2018 -- S 2689 SUBSTITUTE A

========

LC004877/SUB A

========

     STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2018

____________

A N   A C T

RELATING TO BEHAVIORAL HEALTHCARE, DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES AND

HOSPITALS

     Introduced By: Senator Erin Lynch Prata

     Date Introduced: March 20, 2018

     Referred To: Senate Judiciary

     It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

     SECTION 1. Section 40.1-5-8 of the General Laws in Chapter 40.1-5 entitled "Mental

Health Law" is hereby amended to read as follows:

     40.1-5-8. Civil court certification.

     (a) Petitions. A verified petition may be filed in the district court, or family court in the

case of a person who has not reached his or her eighteenth (18th) birthday, for the certification to

a facility of any person who is alleged to be in need of care and treatment in a facility, and whose

continued unsupervised presence in the community would create a likelihood of serious harm by

reason of mental disability. The petition may be filed by any person with whom the subject of the

petition may reside; or at whose house he or she may be; or the father or mother, husband or wife,

brother or sister, or the adult child of any such person; the nearest relative if none of the above are

available; or his or her guardian; or the attorney general; or a local director of public welfare; or

the director of the department of behavioral healthcare, developmental disabilities and hospitals;

the director of the department of human services; or the director of the department of corrections;

the director of the department of health; the warden of the adult correctional institutions; the

superintendent of the boys training school for youth, or his or her designated agent; or the director

of any facility, or his or her designated agent, whether or not the person shall have been admitted

and is a patient at the time of the petition. A petition under this section shall be filed only after the

petitioner has investigated what alternatives to certification are available and determined why the

alternatives are not deemed suitable.

     (b) Contents of petition. The petition shall state that it is based upon a personal

observation of the person concerned by the petitioner within a ten-day (10) period prior to filing.

It shall include a description of the behavior that constitutes the basis for the petitioner's judgment

that the person concerned is in need of care and treatment and that a likelihood of serious harm by

reason of mental disability exists. In addition, the petitioner shall indicate what alternatives to

certification are available; what alternatives have been investigated; and why the investigated

alternatives are not deemed suitable.

     (c) Certificates and contents thereof. A petition hereunder shall be accompanied by the

certificates of two (2) physicians unless the petitioner is unable to afford, or is otherwise unable

to obtain, the services of a physician or physicians qualified to make the certifications. The

certificates shall be rendered pursuant to the provisions of § 40.1-5-5, except when the patient is a

resident in a facility, the attending physician and one other physician from the facility may sign

the certificates, and shall set forth that the prospective patient is in need of care and treatment in a

facility and would likely benefit therefrom, and is one whose continued unsupervised presence in

the community would create a likelihood of serious harm by reason of mental disability together

with the reasons therefor. The petitions and accompanying certificates shall be executed under

penalty of perjury, but shall not require the signature of a notary public thereon.

     (d) Preliminary hearing.

     (1) Upon a determination that the petition sets forth facts constituting reasonable grounds

to support certification, the court shall summon the person to appear before the court at a

preliminary hearing, scheduled no later than five (5) business days from the date of filing. This

hearing shall be treated as a priority on the court calendar and may be continued only for good

cause shown. In default of an appearance, the court may issue a warrant directing a police officer

to bring the person before the court.

     (2) At the preliminary hearing, the court shall serve a copy of the petition upon the person

and advise him or her of the nature of the proceedings and of his or her right to counsel. If the

person is unable to afford counsel, the court forthwith shall appoint the mental health advocate for

him or her. If the court finds that there is no probable cause to support certification, the petition

shall be dismissed, and the person shall be discharged unless the person applies for voluntary

admission. However, if the court is satisfied by the testimony that there is probable cause to

support certification, a final hearing shall be held not less than seven (7) days, nor more than

twenty-one (21) days, after the preliminary hearing, unless continued at the request of counsel for

the person, and notice of the date set down for the hearing shall be served on the person. Copies

LC004877/SUB A - Page 2 of 6

of the petition and notice of the date set down for the hearing shall also be served immediately

upon the person's nearest relatives or legal guardian, if known, and to any other person designated

by the patient, in writing, to receive copies of notices. The preliminary hearing can be waived by

a motion of the patient to the court if the patient is a resident of a facility.

