2017 -- H 5510 SUBSTITUTE B

========

LC001499/SUB B

========

     STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2017

____________

A N   A C T

RELATING TO COURTS AND CIVIL PROCEDURE--COURTS -- DOMESTIC ASSAULT -

PROTECT RHODE ISLAND FAMILIES ACT

     

     Introduced By: Representatives Tanzi, Amore, Fogarty, Ruggiero, and Maldonado

     Date Introduced: February 15, 2017

     Referred To: House Judiciary

     It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1

     SECTION 1. Section 8-8.1-3 of the General Laws in Chapter 8-8.1 entitled "Domestic

2

Assault" is hereby amended to read as follows:

3

     8-8.1-3. Protective orders -- Penalty -- Jurisdiction.

4

     (a) A person suffering from domestic abuse may file a complaint in the district court

5

requesting any order which will protect her or him from the abuse, including but not limited to the

6

following:

7

     (1) Ordering that the defendant be restrained and enjoined from contacting, assaulting,

8

molesting or otherwise interfering with the plaintiff at home, on the street, or elsewhere, whether

9

the defendant is an adult or minor;

10

     (2) Ordering the defendant to vacate the household forthwith, unless the defendant holds

11

sole legal interest in the household;

12

     (3) Upon motion by the plaintiff, his or her address shall be released only at the discretion

13

of the district court judge;

14

     (4) Ordering the defendant to surrender physical possession of all firearms in their

15

possession, care, custody, or control and shall further order a person restrained not to purchase or

16

receive or attempt to purchase or receive any firearms while the protective order is in effect. The

17

defendant shall surrender said firearms within twenty-four (24) hours of notice of the protective

18

order to the Rhode Island state police or local police department or to a federally licensed

 

1

firearms dealer.

2

     (i) A person ordered to surrender possession of any firearm(s) pursuant to this section

3

shall, within seventy-two (72) hours after being served with the order, either:

4

     (A) File with the court a receipt showing the firearm(s) was physically surrendered to the

5

Rhode Island state police or local police department, or to a federally licensed firearm dealer; or

6

     (B) Attest to the court that, at the time of the order, the person had no firearms in their

7

immediate physical possession or control or subject to their immediate physical possession or

8

control, and that the person, at the time of the attestation, has no firearms in their immediate

9

physical possession or control or subject to their immediate physical possession or control.

10

     (ii) If a person restrained under this section transfers a firearm(s) to a federally licensed

11

firearms dealer pursuant to this section, the person restrained under this section may instruct the

12

federally licensed firearms dealer to sell the firearm(s) or to transfer ownership in accordance

13

with state and federal law, to a qualified named individual who is not a member of the person's

14

dwelling house, who is not related to the person by blood, marriage, or relationship as defined by

15

§15-15-1(3), and who is not prohibited from possessing firearms under state or federal law. The

16

owner of any firearm(s) sold shall receive any financial value received from their sale, less the

17

cost associated with taking possession of, storing, and transferring of the firearm(s).

18

     (iii) Every individual to whom possession of a firearm(s) is transferred pursuant to this

19

subsection shall be prohibited from transferring or returning any firearm(s) to the person

20

restrained under this section while the protective order remains in effect and shall be informed of

21

this prohibition. Any knowing violation of this subsection is a felony which shall be punishable

22

by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by imprisonment for a term of not

23

less than one year and not more than five (5) years, or both.

24

     (iv) An individual to whom possession of a firearm(s) is transferred pursuant to this

25

subsection shall return a firearm(s) to person formerly restrained under this section only if the

26

person formerly restrained under this section provides documentation issued by a court indicating

27

that the restraining order issued pursuant to this section that prohibited the person from

28

purchasing, carrying, transporting, or possessing firearms has expired and has not been extended.

29

     (4)(b) After notice to the respondent and after a hearing, which shall be held within

30

fifteen (15) days of surrendering said firearms, the court , in addition to any other restrictions,

31

may, for any protective order issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2017, continue the order the

32

defendant to of surrender physical possession of all firearms in his or her possession, care,

33

custody or control, and shall further order a person restrained under this section not to purchase or

34

receive or attempt to purchase or receive any firearms while the protective order is in effect.

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 2 of 17

1

     (b) Any individual who accepts physical possession of a firearm pursuant to this section

2

is prohibited from returning any firearm to any defendant under a restraining order during the

3

existence of the restraining order. Violation of this provision shall subject both the defendant and

4

the individual responsible for the return of the firearm to the defendant, to being found in

5

contempt of court.

