2013 -- S 0718 SUBSTITUTE A AS AMENDED

=======

LC02041/SUB A

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2013

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION

     Introduced By: Senators Sheehan, Walaska, Felag, Goodwin, and Jabour

     Date Introduced: March 13, 2013

     Referred To: Senate Commerce

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Section 42-64-1.1 of the General Laws in Chapter 42-64 entitled "Rhode

1-2

Island Economic Development Corporation" is hereby amended to read as follows:

1-3

     42-64-1.1. Change of name. -- (a) Whenever in any general or public law, reference is

1-4

made to the "department of economic development" or the "Rhode Island port authority and

1-5

economic development corporation", or the "Rhode Island economic development corporation",

1-6

the reference shall be deemed to refer to and mean the "Rhode Island economic development

1-7

corporation" "Rhode Island commerce corporation", which may also be referred to as the

1-8

"economic development commerce corporation".

1-9

      (b) Whenever in any general or public law, reference is made to the "director of the

1-10

department of economic development" or the "executive director of the Rhode Island port

1-11

authority and economic development corporation" or "the executive director of the economic

1-12

development corporation", the reference shall be deemed to refer to and mean the "executive

1-13

director of the Rhode Island economic development commerce corporation".

1-14

      (c) Whenever in any general or public law, reference is made to the "economic

1-15

development council" or "the board of directors of the Rhode Island economic development

1-16

corporation", the reference shall be deemed to refer to and mean the "board of directors of the

1-17

Rhode Island economic development commerce corporation".

1-18

     (d) Nothing in this act shall be construed to change or modify any contracts or

1-19

agreements of any kind by, for, between, or to which the economic development corporation is a

2-1

party. All said contracts and agreements of whatsoever kind are hereby assigned, transferred to

2-2

and assumed by the Rhode Island commerce corporation.

2-3

     SECTION 2. Sections 42-64-8, 42-64-9.9, and 42-64-31 of the General Laws in Chapter

2-4

42-64 entitled "Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation" are hereby amended to read

2-5

as follows

2-6

     42-64-8. Directors, officers, and employees. -- (a) The powers of the Rhode Island

2-7

economic development corporation shall be vested in a board of directors consisting of thirteen

2-8

(13) fourteen (14) members.

2-9

      (1) The governor shall serve as a member of the board and as chairperson, ex-officio,

2-10

who shall vote only in the event of a tie.

2-11

     (2) The chairperson of the governor's workforce development board, or his or her

2-12

designee, shall serve as a member of the board.

2-13

     (2)(3) In addition to the governor and the chairperson of the governor's workforce

2-14

development board, or his or her designee, the membership of the board shall consist of twelve

2-15

(12) public members to be appointed by the governor.

2-16

      (3)(4) Each gubernatorial appointee shall be subject to the advice and consent of the

2-17

senate and no one shall be eligible for appointment unless he or she is a resident of this state. The

2-18

membership of the board shall reflect the geographic diversity of the state. Four (4) of the public

2-19

members shall be owners or principals of small businesses doing business in this state which are

2-20

independently owned and operated and which employs one hundred (100) or fewer persons. One

2-21

other of the public members shall be a representative of a minority-owned company. One other of

2-22

the public members shall be a representative of organized labor. One other of the public members

2-23

shall be a representative of higher education. One other of the public members shall be appointed

2-24

on an interim basis by the governor when a project plan of the corporation situated on federal

2-25

land is disapproved by the governing body of a municipality in accordance with section 42-64-

2-26

13(a)(4). The member shall be the mayor of the municipality within whose borders all or a

2-27

majority of the project plan is to be carried out, or in a municipality, which has no mayor, the

2-28

member shall be the president of the town or city council. The appointed interim member shall

2-29

have all the powers of other members of the board only in its deliberations and action on the

2-30

disapproval of the project plan situated on federal land and within the borders of his or her

2-31

municipality. Upon final action by the board pursuant to section 42-64-13(a)(5), the interim

2-32

member's term of appointment shall automatically terminate.

