2019 -- S 0055

========

LC000477

========

     STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2019

____________

A N   A C T

RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT - ESTABLISHING A SMALL

BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT FUND

     Introduced By: Senators Conley, Cano, DiPalma, Felag, and Pearson

     Date Introduced: January 16, 2019

     Referred To: Senate Finance

     It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

     SECTION 1. Title 42 of the General Laws entitled "STATE AFFAIRS AND

GOVERNMENT" is hereby amended by adding thereto the following chapter:

CHAPTER 64.33

THE RHODE ISLAND SMALL BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT FUND

     42-64.33-1. Short title.

     This chapter shall be known and may be cited as the "Rhode Island Small Business

Development Fund."

     42-64.33-2. Definitions.

     (a) As used in this chapter:

     (1) "Affiliate" means an entity that directly, or indirectly, through one or more

intermediaries, controls, or is controlled by, or is under common control with another entity. For

the purposes of this chapter, an entity is "controlled by" another entity if the controlling entity

holds, directly or indirectly, the majority voting or ownership interest in the controlled entity or

has control over the day-to-day operations of the controlled entity by contract or by law.

     (2) "Applicable percentage" means zero percent (0%) for the first three (3) credit

allowance dates, and twenty-one and one-half percent (21.5%) for the fourth, fifth, and sixth

credit allowance dates.

     (3) "Capital investment" means any equity investment in a small business development

fund by a small business fund investor that:

     (i) Is acquired after the effective date of this chapter at its original issuance solely in

exchange for cash;

     (ii) Has one hundred percent (100%) of its cash purchase price used by the small business

development fund to make qualified investments in eligible businesses located in this state within

three (3) years of the initial credit allowance date; and

     (iii) Is designated by the small business development fund as a capital investment under

this chapter and is certified by the department pursuant to § 42-64.33-4. This term shall include

any capital investment that does not meet the provisions of § 42-64.33-4(a) if the investment was

a capital investment in the hands of a prior holder.

     (4) "Credit allowance date" means the date on which a capital investment is made and

each of the five (5) anniversary dates of the date thereafter.

     (5) "Department" means the Rhode Island commerce corporation.

     (6) "Eligible business" means a business that, at the time of the initial qualified

investment in the company:

     (i) Has less than two hundred fifty (250) employees;

     (ii) Has not more than fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000) in net income from the

preceding tax year;

     (iii) Has its principal business operations in this state; and

     (iv) Is engaged in industries related to clean energy, biomedical innovation, life sciences,

information technology, software, cyber physical systems, cybersecurity, data analytics, defense,

shipbuilding, maritime, composites, advanced business services, design, food, manufacturing,

transportation, distribution, logistics, arts, education, hospitality, tourism, or, if not engaged in the

industries, the department makes a determination that the investment will be beneficial to the

economic growth of the state.

     (7) "Eligible distribution" means:

     (i) A distribution of cash to one or more equity owners of a small business fund investor

to fully or partially offset a projected increase in the owner's federal or state tax liability,

including any penalties and interest, related to the owner's ownership, management, or operation

of the small business fund investor;

     (ii) A distribution of cash as payment of interest and principal on the debt of the small

business fund investor or small business development fund; or

     (iii) A distribution of cash related to the reasonable costs and expenses of forming,

syndicating, managing, and operating the small business fund investor or the small business

LC000477 - Page 2 of 11

development fund, or a return of equity to affiliates of a small business fund investor or small

business development fund. The distributions may include reasonable and necessary fees paid for

professional services, including legal and accounting services, related to the formation and

operation of the small business development fund.

     (8) "Jobs created" means a newly created position of employment that was not previously

located in the state at the time of the qualified investment in the eligible business and requiring a

minimum of thirty five (35) hours worked each week, measured each year by subtracting the

number of employment positions at the time of the initial qualified investment in the eligible

business from the monthly average of employment positions for the applicable year. The number

shall not be less than zero.

