2014 -- H 8068

========

LC005451

========

     STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2014

____________

A N   A C T

RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT

     Introduced By: Representatives Carnevale, Marshall, Hull, Palangio, and Almeida

     Date Introduced: April 17, 2014

     Referred To: House Finance

     It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

     SECTION 1. Title 42 of the General Laws entitled "STATE AFFAIRS AND

GOVERNMENT" is hereby amended by adding thereto the following chapter:

CHAPTER 64.20

THE 111 WESTMINSTER STREET HISTORIC REDEVELOPMENT AND ECONOMIC

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

     42-64.20-1. Declaration of purpose. – (a) the general assembly finds and declares the

building located at 111 Westminster Street, city of Providence, county of Providence, state of

Rhode Island (hereinafter referred to as "111 Westminster") is an iconic historic structure that has

and will continue to play a crucial role in the vitality of downtown Providence and the historic

fabric of the state. 111 Westminster is among the most visible and prominent buildings in the

capital city's skyline. 111 Westminster is a certified historic structure as defined under Rhode

Island general laws § 44-33.6-2 and its preservation shall foster civic beauty, promote public

education, pleasure and welfare and otherwise generally improve and enhance the economic

wellbeing of the citizens of the state of Rhode Island. The general assembly recognizes that, like

most historic structures in central business districts across the state of Rhode Island, without

providing economic incentives or assistance, 111 Westminster is not viable for redevelopment

and reuse by modem commercial, residential or manufacturing enterprises. The high cost of

redeveloping 111 Westminster is prohibitive to placing the building back into service at its

highest and best use for the overall city and state economies and, as such, is at serious risk of

further deterioration and continued vacancy, which shall serve to detract from neighboring

properties and the capital city's downtown as a whole. The purpose of this chapter is to create an

economic investment package by way of a public-private partnership to stimulate the

redevelopment of 111 Westminster, stabilize the commercial office market in downtown

Providence, preserve and potentially enhance property values in the capital city's downtown, as

well as generate positive economic and employment activities that will result from the

redevelopment and reuse of the building.

     (b) The general assembly recognizes that the commercial office space market in

downtown Providence has over one million square feet (1,000,000 sq. ft.) of vacant office space.

This overwhelming vacancy rate would only be further exacerbated if 111 Westminster flooded

the market with more than three hundred fifty thousand square feet (350,000 sq. ft.) of additional

vacant space. Conversely, the downtown Providence has one of the highest residential rental

apartment occupancy rates in the county of Providence. There is a clear shortage of apartment

units that needs to be addressed for the overall economic vitality of the city of Providence and

state of Rhode Island.

     (c) The highest and best use of 111 Westminster is to redevelop the building into a

modern mixed use building with commercial, retail and public space on the ground floor and

approximately two hundred fifty (250) apartment units on the remaining floors of the building.

This will enhance the tax base of the city of Providence, stabilize the property values of the

surrounding properties, particularly commercial office buildings, and attract hundreds of new

residents to live in downtown Providence. This conversion will create approximately one

thousand (1,000) jobs related to redevelopment activities, and generate millions of dollars in

economic activity in the struggling construction industry. The establishment of a public-private

partnership with the owner of the building will attract over eighty million dollars ($80,000,000) in

private and federal investment in downtown Providence. The redevelopment of 111 Westminster

will generate over forty million dollars ($40,000,000) in wages paid to people working in Rhode

Island. The redevelopment of 111 Westminster will generate approximately one hundred million

five hundred thousand dollars ($100,500,000) in qualified rehabilitative expenditures as defined

by Rhode Island general law § 44-33.6-2. The presence of hundreds of new residents living in

downtown Providence will also benefit the restaurants, stores and other small businesses

currently located in downtown Providence, further strengthening commerce in the re-emerging

downtown.

     (d) Furthermore, the general assembly recognizes the need for a public-private

partnership with the owner of 111 Westminster. The state has experienced great success in

LC005451 - Page 2 of 8

investing in the rehabilitation of historic structures in various forms. In the past, investing in the

rehabilitation of historic structures has created thousand of jobs and generated hundreds of

millions of dollars in economic activity in the state, as well as preserved and enhanced property

values in many communities throughout the state. Due to the universally high costs of such

historic rehabilitation projects and the large scale of this particular project, the state of Rhode

Island's presently available economic incentive programs for redeveloping historic structures are

inadequate in scope. Given the high cost of the redevelopment of 111 Westminster and the

current market rental rates, this project cannot be financed without public support. The owner of

111 Westminster anticipates being able to secure approximately eighty million five hundred

thousand dollars ($80,500,000) in new equity, debt and the monetization of federal historic tax

credits for the anticipated redevelopment project. This leaves a need for state investment in the

project of thirty-nine million dollars ($39,000,000) to make the redevelopment of 111

Westminster financially viable. This chapter shall create an economic investment package by way

of a public-private partnership to stimulate the redevelopment of 111 Westminster and thereby

preserving and enhancing the capital city's downtown, creating needed employment

opportunities, and generating substantial direct and indirect positive economic activities/impact

that will result from the subject redevelopment project and the resulting use of same as a vibrant

mixed use building that preserves its iconic stature.