2-33

      (4)(5) It shall be the responsibility of the corporation to conduct a training course for

2-34

newly appointed and qualified members and new designees of ex-officio members within six (6)

3-1

months of their qualification or designation. The course shall be developed by the executive

3-2

director of the corporation or his or her designee, be approved by the board, and conducted by the

3-3

executive director or his or her designee. The board may approve the use of any board or staff

3-4

members or other individuals to assist with training. The training course shall include instruction

3-5

in the following areas: the provisions of the entirety of chapter 64 of this title and of chapters 46

3-6

of this title, 14 of title 36, and 2 of title 38 of the Rhode Island general laws; and the board's rules

3-7

and regulations. The director of the department of administration shall, within ninety (90) days of

3-8

July 15, 2005, prepare and disseminate materials relating to the provisions of chapters 46 of this

3-9

title, 14 of title 36, and 2 of title 38.

3-10

      (5)(6) Public Members members of the board shall be removable by the governor,

3-11

pursuant to the provisions of section 36-1-7 and for cause only, and removal solely for partisan or

3-12

personal reasons unrelated to capacity or fitness for the office shall be unlawful.

3-13

      (6)(7) The five (5) current members of the board of directors who were duly appointed

3-14

and who have unexpired terms shall continue as directors of the corporation until February 1,

3-15

2010, and thereafter until their successors are appointed and qualified. Upon passage of this act,

3-16

the governor shall appoint seven (7) members to the board, with terms expiring as follows: three

3-17

(3) members shall have terms expiring on February 1, 2011; three (3) members shall have terms

3-18

expiring on February 1, 2012; and one member shall have a term expiring on February 1, 2013. In

3-19

January 2010, the governor shall appoint five (5) members to the board with terms expiring as

3-20

follows: two (2) members shall have terms expiring on February 1, 2013 and three (3) members

3-21

shall have terms expiring on February 1, 2014. Beginning in 2011 and annually thereafter, during

3-22

the month of January, the governor shall appoint a member or members to succeed the member or

3-23

members whose terms will then next expire to serve for a term of four (4) years commencing on

3-24

the first day of February and then next following, and thereafter until the successors are appointed

3-25

and qualified. Beginning in 2011 and annually thereafter the governor shall appoint owners or

3-26

principals of small businesses doing business in this state which are independently owned and

3-27

operated, and which employs one hundred (100) or fewer persons. The members of the board

3-28

shall be eligible to succeed themselves, but only upon reappointment and with senate advice and

3-29

consent.

3-30

      (7)(8) In the event of a vacancy occurring in the office of a member by death, resignation

3-31

or otherwise, that vacancy shall be filled in the same manner as an original appointment, but only

3-32

for the remainder of the term of the former member.

3-33

      (b) The directors shall receive no compensation for the performance of their duties under

3-34

this chapter, but each director shall be reimbursed for his or her reasonable expenses incurred in

4-1

carrying out those duties. A director may engage in private employment, or in a profession or

4-2

business.

4-3

      (c) The chairperson shall designate a vice chairperson from among the members of the

4-4

board who shall serve at the pleasure of the chairperson. A majority of directors holding office

4-5

shall constitute a quorum, and, except as otherwise provided in section 42-64-13, any action to be

4-6

taken by the corporation under the provisions of this chapter may be authorized by resolution

4-7

approved by a majority of the directors present and entitled to vote at any regular or special

4-8

meeting at which a quorum is present. A vacancy in the membership of the board of directors

4-9

shall not impair the right of a quorum to exercise all of the rights and perform all of the duties of

4-10

the corporation.

4-11

      (d) The chief executive officer of the corporation shall be executive director of the

4-12

corporation, appointed by the governor with the advice and consent of the senate. The executive

4-13

director shall hold office for the term of three (3) years from the time of his or her appointment

4-14

and until his or her successor is duly appointed and qualified. The director shall be eligible for

4-15

reappointment, and shall not engage in any other occupation. The executive director of the

4-16

corporation shall be entitled to receive for his or her services any reasonable compensation as the

4-17

board of directors may determine.

