2014 -- S 2690 SUBSTITUTE A

========

LC004420/SUB A/3

========

     STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2014

____________

A N   A C T

RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS - THE CLEAN ENERGY JOBS

PROGRAM

     

     Introduced By: Senators Sosnowski, Walaska, Conley, Cool Rumsey, and Bates

     Date Introduced: March 05, 2014

     Referred To: Senate Environment & Agriculture

     It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1

     SECTION 1. Title 39 of the General Laws entitled "PUBLIC UTILITIES AND

2

CARRIERS" is hereby amended by adding thereto the following chapter:

3

CHAPTER 26.6

4

THE RENEWABLE ENERGY GROWTH PROGRAM

5

     39-26.6-1. Purpose. -- The purpose of this chapter is to facilitate and promote installation

6

of grid-connected generation of renewable energy; support and encourage development of

7

distributed renewable energy generation systems; reduce environmental impacts; reduce carbon

8

emissions that contribute to climate change by encouraging the siting of renewable energy

9

projects in the load zone of the electric distribution company; diversify the energy generation

10

sources within the load zone of the electric distribution company; stimulate economic

11

development; improve distribution system resilience and reliability within the load zone of the

12

electric distribution company; and reduce distribution system costs.

13

     39-26.6-2. Renewable energy growth program established. -- To carry out these

14

purposes, a tariff-based renewable energy distributed generation financing program, hereinafter

15

referred to as the renewable energy growth program, is hereby established with the intention of

16

continuing the development of renewable energy distributed generation in the load zone of the

17

electric distribution company at reasonable cost. The program shall be designed to finance the

18

development, construction, and operation of renewable energy distributed generation projects

 

1

over five (5) years through a performance based incentive system that is designed to achieve

2

specified megawatt targets at reasonable cost through competitive processes. The renewable

3

energy growth program shall be implemented by the electric distribution company, and guided by

4

the distributed generation board, in consultation with the office of energy resources, subject to the

5

review and supervision of the commission.

6

     39-26.6-3. Definitions. -- When used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the

7

following meanings:

8

     (1) "Commission" means the Rhode Island public utilities commission.

9

     (2) "Board" shall mean the distributed generation board as established pursuant to the

10

provisions of § 39-26.2-10 under the title distributed generation standard contract board, but shall

11

also fulfill the responsibilities set forth in this chapter.

12

     (3) "Commercial scale solar project" means a solar distributed generation project with the

13

nameplate capacity specified in section 7 of this chapter.

14

     (4) "Distributed generation facility" means an electrical generation facility located in the

15

electric distribution company's load zone with a nameplate capacity no greater than five

16

megawatts (5 MW), using eligible renewable energy resources as defined by § 39-26-5, including

17

biogas created as a result of anaerobic digestion, but, specifically excluding all other listed

18

eligible biomass fuels, and connected to an electrical power system owned, controlled, or

19

operated by the electric distribution company. For purposes of this chapter, a distributed

20

generation facility must be a new resource that:

21

     (i) Has not begun operation;

22

     (ii) Is not under construction, but excluding preparatory site work that is less than twenty-

23

five percent (25%) of the estimated total project cost; and

24

     (iii) Except for small scale solar projects, does not have in place investment or lending

25

agreements necessary to finance the construction of the facility prior to the submittal of an

26

application or bid for which the payment of performance based incentives are sought under this

27

chapter except to the extent that such financing agreements are conditioned upon the project

28

owner being awarded performance based incentives under the provisions of this chapter. For

29

purposes of this definition, pre-existing hydro generation shall be exempt from the provisions of

30

subsection (i) of this section, regarding operation, if the hydro generation facility will need a

31

material investment to restore or maintain reliable and efficient operation and meet all regulatory,

32

environmental or operational requirements. For purposes of this provision, "material investment"

33

shall mean investment necessary to allow the project to qualify as a new renewable energy

34

resource under § 39-26-2(2). To be eligible for this exemption, the hydro project developer at the

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 2 of 29

1

time of submitting a bid in the applicable procurement must provide reasonable evidence with its

2

bid application showing the level of investment needed along with any other facts that support a

3

finding that the investment is material, the determination of which shall be a part of the bid

4

review process set forth in § 39-26.6-16 for the award of bids.

5

     (5) "Distributed generation project" means a distinct installation of a distributed

6

generation facility. An installation will be considered distinct if it does not violate the

7

segmentation prohibition set forth in § 39-26.6-9.

8

     (6) "Electric distribution company" means a company defined in § 39-1-2(12), supplying

9

standard offer service, last resort service, or any successor service to end-use customers, but not

10

including the Block Island Power Company or the Pascoag Utility District.

11

     (7) "ISO-NE" means Independent System Operator-New England, the Regional

12

Transmission Organization for New England designated by the Federal Energy Regulatory

13

Commission.

14

     (8) "Large distributed generation project" means a distributed generation project that has

15

a nameplate capacity that exceeds the size of a small distributed generation project in a given

16

year, but is no greater than five megawatts (5 MW) nameplate capacity.

17

     (9) "Large scale solar project" means a solar distributed generation project with the

18

nameplate capacity specified in § 39-26.6-7.

19

     (10) "Medium scale solar project" means a solar distributed generation project with the

20

nameplate capacity specified in § 39-26.6-7.

21

     (11) "Office" means the Rhode Island office of energy resources.

22

     (12) "Program year" means a year beginning April 1 and ending March 31 except for the

23

first program year, which may commence after April 1, 2015, subject to commission approval.

24

     (13) "Renewable energy classes" means categories for different renewable energy

25

technologies using eligible renewable energy resources as defined by § 39-26-5 , including biogas

26

created as a result of anaerobic digestion, but, specifically excluding all other listed eligible

27

biomass fuels specified in § 39-26-2(6). For each program year, in addition to the classes of solar

28

distributed generation specified in § 39-26.6-7, the board shall determine the renewable energy

29

classes as are reasonably feasible for use in meeting distributed generation objectives from

30

renewable energy resources and are consistent with the goal of meeting the annual target for the

31

program year. The board may make recommendations to the commission to add, eliminate, or

32

adjust renewable energy classes for each program year, provided that the solar classifications set

33

forth in § 39-26.6-7 shall remain in effect for at least the first two (2) program years and no

34

distributed generation project may exceed five megawatts (5MW) of nameplate capacity.

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 3 of 29

1

     (14) "Renewable energy certificate" means a New England Generation Information

2

System renewable energy certificate as defined in § 39-26-2(13).

3

     (15) "Small scale solar project" means a solar distributed generation project with the

4

nameplate capacity specified in § 39-26.6-7.

5

     (16) "Small distributed generation project" means a distributed generation renewable

6

energy project that has a nameplate capacity within the following: Wind: fifty kilowatts (50 KW)

7

to one and one-half megawatts (1.5 MW); small scale solar projects and medium scale solar

8

projects with the capacity limits as specified in § 39-26.6-7. For technologies other than solar and

9

wind, the board shall set the nameplate capacity size limits, but such limits may not exceed one

10

(1MW) megawatt.

11

     (17) "Ceiling price" means the bidding price cap applicable to an enrollment for a given

12

distributed generation class, which shall be approved annually for each renewable energy class

13

pursuant to the procedure established in this chapter. The ceiling price for each technology should

14

be a price that would allow a private owner to invest in a given project at a reasonable rate of

15

return, based on recently reported and forecast information on the cost of capital, and the cost of

16

generation equipment. The calculation of the reasonable rate of return for a project shall include,

17

where applicable, any state or federal incentives including, but not limited to, tax incentives.

18

     39-26.6-4. Continuation of Board. -- (a) The distributed generation standard contract

19

board shall remain fully constituted and authorized as provided in chapter 26.2 of title 39

20

provided, however, that the name shall be changed to the "distributed generation board."

21

Additional purposes of the board shall be to:

22

     (1) Evaluate and make recommendations to the commission regarding ceiling prices and

23

annual targets, the make-up of renewable energy classifications eligible under the distributed

24

generation growth program, the terms of the tariffs, and other duties as set forth in this chapter;

25

     (2) Provide consistent, comprehensive, informed and publicly accountable involvement

26

by representatives of all interested stakeholders affected by, involved with, or knowledgeable

27

about the development of distributed generation projects that are eligible for performance-based

28

incentives under the distributed generation growth program; and

29

     (3) Monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of the distributed generation growth program.