     (9) "Jobs retained" means a position requiring a minimum of thirty five (35) hours

worked each week that existed prior to the initial qualified investment. Retained jobs shall be

counted each year based on the monthly average of employment positions for the applicable year.

The number shall not exceed the initial amount of retained jobs reported and shall be reduced

each year if employment at the eligible business concern drops below that number.

     (10) "Minority business enterprise" means a small business concern which is certified by

the Rhode Island office of diversity, equity and opportunity as being a minority or women

business enterprise.

     (11) "Principal business operations" means the location where at least sixty percent

(60%) of a business's employees work or where employees who are paid at least sixty percent

(60%) percent of the business's payroll work. A business that has agreed to relocate employees

using the proceeds of a qualified investment to establish its principal business operations in a new

location shall be deemed to have its principal business operations in the new location if it satisfies

these requirements no later than one hundred eighty (180) days after receiving a qualified

investment.

     (12) "Purchase price" means the amount paid to the small business development fund that

issues a capital investment which shall not exceed the amount of capital investment authority

certified pursuant to § 42-64.33-4.

     (13) "Qualified investment" means any investment in an eligible business or any loan to

an eligible business with a stated maturity date of at least one year after the date of issuance,

excluding revolving lines of credit and senior secured debt unless the eligible business has a

credit refusal letter or similar correspondence from a depository institution or a referral letter or

similar correspondence from a depository institution referring the business to a small business

development fund; provided that, with respect to any one eligible business, the maximum amount

LC000477 - Page 3 of 11

of investments made in the business by one or more small business development funds, on a

collective basis with all of the businesses' affiliates, with the proceeds of capital investments shall

be twenty percent (20%) of the small business development fund's capital investment authority,

exclusive of investments made with repaid or redeemed investments or interest or profits realized

thereon. An eligible business, on a collective basis with all of the businesses' affiliates, is

prohibited from receiving more than four million dollars ($4,000,000) in investments from one or

more small business development funds with the proceeds of capital investments.

     (14) "Small business development fund" means an entity certified by the department

under § 42-64.33-4.

     (15) "Small business fund investor" means an entity that makes a capital investment in a

small business development fund.

     (16) "State" means the state of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations.

     (17) "State tax liability" means any liability incurred by any entity under § 44-17-1 et

seq., § 27-2-17 or, if the taxes are eliminated or reduced, the term shall also mean any tax liability

imposed on an entity or other person that had tax liability under the laws of this state.

     42-64.33-3. Tax credit established.

     (a) Upon making a capital investment in a small business development fund, a small

business fund investor earns a vested right to a credit against the entity's state tax liability that

may be utilized on each credit allowance date of the capital investment in an amount equal to the

applicable percentage for the credit allowance date multiplied by the purchase price paid to the

small business development fund for the capital investment. The amount of the credit claimed by

a small business fund investor shall not exceed the amount of the entity's state tax liability for the

tax year for which the credit is claimed. Any amount of credit that a small business investor is

prohibited from claiming in a taxable year as a result of this section may be carried forward for

use in any subsequent taxable year. It is the intent of this chapter that a small business investor

claiming a credit under this section is not required to pay any additional tax that may arise as a

result of claiming the credit.

     (b) No credit claimed under this section shall be refundable or saleable on the open

market. Credits earned by or allocated to a partnership, limited liability company, or S

corporation may be allocated to the partners, members, or shareholders of the entity for their

direct use in accordance with the provisions of any agreement among the partners, members, or

shareholders, and a small business development fund must notify the department of the names of

the entities that are eligible to utilize credits pursuant to an allocation of credits or a change in

allocation of credits or due to a transfer of a capital investment upon the allocation, change, or

LC000477 - Page 4 of 11

transfer. The allocation shall be not considered a sale for purposes of this section. Interest in a

partnership, limited liability company, or S corporation may be earned by the purchase of an

equity interest in the partnership, limited liability company or S corporation or the purchase of a

debt instrument issued by the partnership, limited liability company, or S corporation.

     42-64.33-4. Application, approval and allocations.