4-18

      (e) The board of directors shall appoint a secretary and such additional officers and staff

4-19

members as they shall deem appropriate and shall determine the amount of reasonable

4-20

compensation, if any, each shall receive. The board of directors may vest in the executive

4-21

director, or the director's subordinates, the authority to appoint additional staff members and to

4-22

determine the amount of compensation each individual shall receive.

4-23

      (f) No full-time employee shall during the period of his or her employment by the

4-24

corporation engage in any other private employment, profession or business, except with the

4-25

approval of the board of directors during an open meeting.

4-26

      (g) Notwithstanding any other law to the contrary, it shall not be or constitute a conflict

4-27

of interest for a director, officer, or employee of any financial institution, investment banking

4-28

firm, brokerage firm, commercial bank, trust company, building-loan association, architecture

4-29

firm, insurance company, or any other firm, person, or corporation to serve as a director of the

4-30

corporation, nor shall any contract or transaction between the corporation and a financial

4-31

institution, investment banking firm, brokerage firm, commercial bank, trust company, building-

4-32

loan association, architecture firm, insurance company, or other firm, person, or corporation be

4-33

void or voidable by reason of that service as director of the corporation. If any director, officer, or

4-34

employee of the corporation shall be interested either directly or indirectly, or shall be a director,

5-1

officer, or employee of or have an ownership interest (other than as the owner of less than one

5-2

percent (1%) of the shares of a publicly-held corporation) in any firm or corporation interested

5-3

directly or indirectly in any contract with the corporation, that interest shall be disclosed to the

5-4

corporation and set forth in the minutes of the corporation, and the director, officer, or employee

5-5

having that ownership interest shall not participate on behalf of the corporation in the

5-6

authorization of that contract. Interested directors may be counted in determining the presence of

5-7

a quorum at a meeting of the board of directors of the corporation, which authorizes the contract

5-8

or transaction.

5-9

      (h) Any action taken by the corporation under the provisions of this chapter may be

5-10

authorized by vote at any regular or special meeting, and each vote shall take effect immediately.

5-11

All meetings shall be open to the public and all records shall be a matter of public record except

5-12

that if a majority of the board of directors decides that it would be in the best interests of the

5-13

corporation and the state to hold an executive session in private, then the board of directors is

5-14

authorized to transact any business it deems necessary at that executive session in private, and the

5-15

record of the executive session shall not become a matter of public record until the transaction

5-16

discussed has in the opinion of the board of directors been completed. The corporation shall be

5-17

subject to the provisions of chapter 42-46 ("Open Meetings") and chapter 38-2 ("Access to Public

5-18

Records").

5-19

      (i) The board of directors may designate from among its members an executive

5-20

committee and one or more other committees each of which, to the extent authorized by the board

5-21

of directors, shall have and may exercise all of the authority of the board of directors, but no

5-22

executive committee shall have the authority of the board of directors in reference to the

5-23

disposition of all or substantially all of the property and assets of the corporation, amending the

5-24

by-laws of the corporation, exercising the condemnation power conferred upon the corporation by

5-25

section 42-64-9 or taking actions described or referred to in section 42-64-13(a).

5-26

      (j) Any action required by this chapter to be taken at a meeting of the board of directors,

5-27

or any action which may be taken at a meeting of the board of directors, or committee of the

5-28

board of directors, may be taken without a meeting if a consent in writing, setting forth the action

5-29

to be taken, shall be signed before or after that action by all of the directors, or all of the members

5-30

of the committee, as the case may be.

5-31

      (k) (j) Employees of the corporation shall not, by reason of their employment, be deemed

5-32

to be employees of the state for any purpose, any other provision of the general laws to the

5-33

contrary notwithstanding, including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, chapters 29,

5-34

39, and 42 of title 28 and chapters 4, 8, 9, and 10 of title 36.

6-1

     42-64-9.9. Public access to information. -- Any permit, permit application or effluent

6-2

data shall be available to the public for inspection and copying. The Rhode Island economic

6-3

development corporation shall treat as privileged any information, which would, if made public,

6-4

divulge methods or processes entitled to protections as trade secrets of the person or entity. in

6-5

accordance with chapter 38-2 ("Access to Public Records"). Confidential or privileged materials

6-6

may be disclosed or transmitted to other officers, employees or agents of the corporation.