30

     (b) The office, in consultation with the board, shall be authorized to hire or to request the

31

electric distribution company to hire the services of qualified consultants to perform ceiling price

32

studies subject to commission approval which shall be granted or denied within sixty (60) days of

33

receipt of such request from the office. The cost of such studies shall be recoverable through the

34

rate reconciliation provisions of the electric distribution company set forth in § 39-26.6-25,

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 4 of 29

1

subject to commission approval. In addition, the office, in consultation with the board, may

2

request the commission to approve other costs incurred by the board or the electric distribution

3

company to perform any other studies and reports, subject to the review and approval of the

4

commission, which shall be granted or denied within one hundred twenty (120) days of receipt of

5

such request from the office, and which shall be recoverable through the same reconciliation

6

provisions.

7

     39-26.6-5. Tariffs Proposed and Approved. -- (a) Each year for a period of at least five

8

(5) program years, the electric distribution company shall file tariffs with the commission that are

9

designed to provide a multi-year stream of performance-based incentives to eligible renewable

10

distributed generation projects for a term of years, under terms and conditions set forth in the

11

tariffs and approved by the commission. The tariffs shall set forth the rights and obligations of the

12

owner of the distributed generation project and the conditions upon which payment of

13

performance-based incentives by the electric distribution company will be paid. The tariffs shall

14

include the non-price conditions set forth in §§ 39-26.2-7(2)(i) – (vii) for small distributed

15

generation projects (other than small and medium scale solar), and large distributed generation

16

projects; provided, however, that the time periods for such projects to reach ninety percent (90%)

17

of output shall be extended to twenty-four (24) months (other than eligible anaerobic digestion

18

projects which shall be thirty-six (36) months and eligible small-scale hydro which shall be forty-

19

eight (48) months). The non-price conditions in the tariffs for small and medium scale solar shall

20

take into account the different circumstances for distributed generation projects of the smaller

21

sizes.

22

     (b) In addition to the tariff(s) the filing shall include the rules governing the solicitation

23

and enrollment process. The solicitation rules will be designed to ensure the orderly functioning

24

of the distributed generation growth program and shall be consistent with the legislative purposes

25

of this chapter.

26

     (c) In proposing the tariff(s) and solicitation rules applicable to each year, the tariff(s) and

27

rules shall be developed by the electric distribution company and will be reviewed by the office

28

and the board before being sent to the commission for its approval. The proposed tariffs shall

29

include the ceiling prices and term lengths for each tariff that are recommended by the board. The

30

term lengths shall be from fifteen (15) to twenty (20) years, provided, however, that the board

31

may recommend shorter terms for small scale solar projects. Whatever term lengths between

32

fifteen (15) and twenty (20) years are chosen for any given tariff, the evaluation of the bids for

33

that tariff shall be done on a consistent basis such that the same term lengths for competing bids

34

are used to determine the winning bids.

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 5 of 29

1

     (d) The board shall use the same standards for setting ceiling prices as set forth in § 39-

2

26.2-5. In setting the ceiling prices, the board may specifically consider:

3

     (1) Transactions for newly developed renewable energy resources, by technology and

4

size, in the ISO-NE control area and the northeast corridor;

5

     (2) Pricing from bids received during the previous program year;

6

     (3) Environmental benefits, including, but not limited to, reducing carbon emissions;

7

     (4) System benefits; and

8

     (5) Cost effectiveness.

9

     (e) At least forty-five (45) days before filing the tariff(s) and solicitation rules, the

10

electric distribution company shall provide the tariff(s) and rules in draft form to the board for

11

review. The commission shall have the authority to determine the final terms and conditions in

12

the tariff and rules. Once approved, the commission shall retain exclusive jurisdiction over the

13

performance based incentive payments, terms, conditions, rights, enforcement, and

14

implementation of the tariffs and rules, subject to appeals pursuant to chapter 5 of title 39.

15

     39-26.6-6. Permanence of Tariff Terms Once Set. -- It is the intention of the general

16

assembly in enacting this chapter that the developers, owners, investors, customers, and lenders

17

of the distributed generation projects receiving performance based incentives under the tariffs be

18

able to rely on the tariffs for the entire term of the applicable tariff for purposes of obtaining

19

financing. Consistent with that intention and expectation, the terms under the tariffs for a given

20

program year, once approved by the commission, shall not be altered in any way that would

21

undermine such reliance on those tariffs during the applicable terms of the tariffs; and in no

22

circumstance will the performance-based incentive rate paid to a renewable energy project

23

developer or owner be reduced during the term of the tariff once a renewable energy project has

24

qualified to receive a tariff under the terms of this chapter.

25

     39-26.6-7. Solar Project Size Categories. – (a) Tariff(s) shall be proposed for each of

26

the following solar distributed generation classes:

27

     (1) Small scale solar projects;

28

     (2) Medium scale solar projects;

29

     (3) Commercial scale solar projects; and

30

     (4) Large scale solar projects.

31

     (b) Such classes of solar distributed generation projects shall be established based on

32

nameplate megawatt size as follows:

33

     (1) Large scale: solar projects from one megawatt (1 MW) up to and including five

34

megawatts (5MW) nameplate capacity;

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 6 of 29

1

     (2) Commercial scale: solar projects greater than two hundred fifty kilowatts (250 kW),

2

but less than one megawatt (1 MW) nameplate capacity;

3

     (3) Medium scale: solar projects greater than twenty-five kilowatts (25 kW) up to and

4

including two hundred fifty kilowatts (250 kW) nameplate capacity; and

5

     (4) Small scale: solar projects up to and including twenty-five kilowatts (25 kW)

6

nameplate capacity.

7

     (c) Other classifications of solar projects may also be proposed by the board, subject to

8

the approval of the commission. After the second program year, the board may make

9

recommendations to the commission to adjust the size categories of the solar classes, provided

10

that the medium scale solar projects may not exceed two hundred fifty kilowatts (250 kW).

11

     39-26.6-8. Renewable Technologies Other Than Solar. -- Tariffs also shall be proposed

12

for on-shore wind and any other distributed generation technologies permissible under this

13

chapter that the board, in its discretion, recommends; provided, however, that no project shall

14

exceed five megawatts (5 MW) nameplate capacity. The electric distribution company shall file

15

tariffs for each technology and size categories recommended by the board pursuant to the

16

procedures set forth in this chapter.

17

     39-26.6-9. Project Segmentation Prohibition. -- In no case may a project developer be

18

allowed to segment a distributed generation project on the same parcel or contiguous parcels into

19

smaller sized projects in order to fall under a smaller size project classification. Notwithstanding

20

this prohibition, a project developer may designate a generation unit on the same parcel or

21

contiguous parcel for net metering or other means of participating in electricity markets, provided

22

that such unit or portion of such unit designated for net metering or other market participation is

23

not receiving performance-based incentives under this chapter, is capable of being segregated

24

electrically, is configured with such electrical segregation, and is separately metered. Further, a

25

project shall not be considered to have been segmented if:

26

     (1) There is a lapse of at least twenty-four (24) months between: (i) The commencement

27

of construction of new distributed generation units on a parcel that is the same as or is contiguous

28

with a parcel upon which a distributed generation project has already been constructed; and (ii)

29

The operation date of the pre-existing project; or

30

     (2) The new project is a different renewable technology.

31

     39-26.6-10. Timing and Schedule of Tariff Filings. -- (a) The electric distribution

32

company shall file with the commission the first set of tariffs and solicitation rules pursuant to

33

this chapter no later than November 15, 2014. Thereafter, the electric distribution company shall

34

make annual tariff and solicitation rules filings with the commission no later than November 15

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 7 of 29

1

prior to the beginning of the applicable program year, which tariffs and rules shall be applicable

2

for the next program year.

3

     (b) Upon receiving the filing from the electric distribution company, the commission

4

shall open a docket to consider the filing. The commission shall issue an order approving the

5

proposed tariffs and solicitation rules; provided, however, that the commission may make any

6

modifications that it deems appropriate consistent with the legislative purposes of this chapter as

7

set forth herein.

8

     (c) For the first program year, the commission shall issue its order approving tariff(s) and

9

solicitation rules by no later than March 31, 2015. Thereafter, the commission shall approve them

10

by February 15 of each succeeding year.

11

     (d) During the course of any program year, the electric distribution company may, at any

12

time, in consultation with the office and the board, propose tariff or solicitation rules

13

modifications. The commission shall consider such proposed modifications through an already

14

open or new docket, and shall issue its order within one hundred five (105) days of the filing of

15

the proposed modification. If approved, the proposed modification shall take effect for the next

16

enrollment event following the issuance of the commission's order.