6

     (c) The district court shall provide a notice on all forms requesting a protective order that,

7

at the hearing for a protective order, the defendant may a person restrained under this section

8

shall be ordered pursuant to §11-47-5, to surrender possession or control of any firearms and not

9

to purchase or receive or attempt to purchase or receive any firearms for a period not to exceed

10

the duration of the while the restraining order is in effect. The form shall further provide that any

11

person who has surrendered their firearms shall be afforded a hearing within fifteen (15) days of

12

surrendering their firearms.

13

     (d) If the defendant is present in court at a duly noticed hearing, the court may, in

14

addition to any other restrictions, order the defendant to physically surrender any firearm(s) in

15

that person's immediate physical possession or control, or subject to that person's immediate

16

physical possession or control, within twenty-four (24) hours of the order, by surrendering the

17

possession of the firearm(s) to the control of any individual not legally prohibited from

18

possessing a firearm who is not related to the defendant by blood, marriage, or relationship as

19

defined by § 15-15-1(3), (4), or (5) of the Rhode Island general laws, or by surrendering any

20

firearm(s) to the Rhode Island state police or local police department, or by surrendering the

21

firearm(s) to a licensed gun dealer. If the defendant is not present at the hearing, the defendant

22

shall surrender the firearm(s) within forty-eight (48) hours after being served with the order. A

23

person ordered to surrender possession of any firearm(s) pursuant to this subsection shall file with

24

the court a receipt showing the firearm(s) was either physically surrendered to an individual not

25

legally prohibited from possessing a firearm who is not related to the defendant by blood,

26

marriage, or relationship as defined by § 15-15-1(3), (4), or (5) or surrender to a licensed gun

27

dealer within seventy-two (72) hours after receiving the order. Any defendant transporting a

28

firearm to surrender in accordance with the above shall not be liable to prosecution under § 11-

29

47-8.

30

     Any firearm surrendered in accordance with this section to the Rhode Island state police

31

or local police department shall be returned to the person formerly restrained under this section

32

upon their request when:

33

     (1) The person formerly restrained under this section produces documentation issued by a

34

court indicating that the restraining order issued pursuant to this section that prohibited the person

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 3 of 17

1

from purchasing, carrying, transporting, or possessing firearms has expired and has not been

2

extended; and

3

     (2) The law enforcement agency in possession of the firearms determines that the person

4

formerly restrained under this section is not otherwise prohibited from possessing a firearm under

5

state or federal law.

6

     (3) The person required to surrender their firearms pursuant to this section shall not be

7

responsible for any costs of storage of any firearms surrendered pursuant to this section.

8

     (e) The Rhode Island state police are authorized to develop rules and procedures

9

pertaining to the storage and return of firearms surrendered to the Rhode Island state police or

10

local police departments pursuant to this section. The Rhode Island state police may consult with

11

the Rhode Island Police Chiefs' Association in developing rules and procedures.

12

     (f) Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit, expand, or in any way modify

13

orders issued under §§12-29-4 or 15-5-19.

14

     (e)(g) Nothing in this section shall limit a defendant's right under existing law to petition

15

the court at a later date for modification of the order.

16

(h) The court shall immediately notify the person suffering from domestic abuse whose

17

complaint gave rise to the protective order and the law enforcement agency where the person

18

restrained under this section resides of the hearing.

19

(i) The person suffering from domestic abuse, local law enforcement, and the person

20

restrained under this section shall all have an opportunity to be present and to testify when the

21

court considers the petition.

22

(j) At the hearing, the person restrained under this section shall have the burden of

23

showing, by clear and convincing evidence, that, if their firearm rights were restored, they would

24

not pose a danger to the person suffering from domestic abuse or to any other person.

25

     (1) In determining whether to restore a person's firearm rights, the court shall examine all

26

relevant evidence, including, but not limited to: the complaint seeking a protective order; the

27

criminal record of the person restrained under this section; the mental health history of the person

28

restrained under this section; any evidence that the person restrained under this section has, since

29

being served with the order, engaged in violent or threatening behavior against the person

30

suffering from domestic abuse or any other person.

31

     (2) If the court determines, after a review of all relevant evidence and after all parties

32

have had an opportunity to be heard, that the person restrained under this section would not pose

33

a danger to the person suffering from domestic abuse or to any other person if their firearm rights

34

were restored, then the court may grant the petition and modify the protective order and lift the

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 4 of 17

1

firearm prohibition.

2

     (3) If the court lifts a person's firearms prohibition pursuant to this subsection, the court

3

shall issue the person written notice that they are no longer prohibited under this section from

4

purchasing or possessing firearms while the protective order is in effect.

5

     (f)(k) The prohibition against possessing a firearm(s) due solely to the existence of a

6

domestic violence restraining order issued under this section shall not apply with respect to sworn

7

peace officers as defined in § 12-7-21 and active members of military service including members

8

of the reserve components thereof, who are required by law or departmental policy to carry

9

departmental firearms while on duty or any person who is required by their employment to carry

10

a firearm in the performance of their duties. Any individual exempted pursuant to this exception

11

may possess a firearm only during the course of their employment. Any firearm required for

12

employment must be stored at the place of employment when not being possessed for

13

employment use; all other firearm(s) must be surrendered in accordance with § 8-8.1-3.