     (a) A small business development fund that seeks to have an equity investment certified

as a capital investment and eligible for credits under this chapter shall apply to the department.

The department shall begin accepting applications within ninety (90) days of the effective date of

this chapter. The small business development fund shall include the following:

     (1) The amount of capital investment requested;

     (2) A copy of the applicant's or an affiliate of the applicant's license as a rural business

investment company under 7 U.S.C. § 2009cc, or as a small business investment company under

15 U.S.C. § 681, and a certificate executed by an executive officer of the applicant attesting that

the license remains in effect and has not been revoked;

     (3) Evidence that, as of the date the application is submitted, the applicant or affiliates of

the applicant have invested at least one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000) in nonpublic

companies;

     (4) An estimate of the number of jobs that will be created or retained in this state as a

result of the applicant's qualified investments;

     (5) A business plan that includes a strategy for reaching out to and investing in minority

business enterprises and a revenue impact assessment projecting state and local tax revenue to be

generated by the applicant's proposed qualified investment prepared by a nationally recognized,

third-party, independent economic forecasting firm using a dynamic economic forecasting model

that analyzes the applicant's business plan over the ten (10) years following the date the

application is submitted to the department; and

     (6) A nonrefundable application fee of five thousand dollars ($5,000), payable to the

department.

     (b) Within thirty (30) days after receipt of a completed application, the department shall

grant or deny the application in full or in part. The department shall deny the application if:

     (1) The applicant does not satisfy all of the criteria described in subsection (a) of this

section;

     (2) The revenue impact assessment submitted with the application does not demonstrate

that the applicant's business plan will result in a positive economic impact on this state over a ten

(10) year period that exceeds the cumulative amount of tax credits that would be issued to the

LC000477 - Page 5 of 11

applicant if the application were approved; or

     (3) The department has already approved the maximum amount of capital investment

authority under subsection (g) of this section.

     (c) If the department denies any part of the application, it shall inform the applicant of the

grounds for the denial. If the applicant provides any additional information required by the

department or otherwise completes its application within fifteen (15) days of the notice of denial,

the application shall be considered completed as of the original date of submission. If the

applicant fails to provide the information or fails to complete its application within the fifteen

(15) day period, the application remains denied and must be resubmitted in full with a new

submission date.

     (d) If the application is complete, the department shall certify the proposed equity

investment as a capital investment that is eligible for credits under this chapter, subject to the

limitations contained in subsection (g) of this section. The department shall provide written notice

of the certification to the small business development fund.

     (e) The department shall certify capital investments in the order that the applications were

received by the department. Applications received on the same day shall be deemed to have been

received simultaneously.

     (f) For applications that are complete and received on the same day, the department shall

certify applications in proportionate percentages based upon the ratio of the amount of capital

investments requested in an application to the total amount of capital investments requested in all

applications.

     (g) The department shall certify sixty-five million dollars ($65,000,000) in capital

investments pursuant to this section; provided that not more than twenty million dollars

($20,000,000) may be allocated to any individual small business development fund certified

under this section.

     (h) Within sixty (60) days of the applicant receiving notice of certification, the small

business development fund shall issue the capital investment to and receive cash in the amount of

the certified amount from a small business fund investor. At least forty-five percent (45%) of the

small business fund investor's capital investment shall be composed of capital raised by the small

business fund investor from sources, including directors, members, employees, officers, and

affiliates of the small business fund investor, other than the amount of capital invested by the

allocatee claiming the tax credits in exchange for the allocation of tax credits; provided that at

least ten percent (10%) of the capital investment shall be derived from the small business

investment fund's managers. The small business development fund shall provide the department

LC000477 - Page 6 of 11

with evidence of the receipt of the cash investment within sixty-five (65) days of the applicant

receiving notice of certification. If the small business development fund does not receive the cash

investment and issue the capital investment within the time period following receipt of the

certification notice, the certification shall lapse and the small business development fund shall not

issue the capital investment without reapplying to the department for certification. Lapsed

certifications revert to the authority and shall be reissued pro rata to applicants whose capital

investment allocations were reduced pursuant to this chapter and then in accordance with the

application process.