17

     39-26.6-11. Power Purchase Agreements Not Required. -- The distributed generation

18

growth program shall be implemented and administered exclusively through the tariff structure

19

and procedures set forth in this chapter, and the electric distribution company shall not be

20

required to execute power purchase agreements for the procurement of the renewable energy

21

distributed generation capacity requirements set forth in this chapter.

22

     39-26.6-12. Annual Bidding and Enrollments. -- (a) With the exception of the first

23

program year (2015), the electric distribution company, in consultation with the board and office,

24

shall conduct at least three (3) tariff enrollments for each distributed generation class each

25

program year. For the first program year, the board may recommend that either two (2) or three

26

(3) enrollments be conducted.

27

     (b) During each program year the tariff enrollments shall have both an annual targeted

28

amount of nameplate megawatts ("annual MW target") and a nameplate megawatt target for each

29

separate enrollment event ("enrollment MW target"). The enrollment MW target shall comprise

30

the specific portion of the annual MW target sought to be obtained in that enrollment. The

31

enrollment MW targets shall be recommended by the board each year, subject to commission

32

approval. The board shall also recommend a megawatt target for each class ("class MW target")

33

that comprises a specified portion of the enrollment MW target, subject to commission approval.

34

If the electric distribution company, the office, and the board mutually agree, they may reallocate

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 8 of 29

1

megawatts during an enrollment from one class to another without commission approval if there

2

is an over-subscription in one class and an under-subscription in another, provided that the annual

3

MW Target is not being exceeded, except as provided in § 39-26.6-7.

4

     (c) The annual MW targets shall be established as follows; provided, however that at

5

least three megawatts (3 MW) of nameplate capacity shall be carved out exclusively for small

6

scale solar projects in each of the first four (4) program years:

7

     (1) For the first program year (2015), the annual MW target shall be twenty-five (25)

8

nameplate megawatts;

9

     (2) For the second program year, the annual targets shall be forty (40) nameplate

10

megawatts;

11

     (3) For the third and fourth program years, the annual target shall be forty (40) nameplate

12

megawatts, subject to the conditions set forth in § 39-26.6-12(f) having been met for the

13

applicable prior program year as determined in the manner specified in § 39-26.6-12(g); and

14

     (4) For the fifth program year, the annual target shall be set to obtain the balance of

15

capacity needed to achieve one hundred sixty (160) nameplate megawatts within the five (5) year

16

distributed generation growth program, subject to § 39-26.6-12(e) and the conditions set forth in §

17

39-26.6-12(f) having been met for the fourth program year as determined in the manner specified

18

in § 39-26.6-12(g).

19

     (d) During the fifth year of the distributed generation growth program, the board may

20

recommend to the commission an extension of time in the event that additional time is required to

21

achieve the full one hundred sixty (160) nameplate megawatt target of the program. The

22

commission shall approve the recommendation of the board; provided, however, that the

23

commission may make any modifications to the board's recommendation that the commission

24

deems appropriate, consistent with the legislative purposes of this chapter as set forth herein.

25

     (e) To the extent there was a shortfall of capacity procured under chapter 26.2 of title 39

26

from distributed generation procurements in 2014, such shortfall amount may be added to the one

27

hundred sixty megawatt (160MW) target for acquisition in the fifth program year under this

28

chapter. In no event shall the electric distribution company be required to exceed the aggregate

29

amount of one hundred sixty (160) nameplate capacity plus any such shortfall amount over the

30

five (5) years, but may do so voluntarily, in consultation with the board and subject to

31

commission approval.

32

     (f) The conditions specified in subsections (c)(3) and (c)(4) of this section are as follows:

33

(1) That it is reasonable to conclude that the bid prices submitted in the procurements for the

34

large scale solar and commercial scale solar classes were reasonably competitive in the

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 9 of 29

1

immediately preceding program year; (2) That it is reasonable to conclude that the annual MW

2

target specified for the next program year is reasonably achievable; and (3) That the electric

3

distribution company was able to, or with reasonably prudent efforts should have been able to,

4

perform the studies and system upgrades on a timely basis necessary to accommodate the number

5

of applications associated with the targets without materially adversely affecting other electric

6

distribution construction projects needed to provide reliable and safe electric distribution service.

7

To the extent the board or the commission concludes that any of these conditions have not been

8

met for the applicable program year, the board may recommend and/or the commission may

9

adopt a new annual MW target, based on the factors set forth in § 39-26.6-12(h).

10

     (g) Before the third, fourth, and fifth program years, each year the board shall review the

11

conditions specified in § 39-26.6-12(f) and make a recommendation to the commission for

12

findings as to whether they have been met for the applicable year. The recommendation shall be

13

filed with the commission, with copies to the office and the electric distribution company, and

14

any person who has made a written request to the commission to be included in such notification,

15

such list which may be obtained from the commission clerk, and a notice of such filing shall be

16

posted by the commission on its website. If no party files an objection to the recommended

17

findings within ten (10) business days of the posting, the commission may accept them without

18

hearings. If an objection is filed with a reasonable explanation for its basis, the commission shall

19

hold hearings and make the factual determination of whether the conditions have been met.

20

     (h) In the event that the conditions in § 39-26.6-12(f) have not been met for any program

21

year, then the board and the commission shall take into account the factors set forth below in

22

setting the annual MW target for the following year. In addition, for every program year the board

23

and the commission shall take into account these factors in setting the class MW targets, and the

24

enrollment MW targets for the following year: (1) That the new annual, class, and enrollment

25

levels reasonably assure that competition among projects for the applicable bidding

26

classifications remains robust and likely to yield reasonable and competitive program costs; (2)

27

That, assuming prudent management of the program, the electric distribution company should be

28

able to perform the studies and system upgrades on a timely basis necessary to accommodate the

29

number of applications associated with the targets without materially adversely affecting other

30

electric distribution construction projects needed to provide reliable and safe electric distribution

31

service; and (3) Any other reasonable factors that are consistent with the legislative purpose of

32

this chapter as set forth herein, including the program purpose to facilitate the development of

33

renewable distributed generation in the load zone of the electric distribution company at

34

reasonable cost.

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 10 of 29

1

     (i) The renewable energy growth program is intended to achieve at least an aggregate

2

amount of one hundred sixty (160) nameplate megawatts over five (5) years, plus any shortfall

3

amount added in pursuant to § 39-26.6-12(e). However, after the second program year the board

4

may, based on market data and other information available to it, including pricing received during

5

previous program years, recommend changes to the annual target for any program year above or

6

below the specified targets in § 39-26.6-12(c) if the board concludes that market conditions are

7

likely to produce favorably low or unfavorably high target pricing during the upcoming program

8

year, provided that the recommendation may not result in the five (5)-year one hundred sixty

9

megawatt (160MW) nameplate target, plus any shortfall added pursuant to § 39-26.6-12(e), being

10

exceeded. Any megawatt reduction in an annual target shall be added to the target in the fifth year

11

of the program (and any subsequent years if necessary) such that the overall program target of

12

one hundred sixty megawatt (160MW) nameplate capacity, plus any shortfall added pursuant to §

13

39-26.6-12(e), is achieved. In considering such issues, the board and the commission may take

14

into account the reasonableness of current pricing and its impact on all electric distribution

15

customers and the legislative purpose of this chapter as set forth herein, including the program

16

purpose to facilitate the development of renewable distributed generation in the load zone of the

17

electric distribution company at reasonable cost.

18

     (j) The provisions of § 39-26.1-4 shall apply to the annual value of performance based

19

incentives (actual payments plus the value of net metering credits, as applicable) provided by the

20

electric distribution company to all the distributed generation projects under this chapter, subject

21

to the following conditions:

22

     (1) The targets set for the applicable program year for the applicable project

23

classifications were met or, if not met, such failure was due to factors beyond the reasonable

24

control of the electric distribution company;

25

     (2) The electric distribution company has processed applications for service and

26

completed interconnections in a timely and prudent manner for the projects under this chapter,

27

taking into account factors within the electric distribution company's reasonable control. The

28

commission is authorized to establish more specific performance standards to implement the

29

provisions of this chapter; and

30

     (3) The incentive shall be one and three-quarters percent (1.75%) of the annual value of

31

performance-based incentives. The commission is authorized to establish more specific

32

performance standards to implement the provisions of this paragraph.