14

     (g)(l) Any violation of the aforementioned protective order shall subject the defendant to

15

being found in contempt of court.

16

     (h)(m) No order shall issue under this section which would have the effect of compelling

17

a defendant who has the sole legal interest in a residence to vacate that residence.

18

     (i)(n) The contempt order shall not be exclusive and shall not preclude any other

19

available civil or criminal remedies. Any relief granted by the court shall be for a fixed period of

20

time not to exceed three (3) years, at the expiration of which time the court may extend any order

21

upon motion of the plaintiff for such additional time as it deems necessary to protect the plaintiff

22

from abuse. The court may modify its order at any time upon motion of either party.

23

     (j)(o) Any violation of a protective order under this chapter of which the defendant has

24

actual notice shall be a misdemeanor which shall be punished by a fine of no more than one

25

thousand dollars ($1,000) or by imprisonment for not more than one year, or both.

26

     (k)(p) The penalties for violation of this section shall also include the penalties provided

27

under § 12-29-5.

28

     (l)(q) "Actual notice" means that the defendant has received a copy of the order by

29

service thereof or by being handed a copy of the order by a police officer pursuant to § 8-8.1-5(d).

30

     (m)(r) The district court shall have criminal jurisdiction over all violations of this chapter.

31

     SECTION 2. Section 11-47-5 of the General Laws in Chapter 11-47 entitled "Weapons"

32

is hereby amended to read as follows:

33

     11-47-5. Possession of arms by person convicted of crime of violence or who is a

34

fugitive from justice.

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 5 of 17

1

     (a) No person who has been convicted in this state or elsewhere of a crime of violence or

2

who is a fugitive from justice shall purchase, own, carry, transport, or have in his or her

3

possession any firearm. If that person:

4

     (1) Has been convicted in this state or elsewhere of a crime of violence;

5

     (2) Is a fugitive from justice;

6

     (3) Has, in this state or elsewhere, entered a plea of nolo contendere to or been convicted

7

of an offense punishable as a felony under §12-29-5; or

8

     (4) Has, in this state or elsewhere, entered a plea of nolo contendere to or been convicted

9

of any of the following offenses punishable as a misdemeanor under §12-29-5:

10

     (i) Simple assault (§11-5-3);

11

     (ii) Cyberstalking and cyberharassment (§11-52-4.2);

12

     (iii) Violation of a protective order (as set forth in §12-29-2(a)(10); or

13

     (iv) Disorderly conduct (§11-45-1).

14

     (A) A disorderly conduct conviction shall result in prohibition under this section if and

15

only if the offense involves the use or attempted use of force or the threatened use of a dangerous

16

weapon.

17

     (5) The provisions of this subsection shall apply to all persons who enter a plea of nolo

18

contendere to or have been convicted of any of the offenses specified in subsections (a)(3) and

19

(a)(4) of this section, unless and until that person's matter has been expunged, or upon the

20

completion of the sentence of a one-year filing, or the end of a one-year probationary period that

21

no longer constitutes a conviction pursuant to §12-18-3.

22

     (b) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a) of this section, no No person

23

convicted of an offense punishable as a felony offense under § 12-29-5 shall purchase, own,

24

carry, transport, or have in his or her possession any firearm, for a period of two (2) years

25

following the date of that conviction. if that person is subject to an order issued pursuant to

26

chapter 15 of title 15, chapter 8.1 of title 8, or an equivalent order in this state or elsewhere,

27

which order was issued after the person restrained has received notice of the proceedings and had

28

an opportunity to be heard.

29

     (c) No person who is in community confinement pursuant to the provisions of § 42-56-

30

20.2 or who is otherwise subject to electronic surveillance or monitoring devices as a condition of

31

parole shall purchase, carry, transport, or have in his or her possession any firearm. This

32

subsection shall not apply to any person who has not been convicted of (or pleaded guilty or nolo

33

contendere to) a crime of violence in a court of competent jurisdiction.

34

     (d) Every person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 6 of 17

1

punished by imprisonment for not less than two (2) nor more than ten (10) years; and for

2

penalties provided in this section he or she shall not be afforded the benefit of suspension or

3

deferment of sentence nor of probation.

4

     SECTION 3. Chapter 11-47 of the General Laws entitled "Weapons" is hereby amended

5

by adding thereto the following section:

6

     11-47-5.4. Surrender of firearms after domestic violence offenses.