6-7

     42-64-31. Other statutes. -- Nothing contained in this chapter shall restrict or limit the

6-8

powers of the Rhode Island economic development corporation arising under any laws of this

6-9

state except where those powers are expressly contrary to the provisions of this chapter; provided,

6-10

however, that the corporation shall not have any power to create, empower or otherwise establish

6-11

any corporation, subsidiary corporation, corporate body, any form of partnership, or any other

6-12

separate entity, without the express approval and authorization of the general assembly. Except as

6-13

otherwise provided, this chapter shall be construed to provide a complete additional and

6-14

alternative method for doing the things authorized hereby and shall be regarded as supplemental

6-15

and in addition to the powers conferred by other laws. The issuance of all bonds, notes, and other

6-16

obligations of the corporation under the provisions of this chapter need not comply with the

6-17

requirements of any other statute applicable to the issuance of bonds, notes and obligations, and

6-18

contracts for the construction and acquisition of any project undertaken pursuant to this chapter

6-19

need not comply with any provision of any other state law applicable to contracts for the

6-20

construction and acquisition of state owned property, except that the provisions of section 37-13-

6-21

1 et seq. (prevailing wage); section 37-16-2 et seq. (public works arbitration); and section 37-12-1

6-22

et seq. (contractors' bonds) for the construction and acquisition of state or municipally owned

6-23

property shall be applicable. No proceedings or notice of approval shall be required for the

6-24

issuance of any bonds, notes, and other obligations or any instrument of security except as

6-25

provided in this chapter.

6-26

     SECTION 3. Chapter 42-64 of the General Laws entitled "Rhode Island Economic

6-27

Development Corporation" is hereby amended by adding thereto the following sections:

6-28

     42-64-8.2. Role and responsibilities of board members. – (a) Board members of the

6-29

corporation shall:

6-30

     (1) Execute direct oversight of the corporation and the chief executive and other

6-31

management in the effective and ethical management of the corporation;

6-32

     (2) Understand, review, and monitor the implementation of fundamental financial and

6-33

management controls and operational decisions of the corporation;

7-34

     (3) Adopt a code of ethics applicable to each officer, director and employee of the

7-35

corporation that, at a minimum, includes the standards established in chapter 36-14 ("Code of

7-36

Ethics");

7-37

     (4) Adopt a mission statement expressing the purpose and goals of the corporation, a

7-38

description of the stakeholders of the corporation and their reasonable expectations from the

7-39

corporation, and a list of measurements by which performance of the corporation and the

7-40

achievement of its goals may be evaluated. The corporation shall at least once every three (3)

7-41

years publish a self-evaluation based on the stated measurements;

7-42

     (5) Adopt and periodically update an indemnification policy which shall be set forth in

7-43

the bylaws of the corporation;

7-44

     (6) Establish quantifiable performance measurements for all programs of the corporation

7-45

and its subsidiaries that will assist the board in evaluating program effectiveness and inform

7-46

policymaking and resource allocation decisions;

7-47

     (7) Establish an access to capital advisory committee and appoint at least seven (7) public

7-48

members representing diverse interests; and

7-49

     (8) Perform each of their duties as board members, including, but not limited to, those

7-50

imposed by this section, in good faith and with that degree of diligence, care, and skill which an

7-51

ordinarily prudent person in like position would use under similar circumstances and ultimately

7-52

apply independent judgment in the best interest of the corporation, its mission, and the public.