33

     39-26.6-13. Cost reconciliation. -- To the extent the electric distribution company incurs

34

incremental costs to meet the program objectives or make billing system improvements that are

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 11 of 29

1

required to facilitate payments of performance-based incentives and administering net metering,

2

the electric distribution company may elect to recover those incremental costs through the annual

3

charge set forth in § 39-26.6-25, subject to commission review and approval that assures such

4

costs were properly and prudently incurred.

5

     39-26.6-14. Existing powers of agencies and advocacy rights of parties unchanged. --

6

Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to derogate from the statutory authority of the

7

commission or the division of public utilities and carriers, including, but not limited to, the

8

authority to protect ratepayers from unreasonable rates. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed

9

to preclude any party from advocating a position in commission proceedings that differs from the

10

recommendations made by the board to the commission or in any filing with the commission

11

relating to this chapter, including without limitation (1) Individual or organizational members of

12

the board; (2) Participants in board deliberations; (3) The office; and (4) The electric distribution

13

company, unless such party has consented by vote to the execution or executed a settlement

14

agreement agreeing to the terms, policy proposals, or any other matter proposed to the

15

commission.

16

     39-26.6-15. Bidding and Incentive Award Processes for Solar DG Projects. -- (a)

17

Large scale and commercial scale solar projects and distributed generation projects for other

18

eligible technologies shall bid a price per kilowatt-hour for the entire output of the facility (net of

19

any station service), which price shall not exceed the applicable ceiling price. Small-scale and

20

medium-scale solar projects will submit an enrollment application to receive a standard

21

performance-based incentive for the period of years in the applicable tariff, which shall be a price

22

per kilowatt-hour for the entire output of the facility. Except for megawatts that may be allocated

23

to the energy efficiency program pursuant to § 39-26.6-19, small and medium scale projects shall

24

be selected on a first come, first served basis, or by means of a commission-approved lottery

25

system, or such other method as may be recommended by the board and approved by the

26

commission.

27

     (b) Except for the first program year, the board shall determine, subject to commission

28

approval, the standard performance based incentive for small and medium sized solar projects

29

from the average bid price from the last two (2) procurement enrollments conducted in the

30

commercial scale and/or large scale solar projects class. For the first program year, the board may

31

derive the standard performance incentive for small and medium sized solar projects from the

32

bidding data obtained from the distributed generation program in effect in 2014 under the

33

provisions of chapter 26.2 of title 39, until there is bidding data from the first procurement under

34

the new program which shall then be used to set a new standard performance incentive. The

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 12 of 29

1

standard performance incentive may be set at a higher rate than payments for commercial scale

2

and large scale solar projects in order to take into account the potentially higher per-unit cost of

3

smaller projects. The standard performance incentive also shall be adjusted upward or downward,

4

as needed, in order to take into account the term length over which the incentive shall be paid for

5

the small and medium scale solar projects if such terms are different than the terms applicable to

6

the classes from which the standard performance incentive was derived.

7

     (c) For each program year, the board shall recommend to the commission a standard

8

performance incentive for each of the small scale and medium scale solar project classifications.

9

Upon receiving the recommendations from the board, the commission shall open a docket to

10

consider the recommendations or address the recommendations in its approval process for the

11

program year in a consolidated docket, as provided in § 39-26.6-10. The commission shall issue

12

its order approving the recommendations no later than concurrently with approval of the entire

13

program and tariffs applicable to the program year; provided, however, that the commission may

14

make modifications or changes to the board's recommendations consistent with the legislative

15

purposes of this chapter.

16

     (d) If after the first program year the applications for the medium scale solar projects are

17

significantly over-subscribed, then the board and the electric distribution company, in

18

consultation with the office, may propose to the commission a bidding process for medium scale

19

projects or a subset of the medium scale projects under which project selections would be made

20

based on the lowest bids rather than first come first served or such other method previously

21

approved by the commission. The commission shall approve the proposal from the board and

22

electric company within ninety (90) days; provided, however, that the commission may make

23

changes to the proposal consistent with the legislative purposes of this chapter.

24

     (e) The commission shall approve the bidding process for medium scale solar projects

25

recommended by the board only if the commission finds that such bidding process is in a

26

sufficiently simple form that is not administratively burdensome to bidders, and will not have the

27

effect of discouraging participation in the distributed generation growth program by developers of

28

medium scale solar projects who may be unrepresented by counsel.

29

     39-26.6-16. Enrollment Program. -- (a) Each enrollment shall be open for a two (2)

30

week period during which the electric distribution company is required to receive standard short-

31

form applications. The standard short-form application shall require the applicant to provide the

32

following information: the project owner's identity; the location of the proposed project; the

33

nameplate capacity of the proposed project; and renewable energy class of the proposed project.

34

The standard short-form application shall allow project owners to provide additional information

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 13 of 29

1

relative to the permitting, financial feasibility, ability to build, and timing for deployment of the

2

proposed projects. The applicant must submit an affidavit with the standard short-form

3

application confirming that the project is not in violation of the rules that prohibit project

4

segmentation, as set forth in § 39-26.6-9.

5

     (b) For large distributed generation projects only, the standard short-form application

6

shall also require the applicant to bid a bundled price that applies to the energy, renewable energy

7

certificates, and all other environmental attributes and market products that are available or may

8

become available from the distributed generation facility, on a per kilowatt-hour basis measured

9

from the output of the project. At the election of the electric distribution company, and subject to

10

the approval of the commission, the bid may be required to include the sale of capacity.

11

     (c) For (i) Small distributed generation projects other than small scale and medium scale

12

solar projects; and (ii) Large distributed generation projects, the electric distribution company

13

shall select projects based on the lowest proposed prices received that do not exceed the ceiling

14

price from the distributed generation projects which meet the requirements of all applicable tariffs

15

and regulations, and meet the criteria of the renewable energy class in effect, until the class target

16

is met. Performance based incentives shall be awarded to the winning bidders based on their bids

17

submitted.

18

     (d) For small scale and medium scale solar projects, awards shall be made in the manner

19

set forth in §§ 39-26.6-15 and 39-26.6-19.

20

     (e) If there are more projects bidding at the same price than the capacity that is specified

21

for a class target, the electric distribution company shall, in consultation with the board and the

22

office, select first those projects that appear to be the furthest along in development and that are

23

most likely to be deployed. Those projects that are likely to be deployed at the earliest time shall

24

be selected first. To the extent the electric distribution company is unable to make a clear

25

distinction on this basis, the electric distribution company shall report its findings to the board

26

and not award bids for those projects that are tied on pricing. In such case, the board may take

27

such action as it deems appropriate for the selection of projects, including seeking more

28

information from the projects.

29

     (f) Should the electric distribution company determine that it has made sufficient awards

30

to achieve a program-year class target, it shall immediately report this fact to the board, the

31

office, and the commission, and may cease making awards for that renewable energy class for the

32

remainder of the program year. In any event, the electric distribution company may exceed the

33

renewable energy class target if the last award may cause the total purchased to exceed the target.

34

     (g) The board, the office, and the electric distribution company shall enter into a

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 14 of 29

1

memorandum of understanding regarding the sharing of the information and data related to the

2

renewable energy growth program, including, without limitation, information on bids received,

3

details regarding project ownership, and pricing. At the request of the board, the office, or the

4

electric distribution company, the commission shall have the authority to protect from public

5

disclosure individual bid information for any projects that have not been awarded performance

6

based incentives.

7

     (h) The electric distribution company is authorized to award bids up to the applicable

8

ceiling price. As long as the terms of the tariff are met and the pricing is no higher than the

9

applicable ceiling price, such awards shall be deemed prudent and approved by the commission

10

for purposes of recovering the costs in rates.

11

     (i) With respect to any procurement that includes bids from pre-existing hydro-electric

12

generation, the electric distribution company, in consultation with the office, shall have the

13

authority to accept the applicant's representation that its investment is material, within the

14

meaning of § 39-26.6-3(4). However, if the electric distribution company or the office questions

15

whether the material investment standard has been met or the application is otherwise rejected,

16

the application shall be submitted to the board for review and the board shall draw its own

17

conclusion and make a recommendation to the commission at the time the commission is

18

approving awards from the procurement to which the application pertains. The commission shall

19

have the final authority to make the determination as to whether the material investment standard

20

has been met. Nothing in this paragraph shall preclude a project developer from seeking a

21

preliminary confirmation of eligibility for the material investment exemption from the electric

22

distribution company, the office, and the board prior to the submittal of a bid. In such case, if

23

there is any disagreement, the final determination shall be submitted to the commission.