7

     (a) A plea of nolo contendere, resulting in a felony or probation or conviction shall

8

prohibit the defendant from purchasing, carrying, transporting, or having in their possession any

9

firearm. Upon such a plea or conviction, the court shall order the defendant to surrender all

10

firearms owned by the person or in the person's possession as described in this section.

11

     (1) Surrender shall be made within twenty-four (24) hours of prohibition to the Rhode

12

Island state police or local law enforcement or to a licensed gun dealer. The arresting law

13

enforcement agency shall be immediately notified by the court of the order to surrender firearms.

14

A law enforcement agency or licensed gun dealer taking possession of a firearm shall issue a

15

proof of surrender to the person surrendering the firearm. The proof of surrender must include the

16

name of the person, the date of surrender, and the serial number, manufacturer, and model of all

17

surrendered firearms.

18

     (2) A defendant transporting a firearm to surrender in accordance with this section shall

19

not be liable to prosecution under §§11-47-5(d) or 11-47-8.

20

     (3) The defendant shall, within forty-eight (48) hours after being served with the order,

21

either:

22

     (i) File a copy of proof of surrender with the court of jurisdiction, and attest that all

23

firearms owned by the person or in the person's possession at the time of plea or conviction have

24

been surrendered in accordance with this section and that the person currently owns no firearms

25

and has no firearms in their possession; or

26

     (ii) Attest that, at the time of plea or conviction, the person owned no firearms and had no

27

firearms in their possession, and that the person currently owns no firearms and has no firearms in

28

their possession.

29

     (4) The court of jurisdiction's copy of proof of surrender shall be kept under seal and

30

shall not be part of the public record.

31

     (5) The Rhode Island state police are authorized to develop rules, regulations and

32

procedures pertaining to the storage of firearms that are surrendered pursuant to this section. The

33

Rhode Island state police may consult with the Rhode Island Police Chiefs' Association in

34

developing rules and procedures. Law enforcement agencies and departments shall observe due

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 7 of 17

1

care in the receipt and storage of any firearm surrendered pursuant to this section. No law

2

enforcement agency shall dispose of any firearm surrendered pursuant to this section unless that

3

firearm is abandoned as provided in this section. The Rhode Island state police may consult with

4

the Rhode Island Police Chiefs' Association in developing rules and procedures.

5

     (6) A firearm surrendered to the Rhode Island state police or a local police department

6

under this section shall be deemed abandoned if:

7

     (i) Six (6) years have passed from the date of the completion of the defendant's sentence

8

for an offense enumerated in §11-47-5(a)(4); and

9

     (ii) During the two (2) years following the six (6)-year period described in subsection

10

(a)(6)(i) of this section, the Rhode Island state police or local police department has provided

11

notice to the defendant, on at least two (2) separate occasions, that if the firearm is not reclaimed

12

it shall be disposed of; and

13

     (iii) After the two (2)-year period described in subsection (a)(6)(ii) of this section and

14

after notice to the defendant, the defendant fails to reclaim the firearm.

15

     (7) The Rhode Island state police may dispose of an abandoned firearm at any time,

16

provided that no disposal shall occur while any appeal of the conviction for a crime enumerated

17

in §11-47-5(a)(4) is pending and provided that the owner of the firearm receives any financial

18

value generated from its disposal less the cost associated with disposing of the firearm.

19

     SECTION 4. Section 12-29-5 of the General Laws in Chapter 12-29 entitled "Domestic

20

Violence Prevention Act" is hereby amended to read as follows:

21

     12-29-5. Disposition of domestic violence cases. [Effective January 1, 2017.]

22

     (a) Every person convicted of, or placed on probation for, a crime involving domestic

23

violence or whose case is filed pursuant to § 12-10-12 where the defendant pleads nolo

24

contendere, in addition to any other sentence imposed or counseling ordered, shall be ordered by

25

the judge to attend, at his or her own expense, a batterer's intervention program appropriate to

26

address his or her violent behavior; provided, however, that the court may permit a

27

servicemember or veteran to complete any court-approved counseling program administered or

28

approved by the Veterans' Administration. This order shall be included in the conditions of

29

probation. Failure of the defendant to comply with the order shall be a basis for violating

30

probation and/or the provisions of § 12-10-12. This provision shall not be suspended or waived

31

by the court.

32

     (b) Every person convicted of, or placed on probation for, a crime involving domestic

33

violence, as enumerated in § 12-29-2 or whose case if filed pursuant to § 12-10-12 where the

34

defendant pleads guilty or nolo contendere, in addition to other court costs or assessments

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 8 of 17

1

imposed, shall be ordered to pay a one hundred twenty-five dollar ($125) assessment. Eighty

2

percent (80%) of the assessment collected pursuant to this section shall be provided to the Rhode

3

Island Coalition Against Domestic Violence for programs to assist victims of domestic violence

4

and twenty percent (20%) of the assessment shall be deposited as general revenue.