     42-64.20-2. Definitions. -- As used in this chapter:

     (1) "Certified rehabilitation" means any rehabilitation of a certified historic structure

consistent with the historic character of such property or the district in which the property is

located as determined by the guidelines of the Rhode Island historical preservation and heritage

commission created pursuant to § 42-45-2.

     (2) "Commission" means the Rhode Island historical preservation and heritage

commission created pursuant to § 42-45-2.

     (3) "Owner" means the individual, corporation, partnership or LLC that is the owner of

record of 111 Westminster.

     (4) "Placed in service" means that substantial rehabilitation work has been completed

which would allow for occupancy of a substantial portion of the structure, or the owner has

commenced depreciation of the qualified rehabilitation expenditures, whichever occurs first.

     (5) "Qualified Rehabilitative Expenditures" or "QREs" means any amounts expended in

the rehabilitation of a certified historic structure properly capitalized to the building and either:

     (i) Depreciable under the Internal Revenue Code, 26 U.S.C. l et seq.; or

     (ii) Made with respect to property held for sale by the owner.

LC005451 - Page 3 of 8

     (6) "Remain idle" means that work crews have been reduced by more than twenty-five

percent (25%) for reasons unrelated to scheduled completion of work in accordance with the

project schedule, reasonably unanticipated physical conditions, shortage or issues related to

scheduling of work force, or force majeure; or the project schedule that was originally submitted

by the owner to the commission has been extended by more than twelve (12) months for reasons

other than reasonably unanticipated physical conditions or an event of force majeure (by way of

example, and not in limitation, any delays, work stoppage or work force reduction caused by

issues with project funding, finances, disputes or violations of laws shall be deemed to cause the

project to remain idle).

     42-64.20-3. Historic redevelopment program and revolving fund. -- This chapter shall

establish the 111 Westminster historic redevelopment program and revolving fund. The program

shall be for an amount not to exceed thirty-nine million dollars ($39,000,000), provided that the

projects total QRE's equal or exceed one hundred million five hundred thousand dollars

($100,500,000). The amount of the direct allocation to the owner shall be allocated over four (4)

consecutive fiscal years in equal amounts of nine million seven hundred fifty dollars

($9,750,000), commencing with fiscal year 2015, and administered by the Rhode Island

department of administration. No funds from the program shall be released until the project is

placed in service. As the project's construction phase is expected to take approximately two (2)

years, the first fiscal year's payment of the allocated funds shall be held by the state in escrow and

not paid until the completion of the project. Thus, the payment of the funds in the second fiscal

year shall be nineteen million five hundred thousand dollars ($19,500,000) and then payments of

nine million seven hundred fifty thousand dollars ($9,750,000) in each of the following fiscal

years. Following the funding of the fourth and final payment, upon a capital event resulting from

the sale or refinancing of the project, any amount paid to the owner under this program above

thirty percent (30%) of QREs shall be repaid to the state of Rhode Island prior to the owner

realizing any return over the actual amounts invested in the project (the "refundable investment

component"). By way of example, upon such a capital event, the proceeds shall go first to

repaying third-party debt, then to repayment of equity invested (without any interest or profit

thereon), and then to repay the refundable grant component (with any balance after such

repayment going to owner). Capital events involving 111 Westminster shall be subject to the

foregoing repayment until such time as the state of Rhode Island has recovered, in the aggregate,

the entire refundable grant component. The refundable investment component of the project shall

be placed into a revolving fund created and administered by the state of Rhode Island to

rehabilitate historic structures in need of assistance across the state. The revolving fund shall be

LC005451 - Page 4 of 8

established and administered in accordance with Rhode Island law. The specific payment

schedule and funding of the program shall be established by the Rhode Island department of

administration. The owner intends to obtain financing in anticipation of the aforementioned

funding of the program.

     42-64.20-4. Procedure and oversight. -- The owner shall, within nine (9) months from

passage of this chapter, submit a redevelopment proposal to the commission and the department

of administration for review. The owner shall be allowed two (2) ninety (90) day extensions if the

delay in providing the report is caused by forced outside of the reasonable control of the owner.