24

     39-26.6-17. Excess enrollment not required. -- The electric distribution company shall

25

not be required to award bids in excess of the annual target for the applicable program year and

26

shall not be required to procure projects in excess of any limit set by the board and approved by

27

the commission for a given enrollment. However, the electric distribution company, in

28

consultation with the board and the office, may voluntarily exceed an enrollment period limit as

29

long as it does not exceed an annual target for the applicable program year. At its election, the

30

electric distribution company may exceed an annual target for the applicable program year after

31

review by the board and approval by the commission.

32

     39-26.6-18. Utility Right to Separately Meter. -- Owners of medium scale, commercial

33

scale, and large scale solar projects and other distributed generation technologies shall be required

34

to provide at their cost a revenue quality meter to standards approved by the division of public

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 15 of 29

1

utilities and carriers and provide access to the information from the meter to the electric

2

distribution company to measure the output of the generation. The electric distribution company

3

shall have the discretion to install the second meter in a parallel configuration to the retail meter

4

or behind the meter, provided that a parallel installation shall have no effect on the right of the

5

customer to net meter using the net of the two meters. The electric distribution company also

6

shall have the right to install its own revenue quality meter for small scale solar projects if not

7

being supplied by the owner. The electric distribution company shall recover the installation and

8

capital cost of the separate meters it installs for small scale solar projects in the annual

9

reconciliation of solar costs under § 39-26.6-25.

10

     39-26.6-19. Coordination with Energy Efficiency Programs. -- (a) In consultation with

11

the office, the electric distribution company may make a request to the commission that up to half

12

of the megawatts for the small and medium scale solar project enrollments be allocated by the

13

commission for selection through a process coordinated with the energy efficiency program in

14

order that specified solar incentives may be tied with energy efficiency program incentives in

15

order to allow the electric distribution company to implement a coordinated energy efficiency and

16

solar program offering. In such case, the electric distribution company will propose criteria for

17

eligibility for performance based incentives for solar that requires certain energy efficiency

18

standards be met at the customer location in order to be eligible for performance based incentives

19

for a small scale and/or medium scale solar installation.

20

     (b) The electric distribution company must also include program parameters that do not

21

disrupt competition among small-scale and/or medium-scale solar developers, including, without

22

limitation, safeguards against any one or subset of developers in this market being given

23

exclusive rights or other market advantages over competitors. In approving the proposal, the

24

commission must find that there is no such small and medium solar-market disruption.

25

     (c) The commission shall approve the request of the distribution company within ninety

26

(90) days, making such modifications as it deems reasonable, provided such modifications are

27

consistent with the legislative purposes of this chapter and the state's energy efficiency goals.

28

     (d) The allocation of megawatts is for implementation purposes only and shall not

29

authorize funds to be shifted from the distributed generation growth program to energy efficiency

30

programs, nor will implementation of the electric distribution company's request cause a

31

reduction of the annual or cumulative capacity goals established for the distributed generation

32

growth program. To the extent that the megawatts allocated to the energy efficiency program

33

pursuant to this section are not committed during a program year, such uncommitted megawatts

34

shall be allocated back to the distributed generation growth program in the following year or such

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 16 of 29

1

year the board recommends to the commission. Funding for the energy efficiency measures that

2

are tied to the solar installations must be obtained separately from the energy efficiency program

3

budget funded through applicable energy efficiency charges.

4

     (e) Should the small-scale and medium-scale project classes in the renewable energy

5

growth program be oversubscribed in two (2) consecutive enrollments and there are megawatts

6

that have not been committed through the process coordinated with the energy efficiency program

7

after the second enrollment, the board, after consultation with the office and the electric

8

distribution company, shall have the authority to move all or a portion of the uncommitted

9

megawatts out of the coordinated program back to the renewable energy growth program to meet

10

the demand of the oversubscription, subject to commission approval. If, in such case, the board

11

does not exercise the authority, any party may file a petition to the commission requesting action

12

to be taken

13

     39-26.6-20. Issuance of certificates and right to incentive payments. -- (a) For small

14

scale and medium scale solar projects, the electric distribution company shall provide certificates

15

of eligibility to the selected projects without commission confirmation of approval ("distribution

16

company awarded certificates"), subject to the review and consent of the office. The electric

17

distribution company shall file with the commission a list of all such distribution company

18

awarded certificates.

19

     (b) For commercial-scale and large-scale solar and all other distributed generation

20

projects, the electric distribution company shall file with the commission a list of the distributed

21

generation projects selected together with the corresponding pricing information. Within sixty

22

(60) days of receipt of the list, the commission shall issue an order awarding certificates of

23

eligibility to the distributed generation projects ("PUC awarded certificates").

24

     (c) Upon receipt of a PUC awarded certificate or a distribution company certificate, a

25

distributed generation project shall be entitled to receive, and the electric distribution company

26

shall pay and/or credit (as applicable), the performance-based incentives for the specified term

27

and under the terms and conditions of the applicable tariff in the manner set forth below.

28

     (d) The performance based incentive shall be the price per kilowatt-hour that was bid and

29

awarded or established as a standard incentive, as applicable. The performance-based incentive

30

shall be applied as a price per kilowatt-hour for all kilowatt-hours actually produced from the

31

distributed generation (net of station service, if any) for the term of years specified in the

32

applicable tariff, less the value of any kilowatt-hour charges that were offset by any net metering

33

(if applicable) for the host customer associated with the distributed generation for the billing

34

month; provided, however, if the value of kilowatt-hour charges that otherwise would be offset by

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 17 of 29

1

net metering in a given month exceeds the total value of the performance-based incentive for the

2

month, the customer shall not be subject to any additional charge nor receive any additional net

3

metering credit for the difference between the performance-based incentive value and net

4

metering value for the month.

5

     (e) Except as provided herein for residential small-scale solar projects, in every case

6

where a distributed generation project can be configured for net metering, it shall be the election

7

of the owner of such generation to choose one of two (2) separate methods through which the

8

owner will be compensated for the performance based incentive:

9

     (1) The owner is compensated solely through direct payments under the performance-

10

based incentive provisions of this chapter for the life of the tariff term with no net metering

11

implemented; or

12

     (2) The owner is compensated through a combination of direct payments and the bill

13

credit value of net metering for the life of the term of the tariff under the provisions of this

14

chapter.

15

     In the case of residential small-scale solar projects, only option (2) shall be available.

16

     In either option, the total value of the performance incentive per kilowatt-hour is the

17

same. An owner shall have a one-time right to switch the compensation methods after the

18

generation commences operation, provided that at least sixty (60) days notice is given to the

19

electric distribution company. Thereafter, any further compensation method switches shall be at

20

the sole discretion of the electric distribution company if requested again by the owner.

21

     (f) Every owner who elects the compensation method shall:

22

     (1) Receive compensation solely in the form of a check from the electric distribution

23

company or such other payment method that is mutually agreed between the electric distribution

24

company and the owner; and

25

     (2) Shall receive compensation in the form of offsets against its electricity bill from the

26

electric distribution company from net metering and the balance in the form of a check from the

27

electric distribution company or such other payment method that is mutually agreed upon

28

between the electric distribution company and the owner; provided, however, that no owner of a

29

distributed generation project may be compensated twice for the same kilowatt hour of electricity,

30

and that every self-generator shall receive the full pecuniary benefit of its election to participate

31

in the performance-based incentive program.

32

     (g) Every owner of a distributed generation project that can be configured for net

33

metering that elects the first option for compensation under the provisions of § 39-26.6-20(e)

34

shall become eligible to net meter its output in conformity with the provisions of existing law

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 18 of 29

1

upon the completion of the full term of the applicable tariff. Nothing in this section shall preclude

2

a customer from electing not to participate in the performance based program and electing simply

3

to net meter under the provisions of existing law; provided, however, once an election is made to

4

participate, the customer will remain subject to the performance based tariff conditions and may

5

not terminate the arrangement without the consent of the electric distribution company.

6

     (h) As provided in § 39-26.6-9, any project developer may designate a generation unit on

7

the same parcel or contiguous parcel for net metering, provided that such unit or portion of such

8

unit designated for net metering is not receiving performance-based incentives under this chapter,

9

is capable of being segregated electrically, is configured with such electrical segregation, and is

10

separately metered.