     42-64.33-5. Tax credit recapture and exit.

     (a) The department may recapture, from a small business fund investor that claimed the

credit on a tax return, the credit allowed under this chapter if:

     (1) The small business development fund does not invest one hundred (100%) percent of

its capital investment authority in qualified investments in this state within three (3) years of the

first credit allowance date;

     (2) The small business development fund, after satisfying subsection (a)(1) of this

section, fails to maintain qualified investments equal to one hundred (100%) percent of its capital

investment authority until the sixth anniversary of the initial credit allowance date. For the

purposes of this subsection, a qualified investment is considered maintained even if the qualified

investment was sold or repaid so long as the small business development fund reinvests an

amount equal to the capital returned or recovered by the small business development fund from

the original investment, exclusive of any profits realized, in other qualified investments in this

state within twelve (12) months of the receipt of the capital. Amounts received periodically by a

small business development fund shall be treated as continually invested in qualified investments

if the amounts are reinvested in one or more qualified investments by the end of the following

calendar year. A small business development fund shall not be required to reinvest capital

returned from qualified investments after the fifth anniversary of the initial credit allowance date,

and the qualified investments shall be considered held continuously by the small business

development fund through the sixth anniversary of the initial credit allowance date;

     (3) The small business development fund, before exiting the program in accordance with

subsection (e) of this section, makes a distribution or payment that results in the small business

development fund having less than one hundred percent (100%) of its capital investment

authority invested in qualified investments in this state or available for investment in qualified

investments and held in cash and other marketable securities;

     (4) The small business development fund, before exiting the program in accordance with

LC000477 - Page 7 of 11

subsection (e) of this section, fails to make qualified investments in minority business enterprises

that when added together equal at least ten percent (10%) of the small business development

fund's capital investment authority; or

     (5) The small business development fund violates subsection (d) of this section.

     (b) Recaptured credits and the related capital investment authority revert to the

department and shall be reissued pro rata to applicants whose capital investment allocations were

reduced pursuant to § 42-64.33-4(f) of this section and then in accordance with the application

process.

     (c) Enforcement of each of the recapture provisions of subsection (a) of this section shall

be subject to a six (6) month cure period. No recapture shall occur until the small business

development fund has been given notice of noncompliance and afforded six (6) months from the

date of the notice to cure the noncompliance.

     (d) No eligible business that receives a qualified investment under this chapter, or any

affiliates of the eligible business, may directly or indirectly:

     (1) Own or have the right to acquire an ownership interest in a small business

development fund or member or affiliate of a small business development fund, including, but not

limited to, a holder of a capital investment issued by the small business development fund; or

     (2) Loan to or invest in a small business development fund or member or affiliate of a

small business development fund, including, but not limited to, a holder of a capital investment

issued by a small business development fund, where the proceeds of the loan or investment are

directly or indirectly used to fund or refinance the purchase of a capital investment under this

chapter.

     (e) On or after the sixth anniversary of the initial credit allowance date, a small business

development fund may apply to the department to exit the program and no longer be subject to

regulation under this chapter. The department shall respond to the exit application within thirty

(30) days of receipt. In evaluating the exit application, the fact that no credits have been

recaptured and that the small business development fund has not received a notice of recapture

that has not been cured pursuant to subsection (c) of this section shall be sufficient evidence to

prove that the small business development fund is eligible for exit. The department shall not

unreasonably deny an exit application submitted under this subsection. If the exit application is

denied, the notice shall include the reasons for the determination.