Said proposal shall include detailed redevelopment plans, a detailed project budget and all

relevant financial information and documentation, including, but not limited to, the project's

equity sources, anticipated debt sources, expected federal tax credits, and anticipated QREs. The

owner shall also include a construction timeline demonstrating a time frame during which work

shall begin and be completed. Upon receipt of the proposal, the commission shall review the

proposed redevelopment of the building for the purpose of certifying the rehabilitation as

compliant with the historic character of the building and the surrounding district pursuant to the

commission's current guidelines for rehabilitation of historic structures. The commission shall

complete its review and issue its certification (or a detailed report setting forth the elements of

non-compliance) within thirty (30) days of its receipt of such proposal or any resubmission

thereof. Upon substantial completion of the rehabilitation and the project being placed in service,

the commission shall, within thirty (30) days of the owner notifying the commission of

substantial completion, certify that the rehabilitation has been completed in accordance with its

guidelines (or issue a detailed report setting forth the elements of non-compliance). Upon

substantial completion of the rehabilitation, the owner shall provide the department of

administration a schedule of the actual QREs, a list of contractors and subcontractors that worked

on the project, the number of tradespersons employed on the project, the name, state of residence,

occupation, number of hours worked, and actual wages and fringe benefits paid to each worker

employed by the owner and/or any of its contractors or subcontractors and verification of

apprenticeship programs and the number of hours of work completed by apprentices on the

QREs. The department of administration shall work with the department of labor and training to

certify the accuracy of the information provided by the owner. Provided that owner has

substantially complied with the commission guidelines and the terms and conditions of this

chapter, the applicable portion of the grant shall be funded within sixty (60) days of the project

being placed in service.

     During the construction phase of the rehabilitation of 111 Westminster, the owner shall

LC005451 - Page 5 of 8

provide quarterly updates on the progress and financial status of the project to the department of

administration. These reports shall include an approximate schedule of the QREs, a list of

contractors and subcontractors that worked on the project, the number of tradespersons employed

on the project, the name, state of residence, occupation, number of hours worked, and actual

wages and fringe benefits paid to each worker employed by the owner and/or any of its

contractors or subcontractors and verification of apprenticeship programs and the number of

hours of work completed by apprentices on the QREs. Furthermore, the department of

administration, for the purpose of ascertaining the correctness of any claim made by the owner

under the provisions of this chapter, may examine any books, papers, records or memoranda

bearing upon the matters required to be included in the reports or any other statement.

     42-64.20-5. Completion and economic benefit bond guaranty. -- The owner shall

contract for and or purchase a private bond from an institution mutually agreed upon by the

owner and the department of administration. This bond shall be for an amount sufficient to

guaranty the completion of the project thus ensuring that all the economic and employment

benefits to the state of Rhode Island are realized in the event that the owner is financially unable

to complete the project or the project should remain idle as defined in this chapter. The bond

company shall have no recourse against the state of Rhode Island and the cost of said completion

bond shall be borne entirely by the owner. The terms of the bond must ensure that the work of

rehabilitating 111 Westminster in accordance with the terms of this chapter and the proposal

approved by the commission is completed and all of the wages owed and materials costs are paid

as anticipated.

     42-64.20-6. Workforce development. -- All contractors and subcontractors who perform

work on the 111 Westminster rehabilitation shall have an apprenticeship program for all

apprenticeable crafts that will be employed on the project at the time of bid, and that no less than

ten percent (10%) of the labor hours worked on the project shall be performed by apprentices in

these programs unless there is a demonstration of a lack of availability of apprentices or a written

determination by the department of administration that compliance with the apprenticeship

requirements are unduly cost prohibitive. The provisions of this section shall apply only to

contractors and subcontractors with five (5) or more employees. To the extent that any of the

provisions contained herein conflict with the requirements for federal historic tax credits, federal

law and regulations shall govern.

     42-64.20-7. Payment of wages. -- The owner and/or all contractors and subcontractors

working on the 111 Westminster project pursuant to this chapter shall comply with the

requirements of § 37-13-7.

LC005451 - Page 6 of 8

     42-64.20-8. Kennedy Plaza revitalization fund. -- In recognition of the critical relation

between the success of a clean, safe and active Kennedy Plaza and the success of 111

Westminster, the owner shall establish an endowment fund for the maintenance, enhancement and

programming of Kennedy Plaza, or otherwise fund an organization charged with maintaining,

enhancing and programming Kennedy Plaza, and shall contribute fifty thousand dollars ($50,000)

annually to said fund or organization, as applicable. The owner shall make said contributions for

a period of ten (10) years or until the owner has paid back the refundable grant component.

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

========

LC005451

========

LC005451 - Page 7 of 8

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N   A C T

RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT

***

     This act would provide economic incentives and assistance for the redevelopment of 111

Westminster Street using a public-private partnership.

     This act would take effect upon passage.

========

LC005451

========

LC005451 - Page 8 of 8