11

     (i) All distributed generation projects accepting certificates shall be obligated to abide by

12

all the terms and conditions of the approved applicable tariff.

13

     39-26.6-21. Ownership of output, other attributes, and renewable energy

14

certificates. -- (a) Except as provided herein for residential small-scale solar projects, distributed

15

generation projects participating in the renewable energy growth program shall transfer to the

16

electric distribution company the rights and title to:

17

     (1) Those renewable energy certificates generated by the project during the term of the

18

applicable performance-based incentive tariff;

19

     (2) All energy produced by the generation that is not otherwise consumed on site under a

20

net metering arrangement; and

21

     (3) Rights to any other environmental attributes or market products that are created or

22

produced by the project; provided, however, that it shall be the election of the electric distribution

23

company whether it chooses to acquire the capacity of the distributed generation projects under

24

the tariffs set forth in this chapter and no ceiling prices recommended by the board and approved

25

by the commission will be adjusted downward in light of the electric distribution company's

26

election. The electric distribution company shall sell any products acquired and credit them to the

27

reconciliation account specified in § 39-26.6-25. When a generator reverts to net metering after

28

the end of the tariff term under the renewable energy growth program, the net metering generator

29

shall retain title to the renewable energy certificates generated by the project. In the case of

30

residential small-scale projects, title to all energy and capacity produced from the solar generation

31

shall remain with the residential customer, shall not be transferred to the electric distribution

32

company, and shall be deemed consumed by the residential customer on-site during the

33

applicable distribution service billing period with no sale or purchase between the residential

34

customer and the electric distribution company.

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 19 of 29

1

     (b) For the accounting purposes of the electric distribution company in treating the

2

performance-based incentives, the cost of the energy that is procured shall be the real time market

3

price of energy and the balance of the performance-based incentive shall be attributable to the

4

purchase of environmental and any other attributes acquired. This accounting shall have no effect

5

on the total bundled performance-based incentive to which the distributed generation project is

6

entitled under the provisions of this chapter.

7

     39-26.6-22. Zonal and other incentive payments. -- In order to provide the electric

8

distribution company with the flexibility to encourage distributed generation projects to be

9

located in designated geographical areas within its load zone where there is an identifiable system

10

benefit, reliability benefit, or cost savings to the distribution system in that geographical area, the

11

electric distribution company, in consultation with board and office, may propose to include an

12

incentive payment adder to the bid price of any winning bidder that proposes a distributed

13

generation project in the desired geographical area. The electric distribution company also may

14

propose other incentive payments to achieve other technical or public policy objectives that

15

provide identifiable benefits to customers. Any incentive payment adders must be approved by

16

the commission, and shall not be counted as part of the bid price when the bids are selected at an

17

enrollment event.

18

     39-26.6-23. Intersection of distributed generation and net metering. -- (a) Net

19

metering credits for excess generation shall not be credited during the term of the tariff when the

20

distributed generation project is receiving performance-based incentive payments under the tariff.

21

After the end of the term of the performance-based incentive tariff applicable to a distributed

22

generation project, net metering credits for excess generation in any given month shall be credited

23

to the net metered account at the applicable rate allowed under the law.

24

     (b) All distributed generation projects that had begun development prior to the date the

25

commission approves the first set of ceiling price recommendations from the board and that are in

26

operation by no later than July 1, 2016, shall be eligible to continue operation under the net

27

metering rules that would have been applicable to that self-generation project absent the change

28

in law set forth in this section, provided that such project does not otherwise participate in the

29

performance based incentive program set forth in this chapter.

30

     39-26.6-24. Rate design review by the commission. -- (a) On or after July 1, 2015, the

31

commission shall open a docket to consider rate design and distribution cost allocation among

32

rate classes in light of net metering and the changing distribution system that is expected to

33

include more distributed energy resources, including, but not limited to, distributed generation.

34

The commission will determine the appropriate cost responsibility and contributions to the

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 20 of 29

1

operation, maintenance, and investment in the distribution system that is relied upon by all

2

customers, including, without limitation, non-net metered and net metered customers. In that

3

docket, the commission shall require the electric distribution company to file a revenue-neutral

4

allocated cost of service study for all rate classes and a proposal for new rates for all customers in

5

each rate class. The electric distribution company shall use the distribution revenue requirement

6

upon which the then-current distribution rates were set. The electric distribution company may

7

use the allocated cost of service that was filed with the compliance filing from the rate case when

8

the then current distribution rates were set. The commission may also address the rate design for

9

the equitable recovery of costs associated with energy efficiency and any renewable energy

10

programs that are recovered in rates.

11

     (b) In establishing any new rates the commission may deem appropriate, the commission

12

shall take into account and balance the following factors:

13

     (1) The benefits of distributed energy resources;

14

     (2) The distribution services being provided to net metered customers when the

15

distributed generation is not producing electricity;

16

     (3) Simplicity, understandability and transparency of rates to all customers, including

17

non-net metered and net-metered customers;

18

     (4) Equitable ratemaking principles regarding the allocation of the costs of the

19

distribution system;

20

     (5) Cost causation principles;

21

     (6) The general assembly's legislative purposes in creating the distributed generation

22

growth program; and

23

     (7) Any other factors the commission deems relevant and appropriate in establishing a

24

fair rate structure. The rates shall be designed for each proposed rate class in accordance with

25

industry-standard cost allocation principles. The commission may consider any reasonable rate

26

design options, including without limitation, fixed charges, minimum monthly charges, demand

27

charges, volumetric charges, or any combination thereof, with the purpose of assuring recovery of

28

costs fairly across all rate classes.

29

     (c) The commission shall issue an order in the docket by no later than December 1, 2015.

30

Any new rates shall take effect for usage on and after January 1, 2016; provided, however, that

31

the electric distribution company may seek an extension if necessary to make the billing system

32

changes necessary to implement a new rate structure. After new revenue-neutral rates are set in

33

the docket specified above, the commission may approve changes to the rate design in any future

34

distribution base rate cases when a fully allocated embedded cost of service study is being

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 21 of 29

1

reviewed in the rate case, subject to the principles set forth in subsection (b) of this section.

2

     39-26.6-25. Forecasted rate and reconciliation. -- (a) Three (3) months prior to the

3

beginning of the first program year, the electric distribution company shall file a forecast of the

4

total amount of payments that is likely to be paid out to distributed generation projects in the

5

coming program year within the electric distribution company's load zone, along with any costs

6

permitted for recovery pursuant to §§ 39-26.6-4, 39-26.6-13 and 39-26.6-18. The total of all

7

forecasted payments and costs shall be aggregated, net of forecasted revenues from the sale of the

8

energy, renewable energy certificates, and any other market products from the distributed

9

generation projects participating in the performance based incentive program. The forecasted net

10

aggregate amount shall be used to design a fixed monthly charge per customer to recover the net

11

forecast in rates charged to all distribution customers during the prospective calendar year, which

12

fixed charge may be different by rate class in order to reasonably and equitably spread the

13

program costs across all customer classes. The fixed rate shall stay in effect until changed after

14

the first reconciliation filing set forth below and the rate reconciliation process shall be repeated

15

annually, as set forth below. The commission, in its discretion, may move the reconciliation of

16

costs and credits under § 39-26.1-5(f) into this reconciliation in order to have one reconciliation

17

of all program costs and credits from the long-term contracting standard, distributed generation

18

standard contracting, and renewable energy growth program.

19

     (b) Within three (3) months after the end of each program year, the electric distribution

20

company shall reconcile the total amount recovered from distribution customers against the total

21

of net payments and costs for the program year. The electric distribution company shall file the

22

reconciliation with a report along with a new forecast of payments to be made for the next twelve

23

(12) month period, net of forecasted revenues for the resale of energy, renewable energy

24

certificates, or any other market attributes sold by the electric distribution company. The forecast

25

shall be used to set a new rate in the same manner as set forth above and the new rate shall remain

26

in effect until rates are reset in the next annual reconciliation and the reconciliation balance shall

27

be reflected in the new rate.