7-53

     (b) Board members of the corporation shall establish and maintain written policies and

7-54

procedures for the following:

7-55

     (1) Internal accounting and administrative controls in accordance with the provisions of

7-56

chapter 35-20 ("Public Corporation Financial Integrity and Accountability Act of 1995");

7-57

     (2) Travel, including lodging, meals, and incidental expenses, provided that no

7-58

reimbursement shall exceed the allowable state employee reimbursement amount per day;

7-59

     (3) Charitable and civic donations and/or contributions, provided, however, that all such

7-60

donations or contributions shall be voted by the full board during an open meeting and the vote

7-61

shall be recorded in the minutes of the meeting, together with:

7-62

     (i) The citation to the specific state statute authorizing the action;

7-63

     (ii) An explanation of how the donation or contribution relates to the mission of the

7-64

corporation;

7-65

     (iii) The identity of each board member or employee of the corporation that will receive

7-66

any benefit from the donation or contribution including, without limitation, tickets to events,

7-67

meals, and golf;

8-68

     (iv) Any disclosure required by chapter 36-14 ("Code of Ethics"); and

8-69

     (v) Each such donation or contribution shall be clearly identified in the financial

8-70

statements of the corporation.

8-71

     (4) Credit card use, provided, that pursuant to section 35-20-10, no credit card shall be

8-72

used for personal use;

8-73

     (5) Employee reimbursement, including requests by management for business expenses,

8-74

and expenses classified as gifts or entertainment;

8-75

     (6) Personnel, including hiring, dismissing, promoting, and compensating employees of

8-76

the corporation, and provided that no employee of the corporation shall be compensated for sick,

8-77

vacation, or other leave time to an extent greater than state employees;

8-78

     (7) Severance pay;

8-79

     (8) Marketing expenses; and

8-80

     (9) Lobbyists' expenses.

8-81

     (c) The written policies and procedures required by this section and any additional

8-82

written policies and procedures that the board may adopt shall be approved by the board during

8-83

an open meeting and the vote shall be recorded in the minutes of the meeting.

8-84

     (d) Any board member who fails to attend more than fifty percent (50%) of all meetings

8-85

held during any calendar year shall be deemed to have resigned, unless the board member

8-86

requests, in writing, to the chairperson to serve the remaining term of his or her appointment,

8-87

setting forth the reason or reasons for the absences, and the majority of the board members

8-88

approve the request in an open meeting.

8-89

     (e) No board member shall serve in a paid or voluntary capacity as an officer, employee,

8-90

or consultant of the corporation.

8-91

     42-64-8.3. Executive compensation. – (a) The corporation shall establish a committee

8-92

on executive compensation which shall meet independently of management and which shall:

8-93

     (1) Recommend to the full board the compensation packages of the executive and senior

8-94

management of the corporation. The compensation package of the executive officer shall be

8-95

based on a comprehensive and objective analysis of comparable compensation of similar officers

8-96

of state government, other authorities, quasi-public corporations, and private-sector employees

8-97

with similar functions and responsibilities. The committee may retain a consultant to assist in the

8-98

comparability study. When calculating compensation, the committee shall consider the value of

8-99

the retirement plan in the overall compensation package;

8-100

     (2) Prepare clear written job descriptions and clear written expectations of job

8-101

performance for the executive officer and senior management;

9-102

     (3) Conduct the job performance review of the executive officer at least annually; and

9-103

     (4) Negotiate the employment contract of the executive officer which shall be approved

9-104

by the full board during an open meeting.

9-105

     42-64-8.4. Transparency requirements established. – The following shall be public

9-106

record, available to the public upon request and posted directly and not via link, on the website of

9-107

the corporation:

9-108

     (1) Job descriptions of the executive director and management;

9-109

     (2) Employment contracts of the executive director and management;

9-110

     (3) Executive and senior management compensation studies pursuant to section 42-64-

9-111

8.3;

9-112

     (4) Monthly financial statements;

9-113

     (5) Capital improvement plans;

9-114

     (6) Operating budgets;

9-115

     (7) Strategic plans;

9-116

     (8) Agendas and minutes of the open meetings of the board of the corporation and the

9-117

boards of the corporation's subsidiaries, provided, however, that this posting provision shall not

9-118

apply to the Quonset development corporation, the Rhode Island airport corporation, the I-195

9-119

redevelopment district and the East Providence waterfront district;

9-120

     (9) Quarterly reporting required by section 42-90-1;

9-121

     (10) All regulations of the corporation;