5

     (c) (1) Every person convicted of an offense punishable as a misdemeanor involving

6

domestic violence as defined in § 12-29-2 shall:

7

     (i) For a second violation be imprisoned for a term of not less than ten (10) days and not

8

more than one year.

9

     (ii) For a third and subsequent violation be deemed guilty of a felony and be imprisoned

10

for a term of not less than one year and not more than ten (10) years.

11

     (2) No jail sentence provided for under this section can be suspended.

12

     (3) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed as limiting the discretion of the judges to

13

impose additional sanctions authorized in sentencing.

14

     (d) The court shall determine, for every person who pleads nolo contendere to or is

15

convicted of an offense involving domestic violence, as enumerated in §12-29-2, whether, as a

16

result of the plea or conviction, the defendant is prohibited under §11-47-5(a)(3) or §11-47-

17

5(a)(4) from purchasing, owning, carrying, transporting, or having in their possession any

18

firearm.

19

     (1) Prior to the entry of plea of nolo contendere to an offense involving domestic

20

violence, as enumerated in §12-29-2, the court shall advise the defendant that a plea of nolo

21

contendere has the same legal effect and collateral consequences as a plea of guilty.

22

     (2) Prior to the entry of a plea of nolo contendere to an offense punishable as a felony

23

involving domestic violence, as enumerated in §12-29-2, or an offense enumerated in §11-47-

24

5(a)(4), the court shall advise the defendant that, in addition to any other sentence or penalty, the

25

defendant shall, as result of the plea, be prohibited from purchasing, owning, carrying,

26

transporting, or having in their possession any firearm under §11-47-5.

27

     (3) The person required to surrender their firearms pursuant to this section shall not be

28

responsible for any costs of storage of any firearms surrendered pursuant to this section.

29

     (d)(e) For the purposes of this section, "batterers intervention program" means a program

30

which is certified by the batterers intervention program standards oversight committee according

31

to minimum standards, pursuant to §§ 12-29-5.1, 12-29-5.2, and 12-29-5.3.

32

     (e)(f) For purposes of this section, "servicemember" means a person who is presently

33

serving in the armed forces of the United States, including the Coast Guard, a reserve component

34

thereof, or the National Guard. "Veteran" means a person who has served in the armed forces,

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 9 of 17

1

including the Coast Guard of the United States, a reserve component thereof, or the National

2

Guard, and has been discharged under other than dishonorable conditions.

3

     (f)(g) The court shall indicate on every record of conviction or a plea of nolo contendere

4

for an offense punishable as a felony involving domestic violence, as defined in § 12-29-2, that

5

the defendant is prohibited under §§ 11-47-5 and 11-47-5.3 from purchasing, owning, carrying,

6

transporting, or having in their possession, any firearm(s). The court shall inform the defendant of

7

their prohibited status and shall order the defendant to surrender any firearm(s) in their

8

ownership, possession, care, custody or control in accordance with § 11-47-5.3.

9

     (h) The court shall indicate on every record of conviction or a plea of nolo contendere for

10

an offense enumerated in §11-47-5(a)(4) that the defendant is prohibited under §§11-47-5 and 11-

11

47-5.4 from purchasing, owning, carrying, transporting, or having in their possession, any

12

firearm(s). The court shall inform the defendant of their prohibited status, shall order the

13

defendant to surrender any firearm(s) in their ownership, possession, care, custody or control, and

14

shall ensure that surrender is made in accordance with §11-47-5.4.

15

     (g)(i) No proceeds shall be provided to any person if the firearm(s) is destroyed pursuant

16

to this section.

17

     (h)(j) Any firearm(s) used in the commission of the offense leading to the conviction

18

pursuant to this section shall be forfeited to the state upon conviction.

19

     SECTION 5. Section 15-15-3 of the General Laws in Chapter 15-15 entitled "Domestic

20

Abuse Prevention" is hereby amended to read as follows:

21

     15-15-3. Protective orders -- Penalty -- Jurisdiction.

22

     (a) A person suffering from domestic abuse may file a complaint in the family court

23

requesting any order which will protect and support her or him from abuse including, but not

24

limited, to the following:

25

     (1) Ordering that the defendant be restrained and enjoined from contacting, assaulting,

26

molesting, or interfering with the plaintiff at home, on the street, or elsewhere, whether the

27

defendant is an adult or a minor;

28

     (2) Ordering the defendant to vacate the household immediately;

29

     (3) Awarding the plaintiff custody of the minor children of the parties, if any;

30

     (4) Ordering the defendant to surrender physical possession of all firearms in their

31

possession, care, custody, or control and shall further order a person restrained not to purchase or

32

receive or attempt to purchase or receive any firearms while the protective order is in effect. The

33

defendant shall surrender said firearms within twenty-four (24) hours of notice of the protective

34

order to the Rhode Island state police or local police department or to a federally licensed

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 10 of 17

1

firearms dealer.