28

     SECTION 2. Section 39-26.1-3 of the General Laws in Chapter 39-26.1 entitled "Long-

29

Term Contracting Standard for Renewable Energy" is hereby amended to read as follows:

30

     39-26.1-3. Long-term contract standard. -- (a) Beginning on or before July 1, 2010,

31

each electric distribution company shall be required to annually solicit proposals from renewable

32

energy developers and, provided commercially reasonable proposals have been received, enter

33

into long-term contracts with terms of up to fifteen (15) years for the purchase of capacity, energy

34

and attributes from newly developed renewable energy resources. Subject to commission

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 22 of 29

1

approval, the electric distribution company may enter into contracts for term lengths longer than

2

fifteen (15) years. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this chapter, on or before August 15,

3

2009, the electric distribution company shall solicit proposals for one newly developed renewable

4

energy resources project as required in section § 39-26.1-7. Proposals for the sale of output from

5

an offshore wind project received under the provisions of this section shall be diligently and fully

6

considered without prejudice, regardless of the status of any proceedings under sections §§ 39-

7

26.1-7 or 39-26.1-8.

8

      (b) The timetable and method for solicitation and execution of such contracts shall be

9

proposed by the electric distribution company, and shall be subject to review and approval by the

10

commission prior to issuance by the company; provided that the timetable is reasonably designed

11

to result in the electric distribution company having the minimum long-term contract capacity

12

under contract within four (4) years of the date of the first solicitation; it is not necessary that the

13

projects associated with these contracts be operational within these four (4) years, as the

14

operational dates shall be specified in the contract. The electric distribution company shall,

15

subject to review and approval of the commission, select a reasonable method of soliciting

16

proposals from renewable energy developers, which shall include, at a minimum, an annual

17

public solicitation, but may also include individual negotiations. The solicitation process shall

18

permit a reasonable amount of negotiating discretion for the parties to engage in commercially

19

reasonable arms-length negotiations over final contract terms. Each long-term contract entered

20

into pursuant to this section shall contain a condition that it shall not be effective without

21

commission review and approval. The electric distribution company shall file such contract, along

22

with a justification for its decision, within a reasonable time after it has executed the contract

23

following a solicitation or negotiation. The commission shall hold public hearings to review the

24

contract within forty-five (45) days of the filing and issue a written order approving or rejecting

25

the contract within sixty (60) days of the filing; in rejecting a contract the commission may advise

26

the parties of the reason for the contract being rejected and direct the parties to attempt to address

27

the reasons for rejection in a revised contract within a specified period not to exceed ninety (90)

28

days. The commission shall approve the contract if it determines that: (1) the contract is

29

commercially reasonable; (2) the requirements for the annual solicitation have been met; and (3)

30

the contract is consistent with the purposes of this chapter. A report on each solicitation shall be

31

filed with the commission each year within a reasonable time after decisions are made by the

32

electric distribution company regarding the solicitation results, even if no contracts are executed

33

following the solicitation.

34

      (c) (1) No electric distribution company shall be obligated to enter into long-term

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 23 of 29

1

contracts for newly developed renewable energy resources on terms which the electric

2

distribution company reasonably believes to be commercially unreasonable; provided, however, if

3

there is a dispute about whether these terms are commercially unreasonable, the commission shall

4

make the final determination after an evidentiary hearing. The electric distribution company shall

5

not be obligated to enter into long-term contracts pursuant to this section that would, in the

6

aggregate, exceed the minimum long-term contract capacity, but may do so voluntarily subject to

7

commission approval. As long as the electric distribution company has entered into long-term

8

contracts in compliance with this section, the electric distribution company shall not be required

9

by regulation or order to enter into power purchase contracts with renewable generation projects

10

for power, renewable energy certificates, or any other attributes with terms of more than three (3)

11

years in meeting its applicable annual renewable portfolio standard requirements set forth in

12

section 39-26-4 or pursuant to any other provision of the law.

13

      (2) Except as provided in section 39-26.1-7 and 39-26.1-8, an electric distribution

14

company shall not be required to enter into long-term contracts for newly developed renewable

15

energy resources that exceed the following five (5) year phased schedule:

16

      By December 30, 2010: Twenty-five percent (25%) of the minimum long-term contract

17

capacity;

18

      By December 30, 2011: Fifty percent (50%) of the minimum long-term contract

19

capacity;

20

      By December 30, 2012: Seventy-five percent (75%) of the minimum long-term contract

21

capacity;

22

      By After December 30, 2014 2013: One hundred percent (100%) of the minimum long-

23

term contract capacity; but may do so earlier voluntarily, subject to commission approval subject

24

to subsection (f) of this section.

25

      (d) Compliance with the long-term contract standard shall be demonstrated through

26

procurement pursuant to the provisions of a long-term contract of energy, capacity and attributes

27

reflected in NE-GIS certificates relating to generating units certified by the commission as using

28

newly developed renewable energy resources, as evidenced by reports issued by the NE-GIS

29

administrator and the terms of the contract; provided, however, that the NE-GIS certificates were

30

procured pursuant to the provisions of a long-term contract. The electric distribution company

31

also may purchase other attributes from the generator as part of the long-term contract.

32

      (e) After the adoption of the rules and regulations promulgated by the commission

33

pursuant to this chapter, an electric distribution company may, at its sole election, immediately

34

and from time to time, procure additional commercially reasonable long-term contracts for newly

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 24 of 29

1

developed renewable energy resources on an earlier timetable or above the minimum long-term

2

contract capacity, subject to commission approval.

3

     (f) At least once per year beginning in 2014, the electric distribution company shall

4

conduct solicitations until one hundred percent (100%) of the minimum long-term contract

5

capacity is met; provided, however, that no contracts shall be awarded unless the pricing under

6

such contract(s) is below the forecasted market price of energy and renewable energy certificates

7

over the term of the proposed contract, using industry standard forecasting methodologies as have

8

been used to evaluate pricing in the past solicitation processes reviewed by the commission under

9

this section. In such solicitations, the electric distribution company may elect not to acquire

10

capacity, but shall acquire all environmental attributes and energy.

11

     SECTION 3. Section 39-26.4-3 of the General Laws in Chapter 39-26.4 entitled "Net

12

Metering" is hereby amended to read as follows:

13

     39-26.4-3. Net metering. -- (a) The following policies regarding net metering of

14

electricity from eligible net metering systems and regarding any person that is a renewable self-

15

generator shall apply:

16

      (1) The maximum allowable capacity for eligible net metering systems, based on

17

nameplate capacity, shall be five megawatts (5 mw).

18

      (2) The aggregate amount of net metering in Rhode Island shall not exceed three percent

19

(3%) of peak load, provided that at least two megawatts (2 mw) are reserved for projects of less

20

than fifty kilowatts (50 kw). The aggregate amount of net metering in the Block Island Power

21

Company and the Pascoag Utility District shall not exceed three percent (3%) of peak load for

22

each utility district.

23

      (3)(2) For ease of administering net metered accounts and stabilizing net metered

24

account bills, the electric distribution company may elect (but is not required) to estimate for any

25

twelve (12) month period:

26

      (i) The production from the eligible net metering system; and

27

      (ii) Aggregate consumption of the net metered accounts at the eligible net metering

28

system site and establish a monthly billing plan that reflects the expected credits that would be

29

applied to the net metered accounts over twelve (12) months. The billing plan would be designed

30

to even out monthly billings over twelve (12) months, regardless of actual production and usage.

31

If such election is made by the electric distribution company, the electric distribution company

32

would reconcile payments and credits under the billing plan to actual production and

33

consumption at the end of the twelve (12) month period and apply any credits or charges to the

34

net metered accounts for any positive or negative difference, as applicable. Should there be a

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 25 of 29

1

material change in circumstances at the eligible net metering system site or associated accounts

2

during the twelve (12) month period, the estimates and credits may be adjusted by the electric

3

distribution company during the reconciliation period. The electric distribution company also may

4

elect (but is not required) to issue checks to any net metering customer in lieu of billing credits or

5

carry forward credits or charges to the next billing period. For residential eligible net metering

6

systems twenty-five kilowatts (25 kw) or smaller, the electric distribution company, at its option,

7

may administer renewable net metering credits month to month allowing unused credits to carry

8

forward into following billing period.

9

      (4)(3) If the electricity generated by an eligible net metering system during a billing

10

period is equal to or less than the net metering customer's usage during the billing period for

11

electric distribution company customer accounts at the eligible net metering system site, the

12

customer shall receive renewable net metering credits, which shall be applied to offset the net

13

metering customer's usage on accounts at the eligible net metering system site.