9-122

     (11) Enabling legislation;

9-123

     (12) Mission statement and board self-evaluation required by subdivision 42-64-

9-124

8.2(a)(4);

9-125

     (13) Board members;

9-126

     (14) Organizational chart;

9-127

     (15) Bylaws of the corporation;

9-128

     (16) All reports and audits required by this chapter; and

9-129

     (17) Within ten (10) business days of execution, a copy of each contract for legal,

9-130

medical, accounting, engineering, or any other professional, financial, technical, or consultant

9-131

services for the corporation, consistent with the provisions of chapter 38-2 ("Access to Public

9-132

Records Act").

9-133

     42-64-31.1. Rules and regulations. – When issuing rules and regulations or any

9-134

amendments to rules and regulations or when adopting bylaws or amendments to bylaws, the

9-135

corporation shall be subject to the provisions of chapter 42-35 ("Administrative Procedures").

10-136

     42-64-36. Loan and loan guarantee programs. – (a) No later than September 1, 2013,

10-137

the corporation shall adopt regulations that establish financing principles and guidelines,

10-138

including risk assessment, for all loans and guarantees awarded by the corporation or its

10-139

subsidiaries, provided, however, that this provision shall not apply to the Quonset development

10-140

corporation, the Rhode Island airport corporation, the I-195 redevelopment district and the East

10-141

Providence waterfront district. The corporation shall, prior to the award of a loan or guarantee,

10-142

document that each loan or guarantee complied with these regulations.

10-143

     (b) On or before January 1 of each year, the corporation shall issue a report on all loans

10-144

and loan guarantees issued by the corporation. The report shall include at a minimum:

10-145

     (1) With respect to loans, a list of each loan, a description of the borrower, the amount of

10-146

principal and interest outstanding on the loan as of the date of each report, and a summary of the

10-147

collateral securing the repayment of the loan.

10-148

     (2) With respect to loan guarantees, a list of each loan guarantee issued, a description of

10-149

the borrower on behalf of which the guarantee was issued, the lender or lenders that made the

10-150

loan and the amount of the loan to the borrower, the amount of principal and interest outstanding

10-151

on the loan as of the date of each report, and a summary of the collateral securing the repayment

10-152

of the loan for which the guarantee was issued.

10-153

     (3) With respect to loan and loan guarantees, a summary of the economic impacts made

10-154

by each borrower as a result of the loan or loan guarantee, including, but not limited to, the

10-155

number, type, and wages of jobs created by the borrower, any impacts on the industry in which

10-156

the borrower operates, and an estimate of income taxes for the state of Rhode Island generated by

10-157

the employees of the borrower and the borrower itself.

10-158

     (4) Copies of each report shall be submitted to the chairpersons of the house finance

10-159

committee and the senate finance committee.

10-160

     42-64-37. Audit of the corporation. – (a) Commencing July 1, 2014, and every three (3)

10-161

years thereafter, the corporation shall be subject to a performance audit conducted in compliance

10-162

with the generally acceptable governmental auditing standards, by the bureau of audits or a

10-163

certified public accounting firm qualified in performance audits.

10-164

     (b) If the audit is not directly performed by his or her office, the selection of the auditor

10-165

and the scope of the audit shall be subject to the approval of the chief of the bureau of audits.

10-166

     (c)  The audit shall be conducted in conformance with subsections 35-7-3(b) through (d). 

10-167

     (d) The results of the audit shall be made public upon completion, posted on the websites

10-168

of the bureau of audits and the corporation.

10-169

     (e) The corporation shall be responsible for all costs associated with the audit.

11-170

      SECTION 4. Section 1 of this act shall take effect six (6) months after the date

11-171

of passage. The remaining sections of this act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC02041/SUB A

========

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT - ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION

***

12-1

     This act would change the name of the economic development corporation to the Rhode

12-2

Island commerce corporation and would also establish transparency and accountability provisions

12-3

with respect to its operations and governance.

12-4

     Section 1 of this act shall take effect six (6) months after the date of passage. The

12-5

remaining sections of this act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC02041/SUB A

=======