     (e) Petition for examination.

     (1) Upon motion of either the petitioner or the person, or upon its own motion, the court

may order that the person be examined by a psychiatrist appointed by the court. The examination

may be conducted on an outpatient basis and the person shall have the right to the presence of

counsel while it is being conducted. A report of the examination shall be furnished to the court,

the petitioner, and the person and his or her counsel at least forty-eight (48) hours prior to the

hearing.

     (2) If the petition is submitted without two (2) physicians' certificates as required under

subsection (c), the petition shall be accompanied by a motion for a psychiatric examination to be

ordered by the court. The motion shall be heard on the date of the preliminary hearing set by the

court pursuant to subsection (d), or as soon thereafter as counsel for the subject person is

engaged, appointed, and ready to proceed. The motion shall be verified or accompanied by

affidavits and shall set forth facts demonstrating the efforts made to secure examination and

certification by a physician or physicians and shall indicate the reasons why the efforts failed.

     (3) After considering the motion and such testimony as may be offered on the date of

hearing the motion, the court may deny the application and dismiss the petition, or upon finding:

(i) That there is a good cause for the failure to obtain one or more physician's certificates in

accordance with subsection (c); and (ii) That there is probable cause to substantiate the

allegations of the petition, the court shall order an immediate examination by two (2) qualified

psychiatrists, pursuant to subsection (e)(1).

     (f) Professional assistance. A person with respect to whom a court hearing has been

ordered under this section shall have, and be informed of, a right to employ a mental health

professional of his or her choice to assist him or her in connection with the hearing and to testify

on his or her behalf. If the person cannot afford to engage such a professional, the court shall, on

application, allow a reasonable fee for the purpose.

     (g) Procedure. Upon receipt of the required certificates and/or psychiatric reports as

applicable hereunder, the court shall schedule the petition for final hearing unless, upon review of

the reports and certificates, the court concludes that the certificates and reports do not indicate,

with supporting reasons, that the person who is the subject of the petition is in need of care and

treatment; that his or her unsupervised presence in the community would create a likelihood of

LC004877/SUB A - Page 3 of 6

serious harm by reason of mental disability; and that all alternatives to certification have been

investigated and are unsuitable, in which event the court may dismiss the petition.

     (h) Venue. An application for certification under this section shall be made to, and all

proceedings pursuant thereto shall be conducted in, the district court, or family court in the case

of a person who has not yet reached his or her eighteenth (18th) birthday, of the division or

county in which the subject of an application may reside or may be, or when the person is already

a patient in a facility, in the district court or family court of the division or county in which the

facility is located, subject, however, to application by any interested party for change of venue

because of inconvenience of the parties or witnesses or the condition of the subject of the petition

or other valid judicial reason for the change of venue.

     (i) Hearing. A hearing scheduled under this section shall be conducted pursuant to the

following requirements:

     (1) All evidence shall be presented according to the usual rules of evidence that apply in

civil, non-jury cases. The subject of the proceedings shall have the right to present evidence in his

or her own behalf and to cross examine all witnesses against him or her, including any physician

who has completed a certificate or filed a report as provided hereunder. The subject of the

proceedings shall have the further right to subpoena witnesses and documents, the cost of such to

be borne by the court where the court finds, upon an application of the subject that the person

cannot afford to pay for the cost of subpoenaing witnesses and documents.

     (2) A verbatim transcript or electronic recording shall be made of the hearing that shall be

impounded and obtained or examined only with the consent of the subject thereof (or in the case

of a person who has not yet attained his or her eighteenth (18th) birthday, his or her parent,

guardian, or next of kin) or by order of the court.

     (3) The hearing may be held at a location other than a court, including any facility where

the subject may currently be a patient, where it appears to the court that holding the hearing at

another location would be in the best interests of the subject thereof.