14

      (5)(4) If the electricity generated by an eligible net metering system during a billing

15

period is greater than the net metering customer's usage on accounts at the eligible net metering

16

system site during the billing period, the customer shall be paid by excess renewable net metering

17

credits for the excess electricity generated beyond the net metering customer's usage at the

18

eligible net metering system site up to an additional twenty-five percent (25%) of the renewable

19

self-generator's consumption during the billing period; unless the electric distribution company

20

and net metering customer have agreed to a billing plan pursuant to subdivision (3).

21

      (6)(5) The rates applicable to any net metered account shall be the same as those that

22

apply to the rate classification that would be applicable to such account in the absence of net

23

metering including customer and demand charges and no other charges may be imposed to offset

24

net metering credits.

25

      (b) The commission shall exempt electric distribution company customer accounts

26

associated with an eligible net metering system from back-up or standby rates commensurate with

27

the size of the eligible net metering system, provided that any revenue shortfall caused by any

28

such exemption shall be fully recovered by the electric distribution company through rates.

29

      (c) Any prudent and reasonable costs incurred by the electric distribution company

30

pursuant to achieving compliance with subsection (a) and the annual amount of the distribution

31

component of any renewable net metering credits or excess renewable net metering credits

32

provided to accounts associated with eligible net metering systems, shall be aggregated by the

33

distribution company and billed to all distribution customers on an annual basis through a

34

uniform per kilowatt-hour (kwh) surcharge embedded in the distribution component of the rates

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 26 of 29

1

reflected on customer bills.

2

      (7)(6) The billing process set out in this section shall be applicable to electric distribution

3

companies thirty (30) days after the enactment of this chapter.

4

     SECTION 4. Section 39-26.2-7 of the General Laws in Chapter 39-26.2 entitled

5

"Distributed Generation Standard Contracts" is hereby amended to read as follows:

6

     39-26.2-7. Standard contract -- Form and provisions. -- The following process shall be

7

implemented to establish the non-price terms and conditions of the standard contract:

8

      (1) A working group ("contract working group") shall be established and supervised by

9

the board, consisting of the following members:

10

     (i) The director of the office of energy resources;

11

     (ii) A designee from the division of public utilities and carriers;

12

     (iii) Two (2) designees of the electric distribution company;

13

     (iv) Two (2) individuals designated by the office of energy resources who are

14

experienced developers of renewable generation projects;

15

     (v) One individual designated by the office of energy resources who represents a

16

customer of the electric distribution company; and (vi) A lawyer designated by the office of

17

energy resources who has at least three (3) years of experience in negotiating and/or developing

18

power purchase agreements. With respect to the lawyer designated in (vi) above, the electric

19

distribution company shall enter into a cost reimbursement agreement with such lawyer, to

20

compensate the lawyer for the time spent serving in the contract working group at the reasonable

21

hourly rate negotiated by the office of energy resources. The costs incurred by the electric

22

distribution company under the reimbursement agreement shall be recovered in rates by the

23

electric distribution company in the year incurred or the year following incurrence through an

24

appropriate filing with the commission. The contract working group shall be an advisory group

25

that is not to be considered to be an agency for purposes of the administrative procedures act or

26

any other laws pertaining to public bodies.

27

      (2) The contract working group shall work in good faith to develop standard contracts

28

that would be applicable for various technologies for both small and large distributed generation

29

projects. The standard contracts should balance the need for the project to obtain financing

30

against the need for the distribution company to protect itself and its distribution customers

31

against unreasonable risks. The standard contract should be developed from contracting terms

32

typically utilized in the wholesale power industry, taking into account the size of each project and

33

the technology. The standard contracts shall provide for the purchase of energy, capacity,

34

renewable energy certificates, and all other environmental attributes and market products that are

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 27 of 29

1

available or may become available from the distributed generation facility. However, the electric

2

distribution company shall retain the right to separate out pricing for each market product under

3

the contracts for administrative and accounting purposes to avoid any detrimental accounting

4

effects or for administrative convenience, provided that such accounting as specified in the

5

contract does not affect the price and financial benefits to the seller as a seller of a bundled

6

product. The standard contract also shall:

7

      (i) Hold the distributed generation facility owner liable for the cost of interconnection

8

from the distributed generation facility to the interconnect point with the distribution system, and

9

for any upgrades to the existing distributed generation system that may be required by the electric

10

distribution company. However, a distributed generation facility owner may appeal to the

11

commission to reduce any required system upgrade costs to the extent such upgrades can be

12

shown to benefit other customers of the electric distribution company and the balance of such

13

costs shall be included in rates by the electric distribution company for recovery in the year

14

incurred or the year following incurrence;

15

      (ii) Require the distributed generation facility owner to make a performance guarantee

16

deposit to the electric distribution company of fifteen dollars ($15.00) for small distributed

17

generation projects or twenty-five dollars ($25.00) for large distributed generation projects for

18

every renewable energy certificate estimated to be generated per year under the contract, but at

19

least five hundred dollars ($500) and not more than seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000), paid

20

at the time of contract execution;

21

      (iii) Require the electric distribution company to refund the performance guarantee

22

deposit on a pro-rated basis of renewable energy credits actually delivered by the distributed

23

generation facility over the course of the first year of the project's operation, paid quarterly;

24

      (iv) Provide that if the distributed generation facility has not generated ninety percent

25

(90%) of the output proposed in its enrollment application within eighteen (18) months after

26

execution of the contract, the contract shall be terminated and the performance guarantee shall be

27

forfeited. An eligible small-scale hydropower distributed generation facility that has not

28

generated ninety percent (90%) of the output proposed in its enrollment application within forty-

29

eight (48) months after execution of the contract shall result in the contract being terminated and

30

the performance guarantee being forfeited. An eligible anaerobic digestion distributed generation

31

facility that has not generated ninety percent (90%) of the output proposed in its enrollment

32

application within thirty-six (36) months after execution of the contract shall result in the contract

33

being terminated and the performance guarantee being forfeited. Any forfeited performance

34

guarantee deposits shall be credited to all distribution customers in rates and not retained by the

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 28 of 29

1

electric distribution company;

2

      (v) Provide for flexible payment schedules that may be negotiated between the buyer and

3

seller, but shall be no longer than quarterly if an agreement cannot be reached;

4

      (vi) Require that an electric meter which conforms with standard industry norms be

5

installed to measure the electrical energy output of the distributed generation facility, and require

6

a system or procedure by which the distributed generation facility owner shall demonstrate

7

creation of renewable energy credits, in a manner recognized and accounted for by the GIS; such

8

demonstration of renewable energy credit creation to be at the distributed generation facility

9

owner's expense. The electric distribution company may, at its discretion, offer to provide such a

10

renewable energy credit measurement and accounting system or procedure to the distributed

11

generation facility owner, and the distributed generation facility owner may, at its discretion, use

12

the electric distribution company's program, or use that of an independent third party, approved

13

by the commission, and the costs of such measurement and accounting are paid for by the

14

distributed generation facility owner.

15

      (vii) All distributed generation projects that have executed contracts will be required to

16

submit quarterly reports on the progress of the project to the distribution company and the office

17

of energy resources. Failure to submit these quarterly progress reports may result in the

18

termination of the contract.

19

      (3) If the contract working group reaches agreement on the terms of standard contracts,

20

the board shall file the contracts with the commission for approval. If there are any

21

disagreements, they shall be identified to the commission. The commission shall review the

22

standard contracts for conformance with the standards set forth in subsection (2). Should there be

23

any disputes, the commission shall issue an order resolving them. To the extent the commission

24

needs expert assistance to resolve any disagreements noted in the filing, the commission is

25

authorized to hire a consultant to assist it in the proceedings, the costs of which shall be recovered

26

from electric distribution customers pursuant to a uniform factor established by the commission

27

in rates for recovery by the electric distribution company in the year incurred or the year

28

following incurrence, as requested through a filing by the electric distribution company. The

29

commission shall issue an order approving standard forms of contract within sixty (60) days of

30

the filing.

31

     SECTION 5. This act shall take effect upon passage.

========

LC004420/SUB A/3

========

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 29 of 29

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N   A C T

RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS - THE CLEAN ENERGY JOBS

PROGRAM

***

1

     This act would create a tariff-based renewable energy distributed generation financing

2

program, or "Renewable Energy Growth Program", to provide for the continuation of the

3

development of the renewable energy growth program in the load zone of the electric distribution

4

company at a reasonable cost.

5

     This act would take effect upon passage.

========

LC004420/SUB A/3

========

 

LC004420/SUB A/3 - Page 30 of 29