2

     (i) A person ordered to surrender possession of any firearm(s) pursuant to this section

3

shall, within seventy-two (72) hours after being served with the order, either:

4

     (A) File with the court a receipt showing the firearm(s) was physically surrendered to the

5

Rhode Island state police or local police department, or to a federally licensed firearms dealer; or

6

     (B) Attest to the court that, at the time of the order, the person had no firearms in their

7

immediate physical possession or control or subject to their immediate physical possession or

8

control, and that the person, at the time of the attestation, has no firearms in their immediate

9

physical possession or control or subject to their immediate physical possession or control.

10

     (ii) If a person restrained under this section transfers a firearm(s) to a federally licensed

11

firearms dealer pursuant to this section, the person restrained under this section may instruct the

12

federally licensed firearms dealer to sell the firearm(s) or to transfer ownership, in accordance

13

with state and federal law, to a qualified named individual who is not a member of the person's

14

dwelling house, who is not related to the person by blood, marriage, or relationship as defined by

15

§15-15-1(3), and who is not prohibited from possessing firearms under state or federal law. The

16

owner of any firearm(s) sold shall receive any financial value received from their sale, less the

17

cost associated with taking possession of, storing, and transferring of the firearm(s).

18

     (iii) Every individual to whom ownership of a firearm(s) is transferred pursuant to this

19

subsection shall be prohibited from transferring or returning any firearm(s) to the person

20

restrained under this section while the protective order remains in effect and shall be informed of

21

this prohibition, Any knowing violation of this subsection is a felony which shall be punishable

22

by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by imprisonment for a term of not

23

less than one year and not more than five (5) years, or both.

24

     (iv) An individual to whom ownership of a firearm(s) is transferred pursuant to this

25

subsection shall return a firearm(s) to person formerly restrained under this section only if the

26

person formerly restrained under this section provides documentation issued by a court indicating

27

that the restraining order issued pursuant to this section that prohibited the person from

28

purchasing, carrying, transporting or possessing firearms has expired and has not been extended.

29

     (4)(5) After notice to the respondent and a hearing, ordering either party to make

30

payments for the support of a minor child or children of the parties as required by law for a period

31

not to exceed ninety (90) days, unless the child support order is for a child or children receiving

32

public assistance pursuant to chapter 5.1 of title 40. In these cases, legal counsel for the division

33

of taxation, child support enforcement, shall be notified as a party in interest to appear for the

34

purpose of establishing a child support order under a new or existing docket number previously

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 11 of 17

1

assigned to the parties and not under the protective docket number. The child support order shall

2

remain in effect until the court modifies or suspends the order.

3

     (5)(b) After notice to the respondent and a hearing, which shall be held within fifteen (15)

4

days of surrendering said firearms, the court, in addition to any other restrictions, may, order the

5

defendant to surrender physical possession of all firearms in his or her possession, care, custody

6

or control. for any protective order issued after or renewed on or after July 1, 2017, continue the

7

order of surrender, and shall further order a person restrained under this section not to purchase or

8

receive or attempt to purchase or receive any firearms while the protective order is in effect.

9

     (b) Any individual who accepts physical possession of a firearm pursuant to this section

10

is prohibited from returning any firearm to any defendant under a restraining order during the

11

existence of the restraining order. Violation of this provision shall subject both the defendant and

12

the individual responsible for the return of the firearm to the defendant, to being found in

13

contempt of court.

14

     (c) The Family Court shall provide a notice on all forms requesting a protective order

15

that, at the hearing for a protective order, the defendant may be ordered to surrender physical

16

possession or control of any firearms and not to purchase or receive or attempt to purchase or

17

receive any firearms for a period not to exceed the duration of the restraining order. that a person

18

restrained under this section shall be ordered pursuant to §11-47-5 to surrender possession of any

19

firearms while the protective order is in effect. The form shall further provide that any person

20

who has surrender their firearms shall be afforded a hearing within fifteen (15) days of

21

surrendering their firearms.