     (4) The burden of proceeding and the burden of proof in a hearing held pursuant to this

section shall be upon the petitioner. The petitioner has the burden of demonstrating that the

subject of the hearing is in need of care and treatment in a facility, is one whose continued

unsupervised presence in the community would create a likelihood of serious harm by reason of

mental disability, and what alternatives to certification are available, what alternatives to

certification were investigated, and why these alternatives were not deemed suitable.

     (5) The court shall render a decision within forty-eight (48) hours after the hearing is

concluded.

LC004877/SUB A - Page 4 of 6

     (j) Order. If the court at a final hearing finds by clear and convincing evidence that the

subject of the hearing is in need of care and treatment in a facility, and is one whose continued

unsupervised presence in the community would, by reason of mental disability, create a

likelihood of serious harm, and that all alternatives to certification have been investigated and

deemed unsuitable, it shall issue an order committing the person to the custody of the director for

care and treatment or to an appropriate facility. In either event, and to the extent practicable, the

person shall be cared for in a facility that imposes the least restraint upon the liberty of the person

consistent with affording him or her the care and treatment necessary and appropriate to his or her

condition. No certification shall be made under this section unless and until full consideration has

been given by the certifying court to the alternatives to in-patient care, including, but not limited

to, a determination of the person's relationship to the community and to his or her family, of his

or her employment possibilities, and of all available community resources, alternate available

living arrangements, foster care, community residential facilities, nursing homes, and other

convalescent facilities. A certificate ordered pursuant to this section shall be valid for a period of

six (6) months from the date of the order. At the end of that period the patient shall be discharged,

unless he or she is discharged prior to that time, in which case the certification shall expire on the

date of the discharge.

     (k) Appeals.

     (1) A person certified under this section shall have a right to appeal from a final hearing

to the supreme court of the state within thirty (30) days of the entry of an order of certification.

The person shall have the right to be represented on appeal by counsel of his or her choice or by

the mental health advocate if the supreme court finds that he or she cannot afford to retain

counsel. Upon a showing of indigency, the supreme court shall permit an appeal to proceed

without payment of costs, and a copy of the transcript of the proceedings below shall be furnished

to the subject of the proceedings, or to his or her attorney, at the expense of the state. The

certifying court shall advise the person of all his or her rights pursuant to this section immediately

upon the entry of an order of certification.

     (2) Appeals under this section shall be given precedence, insofar as practicable, on the

supreme court dockets. The district and family courts shall promulgate rules with the approval of

the supreme court to insure the expeditious transmission of the record and transcript in all appeals

pursuant to this chapter.

     (l) Submission to NICS database.

     (1) The district court shall submit the name, date of birth, gender, race or ethnicity, and

date of civil commitment to the NICS database of all persons subject to a civil court certification

LC004877/SUB A - Page 5 of 6

order pursuant to this section within forty-eight (48) hours of certification.

     (2) Any person affected by the provisions of this section, after the lapse of a period of

three (3) years from the date such civil certification is terminated, shall have the right to appear

before the relief from disqualifiers board.

     (3) Upon notice of a successful appeal pursuant to § 40.1-5-8(k), the district court shall,

as soon as practicable, cause the appellant's record to be updated, corrected, modified, or removed

from any database maintained and made available to the National Instant Criminal Background

Check System (NICS) and reflect that the appellant is no longer subject to a firearms prohibition

as it relates to 18 U.S.C. § 922(d)(4) and 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4).

     (m) Equitable authority. In addition to the powers heretofore exercised, the district and

family courts are hereby empowered, in furtherance of their jurisdiction under this chapter,

petitions for instructions for the provision or withholding of treatment as justice and equity may

require.

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

========

LC004877/SUB A

========

LC004877/SUB A - Page 6 of 6

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N   A C T

RELATING TO BEHAVIORAL HEALTHCARE, DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES AND

HOSPITALS

***

     This act would grant the district and family courts the explicit statutory authority to issue

equitable orders incidental to their adjudication of matters falling within their jurisdiction under

this chapter.

     This act would take effect upon passage.

========

LC004877/SUB A

========

LC004877/SUB A - Page 7 of 6