prohibited or limited by federal or state law. In no case shall any confidentiality |
8-5 |
provisions of state law be construed to restrict the chief’s access to the records; provided, the |
8-6 |
chief’s access to any confidential data shall not in any way change the confidential nature of the |
8-7 |
data obtained. Where an audit or investigative finding emanates from confidential data, specific |
8-8 |
confidential information shall not be made public. The records shall include those in the |
8-9 |
immediate possession of a public agency as well as records which the agency itself has a right to. |
8-10 |
In the event of a dispute between the agency involved and the chief as to whether or not the data |
8-11 |
involved are confidential by law, the matter shall be referred to the attorney general for |
8-12 |
resolution. |
8-13 |
     (d) If, in the course of an executive session, any fact comes to the attention of the chief or |
8-14 |
his or her designated representative, which in his or her judgment constitutes an impropriety, |
8-15 |
irregularity, or illegal transaction, or points to the onset of an impropriety or illegal transaction, |
8-16 |
then the chief shall disclose that information to the bureau of audits committee, and the |
8-17 |
chairperson of the public agency involved. Where the facts or the data upon which the facts are |
8-18 |
based are deemed confidential pursuant to the provisions of federal or state law, the chief’s access |
8-19 |
to the information shall not in any way change the confidential nature of the data obtained. |
8-20 |
     (e) In the event of a dispute between the agency involved and the chief as to whether or |
8-21 |
not the data involved are confidential by law, the matter will be referred to the attorney general |
8-22 |
for resolution. |
8-23 |
     (f) The chief or his or her designated representative shall be immune from any liability to |
8-24 |
any party for claims arising out of disclosure authorized by this section. |
8-25 |
     (g) For the purposes of this section, the phrase “public agency” shall include the |
8-26 |
following: the Rhode Island industrial building authority, the Rhode Island recreational building |
8-27 |
authority, the Rhode Island economic development corporation, the Rhode Island industrial |
8-28 |
facilities corporation, the Rhode Island refunding bond authority, the Rhode Island housing and |
8-29 |
mortgage finance corporation, the Rhode Island resource recovery corporation, the Rhode Island |
8-30 |
public transit authority, the Rhode Island student loan authority, the water resources board, the |
8-31 |
Rhode Island health and educational building corporation, the Rhode Island higher education |
8-32 |
assistance authority, the Rhode Island turnpike and bridge authority, the Narragansett Bay |
8-33 |
commission, Rhode Island public telecommunications authority, the convention center authority, |
8-34 |
channel 36 foundation, their successors and assigns, and any other body corporate and politic |
9-1 |
which has been or which is subsequently created or established within this state. |
9-2 |
     22-20-14. Rules and regulations. – The committee may adopt rules or any amendments |
9-3 |
to rules in accordance with the provisions of chapter 42-35. |
9-4 |
     22-20-15. Applicability of other laws. – The exchange shall be subject to the provisions |
9-5 |
of chapter 22 (“open meetings”), chapter 36-14 (“code of ethics”) and chapter 38-2 (“access to |
9-6 |
public records”). |
9-7 |
     SECTION 3. Chapter 35-7 of the General Laws entitled "Post Audit of Accounts" is |
9-8 |
hereby repealed in its entirety. |
9-9 |
      |
9-10 |
|
9-11 |
      |
9-12 |
|
9-13 |
      |
9-14 |
      |
9-15 |
|
9-16 |
|
9-17 |
|
9-18 |
|
9-19 |
|
9-20 |
|
9-21 |
      |
9-22 |
|
9-23 |
|
9-24 |
|
9-25 |
|
9-26 |
|
9-27 |
|
9-28 |
|
9-29 |
|
9-30 |
      |
9-31 |
|
9-32 |
|
9-33 |
|
9-34 |
|
10-1 |
|
10-2 |
      |
10-3 |
|
10-4 |
|
10-5 |
      |
10-6 |
|
10-7 |
|
10-8 |
|
10-9 |
|
10-10 |
|
10-11 |
|
10-12 |
|
10-13 |
      |
10-14 |
|
10-15 |
      |
10-16 |
      |
10-17 |
|
10-18 |
      |
10-19 |
|
10-20 |
|
10-21 |
|
10-22 |
      |
10-23 |
      |
10-24 |
|
10-25 |
|
10-26 |
|
10-27 |
|
10-28 |
|
10-29 |
|
10-30 |
|
10-31 |
|
10-32 |
      |
10-33 |
|
10-34 |
|
11-1 |
|
11-2 |
|
11-3 |
      |
11-4 |
      |
11-5 |
|
11-6 |
|
11-7 |
|
11-8 |
|
11-9 |
|
11-10 |
      |
11-11 |
|
11-12 |
|
11-13 |
|
11-14 |
|
11-15 |
|
11-16 |
|
11-17 |
      |
11-18 |
      |
11-19 |
|
11-20 |
|
11-21 |
|
11-22 |
|
11-23 |
|
11-24 |
      |
11-25 |
|
11-26 |
|
11-27 |
|
11-28 |
|
11-29 |
|
11-30 |
|
11-31 |
      |
11-32 |
      |
11-33 |
|
11-34 |
|
12-1 |
|
12-2 |
|
12-3 |
|
12-4 |
|
12-5 |
|
12-6 |
|
12-7 |
|
12-8 |
      |
12-9 |
|
12-10 |
|
12-11 |
     SECTION 4. This act shall take effect upon passage. |
      | |
======= | |
LC01905 | |
======== | |
EXPLANATION | |
BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL | |
OF | |
A N A C T | |
RELATING TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY - THE LEGISLATIVE AUDIT BUREAU | |
*** | |
13-1 |
     This act would create the bureau of audits committee, delete the provisions of the general |
13-2 |
laws relative to “post audit of accounts” and would relocate certain sections from the “post audit |
13-3 |
of accounts” chapter into the newly created “bureau of audits committee”. |
13-4 |
     This act would take effect upon passage. |
      | |
======= | |
LC01905 | |
======= |