22

     (d) If the defendant is present in court at a duly noticed hearing, the court may order the

23

defendant to physically surrender any firearm in that person's immediate possession or control, or

24

subject to that person's immediate physical possession or control, within twenty-four (24) hours

25

of the order, by surrendering the possession of the firearm(s) to the control of any individual not

26

legally prohibited from possessing a firearm(s) who is not related to the defendant by blood,

27

marriage, or relationship as defined by § 15-15-1(3), (4), or (5), of the Rhode Island general laws,

28

or by surrendering any firearm(s) to the Rhode Island State Police or local police department, or

29

by surrendering the firearm(s) to a licensed gun dealer. If the defendant is not present at the

30

hearing, the defendant shall surrender possession of the firearm(s) within forty-eight (48) hours

31

after being served with the order. A person ordered to surrender possession of any firearm(s)

32

pursuant to this subsection shall file with the court a receipt showing the firearm(s) was either

33

legally transferred to an individual not legally prohibited from possessing a firearm who is not

34

related to the defendant by blood, marriage, or relationship as defined by § 15-15-1(3), (4), or (5)

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 12 of 17

1

of the Rhode Island general laws or surrender to a licensed gun dealer within seventy-two (72)

2

hours after receiving the order. Any defendant transporting a firearm to surrender in accordance

3

with the above shall not be liable to prosecution under § 11-47-8.

4

     (d) Any firearm surrendered in accordance with this section to the Rhode Island state

5

police or local police department shall be returned to the person formerly restrained under this

6

section upon their request when:

7

     (1) The person formerly restrained under this section produces documentation issued by a

8

court indicating that the restraining order issued pursuant to this section that prohibited the person

9

from purchasing, carrying, transporting or possessing firearms has expired and has not been

10

extended; and

11

     (2) The law enforcement agency in possession of the firearms determined that the person

12

formerly restrained under this section is not otherwise prohibited from possessing a firearm under

13

state or federal law.

14

     (3) The person required to surrender their firearms pursuant to this section shall not be

15

responsible for any costs of storage of any firearms surrendered pursuant to this section.

16

     (e) The Rhode Island state police are authorized to develop rules and procedures

17

pertaining to the storage and return of firearms surrendered to the Rhode Island state police or

18

local police departments pursuant to this section. The Rhode Island state police may consult with

19

the Rhode Island Police Chiefs' Association in developing rules and procedures.

20

     (f) Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit, expand, or in any way modify

21

orders issued under §12-29-7 or §15-5-19.

22

     (e)(g) Nothing in this section shall limit a defendant's right under existing law to petition

23

the court at a later date for modification of the order.

24

     (h) The court shall immediately notify the person suffering from domestic abuse whose

25

complaint gave rise to the protective order and the law enforcement agency where the person

26

restrained under this section resides of the hearing.

27

     (i) The person suffering from domestic abuse, local law enforcement, and the person

28

restrained under this section shall all have an opportunity to be present and to testify when the

29

court considers the petition.

30

     (j) At the hearing, the person restrained under this section shall have the burden of

31

showing, by clear and convincing evidence, that, if their firearm rights were restored, they would

32

not pose a danger to the person suffering from domestic abuse or to any other person.

33

     (1) In determining whether to restore a person's firearm rights, the court shall examine all

34

relevant evidence, including, but not limited to: the complaint seeking a protective order; the

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 13 of 17

1

criminal record of the person restrained under this section; the mental health history of the person

2

restrained under this section; any evidence that the person restrained under this section has, since

3

being served with the order, engaged in violent or threatening behavior against the person

4

suffering from domestic abuse or any other person.

5

     (2) If the court determined, after a review of all relevant evidence and after all parties

6

have had an opportunity to be heard, that the person restrained under this section would not pose

7

a danger to the person suffering from domestic abuse or to any other person if their firearm rights

8

were restored, then the court may grant the petition and modify the protective order and lift the

9

firearm prohibition.

10

     (3) If the court lifts a person's firearms prohibition pursuant to this subsection, the court

11

shall issue the person written notice that they are no longer prohibited under this section from

12

purchasing or possessing firearms while the protective order is in effect.

13

      (f)(k) The prohibition against possessing a firearm(s) due solely to the existence of a

14

domestic violence restraining order issued under this section shall not apply with respect to sworn

15

peace officers as defined in § 12-7-21 and active members of military service including members

16

of the reserve components thereof, who are required by law or departmental policy to carry

17

departmental firearms while on duty or any person who is required by their employment to carry

18

a firearm in the performance of their duties. Any individual exempted pursuant to this exception

19

may possess a firearm only during the course of their employment. Any firearm required for

20

employment must be stored at the place of employment when not being possessed for

21

employment use; all other firearm(s) must be surrendered in accordance with § 15-15-3.

22

     (g)(l) Upon motion by the plaintiff, his or her address shall be released only at the

23

discretion of the family court judge.

24

     (h)(m) (1) Any violation of the protective orders in subsection (a) of this section shall

25

subject the defendant to being found in contempt of court.

26

     (2) The contempt order shall not be exclusive and shall not preclude any other available

27

civil or criminal remedies. Any relief granted by the court shall be for a fixed period of time not

28

to exceed three (3) years, at the expiration of which time the court may extend any order, upon

29

motion of the plaintiff, for any additional time, that it deems necessary to protect the plaintiff

30

from abuse. The court may modify its order at any time upon motion of either party.