     (f) If the number of jobs created or retained by the eligible businesses that received

qualified investments from the small business development fund, calculated pursuant to reports

filed by the small business development fund pursuant to § 42-64.33-7, is:

LC000477 - Page 8 of 11

     (1) Less than sixty percent (60%) of the amount projected in the approved small business

development fund's business plan filed as part of its application for certification under § 42-

64.33-4, then the state shall receive thirty percent (30%) of any distribution or payment to an

equity holder in an approved small business development fund in excess of eligible distributions;

or

     (2) Greater than sixty percent (60%) but less than one hundred percent (100%) of the

amount projected in the approved small business development fund's business plan filed as part of

its application for certification under § 42-64.33-4, then the state shall receive fifteen percent

(15%) of any distribution or payment to an equity holder in an approved small business

development fund in excess of eligible distributions.

     (g) At the time a small business development fund applies to the department to exit the

program, it shall calculate the aggregate internal rate of return of its qualified investments. If the

small business development fund's aggregate internal rate of return on its qualified investments at

exit exceeds ten percent (10%), then, after eligible distributions, the state shall receive ten percent

(10%) of any distribution or payment in excess of the aggregate ten percent (10%) internal rate of

return to an equity holder in an approved small business development fund.

     (h) The department shall not revoke a tax credit certificate after the small business

development fund's exit from the program.

     42-64.33-6. Request for determination.

     A small business development fund, before making a qualified investment, may request

from the department a written opinion as to whether the business in which it is proposed to invest

is an eligible business. The department, not later than the fifteenth business day after the date of

receipt of the request, shall notify the small business development fund of its determination. If the

department fails to notify the small business development fund by the fifteenth business day of its

determination, the business in which the small business development fund proposes to invest shall

be considered an eligible business.

     42-64.33-7. Reporting obligations.

     (a) Each small business development fund shall submit a report to the department and the

division of taxation on or before the fifth business day after the third anniversary of the closing

date. The report shall provide documentation as to the small business development fund's

qualified investments and include:

     (1) A bank statement evidencing each qualified investment;

     (2) The name, location, status as a minority business enterprise if applicable, and industry

of each business receiving a qualified investment, including either the determination letter set

LC000477 - Page 9 of 11

forth in § 42-64.33-6 or evidence that the business qualified as an eligible business at the time the

investment was made; and

     (3) The number of employment positions created or retained as a result of the small

business development fund's qualified investments as of the last day of the preceding calendar

year;

     (b) On or before the last day of February of each year following the year in which the

report required in subsection (a) of this section is due, the small business development fund shall

submit an annual report to the department and the division of taxation including the following:

     (1) The number of employment positions created or retained as a result of the small

business development fund's qualified investments as of the last day of the preceding calendar

year;

     (2) The number of minority business enterprises that have received qualified investments

and the amount of qualified investment that such minority business enterprises have received;

     (3) The average annual salary of the positions described in subsection (b)(1) of this

section; and

     (4) The follow-on capital investment that has occurred along with or after the small

business development fund's investment as of the last day of the preceding calendar year.

     (c) A copy of the reports required under this section must also be sent concurrently to the

speaker of the house, president of the senate, house finance chairperson, senate finance

chairperson, and the general treasurer.

     42-64.33-8. Rules and regulations.

     The department and division of taxation may issue reasonable rules and regulations,

consistent with this chapter, as are necessary to carry out the intent and purpose and

implementation of the responsibilities under this chapter.

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

========

LC000477

========

LC000477 - Page 10 of 11

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N   A C T

RELATING TO STATE AFFAIRS AND GOVERNMENT - ESTABLISHING A SMALL

BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT FUND

***

     This act would establish a small business development fund designed to encourage the

formation of private capital investment by federally licensed investment companies in

underserved small businesses, leveraged by delayed, at-risk stream of tax credits applicable

against insurance premium and retaliatory taxes that can be recaptured for noncompliance with

program investment requirements. Monetary penalties would exist if job creation and retention

projections would be missed, and the state shares in profits above a certain level of fund returns.

Investments would be designated for targeted growth industries for the state, and would be

required to be diversified – no one small business would receive more than four ($4,000,000)

million or twenty percent (20%) of a fund's investment authority. The investment funds would

report annually, and the program would terminate after six (6) years.

     This act would take effect upon passage.

========

LC000477

========

LC000477 - Page 11 of 11