31

     (i)(n) (1) Any violation of a protective order under this chapter of which the defendant

32

has actual notice shall be a misdemeanor which shall be punished by a fine of no more than one

33

thousand dollars ($1,000) or by imprisonment for not more than one year, or both.

34

     (2) The penalties for violation of this section shall also include the penalties as provided

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 14 of 17

1

by § 12-29-5.

2

     (j)(o) Actual notice means that the defendant has received a copy of the order by service

3

or by being handed a copy of the order by a police officer pursuant to § 15-15-5(d).

4

     (k)(p) (1) The district court shall have criminal jurisdiction over all adult violations of

5

this chapter.

6

     (2) The family court shall have jurisdiction over all juvenile violations of this chapter.

7

     SECTION 6. Chapter 11-47 of the General Laws entitled "Weapons" is hereby amended

8

by adding thereto the following section:

9

     11-47-5.5. Motion to lift firearms prohibition for persons convicted of specified

10

misdemeanor domestic violence offenses -- Consecutive prohibitions -- Return of

11

surrendered firearms.

12

     (a) A person prohibited from purchasing, owning, carrying, transporting, or having in

13

their possession any firearm solely because of a plea of nolo contendere to or a conviction of an

14

offense enumerated in §11-47-5(a)(4) may file a motion in the district court to have that firearm

15

prohibition lifted in accordance with this section. A person who is otherwise prohibited under

16

state law from purchasing, owning, carrying, transporting, or having in their possession any

17

firearm shall not be eligible for relief under this section.

18

     (b) Except for those cases where the defendant is eligible to reclaim firearms after the one

19

year completion of a filing or probation under §12-18-3, a person shall become eligible to file a

20

motion seeking relief under this section after five (5) years from the date of the completion of his

21

or her sentence, unless, during that five (5)-year period, the person enters a plea of nolo

22

contendere to or is convicted of any new offense enumerated in §11-47-5(a)(4).

23

     (1) A person already prohibited from purchasing, owning, carrying, transporting, or

24

having in their possession any firearm under §11-47-5(a)(4) who pleads nolo contendere to or is

25

convicted of any new offense enumerated in §11-47-5(a)(4) shall be subject to an additional six

26

(6)-year firearm prohibition under §11-47-5(a)(4). That additional prohibition shall run

27

consecutively to the prohibition already in effect at the time the person pleaded nolo contendere

28

to or was convicted of the new offense.

29

     (2) A person made subject to consecutive firearms prohibitions in accordance with this

30

subsection shall not become eligible to file a motion seeking relief under this section until their

31

consecutive prohibition periods have fully elapsed.

32

     (c) No filing fee shall be charged for the filing of a motion seeking relief under this

33

section.

34

     (d) The district court shall schedule a hearing on a motion seeking relief under this

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 15 of 17

1

section no later than thirty (30) days from the date the motion is filed.

2

     (e) The district court shall only consider whether the required amount of time to retrieve

3

the firearms has expired, and that no other legal prohibition exists to prevent the respondent from

4

recovering his or her firearms. If the court lifts a person's firearm prohibition pursuant to this

5

section, the court shall issue the person written notice that the person is no longer prohibited from

6

purchasing, owning, carrying, transporting, or having in their possession any firearm under §11-

7

47-5(a)(4).

8

     (f) A firearm surrendered to the Rhode Island state police or a local police department by

9

a person formerly prohibited under §11-47-5(a)(4) who is granted relief under this section shall

10

be returned to the person upon their request when:

11

     (1) The person formerly prohibited under §11-47-5(a)(4) provides written proof issued by

12

the court indicating that the firearm prohibition has been lifted pursuant to this section; and

13

     (2) The Rhode Island state police or a local police department determines that the person

14

formerly prohibited under §11-47-5(a)(4) is not otherwise prohibited from possessing a firearm

15

under state or federal law.

16

     (g) A court's grant of relief pursuant to this section shall not constitute an expungement,

17

nor shall it in any way impact, negate, or otherwise modify the person's prior conviction of an

18

offense enumerated in §11-47-5(a)(4).

19

     SECTION 7. This act shall take effect upon passage.

========

LC001499/SUB B

========

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 16 of 17

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N   A C T

RELATING TO COURTS AND CIVIL PROCEDURE--COURTS -- DOMESTIC ASSAULT -

PROTECT RHODE ISLAND FAMILIES ACT

***

1

     This act would limit access to firearms when an individual is under certain types of

2

domestic restraining orders or protective orders issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2017.

3

     This act would take effect upon passage.

========

LC001499/SUB B

========

 

LC001499/SUB B - Page 17 of 17